There are NO Simple Answers Because CONTEXT MATTERS!

If you’ve been following along, over the past few months we’ve had to complain about:

While these may seem like completely different situations that have to be (continually) (re)addressed on their own merits, they really aren’t. They are all interconnected (and taken together they help to define the 88%+ technical project failure rate in our ProcureTech space) and all have the one of the same issues at the core. They all try to oversimplify, which is something you cannot do in any field of technology because CONTEXT MATTERS!

Analyst Firm and Influencer Maps and flashy graphical comparisons on a few randomly selected “data points” are useless because context matters. You can’t create a shortlist of potential solutions without understanding, at a minimum:

  • who the company is and what the department does
  • the platform and skill topography
  • the problems that the existing topography is not solving

Because sourcing is not sourcing is not sourcing, procurement is not procurement is not procurement, and analytics is not analytics is not analytics. Indirect Finished Goods vs Direct Materials vs Services are sourced differently; catalogs vs. one-time buys vs. on-contract inventory replenishments are handled completely differently; and there’s reports vs drill down cubes vs data federation, and each brings different insights. APIs, interface, and integration requirements differ on platforms, core vs. nice to have shift based upon what’s in the ERP, AP, and SCP systems. And the maturity level has a great impact on what will, vs. will not, be used.

It’s NOT SIMPLE! And anytime someone says “keep it simple, just give them a list”, it means they don’t understand the reality of the situation and that, while it is not complex, not hard (and yes, Procurement can be really easy), it’s NOT simple. Context is needed to make the right recommendations and right decisions.

There is NO Autonomous AI Agent and anyone peddling one is selling the new silicon snake oil. (First of all, remember that there’s no such thing as Artificial Intelligence, and it’s still the case that since a computer can’t take responsibility for a critical decision, it should NOT make one.) For an agent to be autonomous, it would need to have, or be able to retrieve, all the data it needs, connect with all relevant internal and external systems, get information not on the web through traditional means (ask people), verify truth from lies, have the ability to adapt to any situation, and the intelligence to know when a decision can be made and when it can’t. Not only does it not have the intelligence, but no software agent in existence meets the rest of these requirements either. (The best that can be created is a support agent that can do all of the data processing, standard analysis, workflow automation, and decision suggestion using Augmented Intelligence that allows it to act as a useful personal assistant that multiplies your productivity. But ONLY if the Agent has the right context — and guess what, YOU have to work with a partner to custom build that agent with YOUR context. It won’t be delivered out of the box and magically trained just by feeding it your data. The myth of emergence has already been debunked. Please stop falling for it.)

There is no Best-In-Class process or methodology guaranteed to work for you. Unless you are lifting it from a company in the same business buying and selling the same products for the same consumer base that is structured the same way and more-or-less does the same thing as you, that best-in-class process or methodology may not even be close to what you need (and no amount of adaptation will get you there). Best-in-Class always works within a context (which includes your maturity level as an organization), and until that is understood, no consultant or analyst can make the right recommendations for where you are today.

So next time someone says it’s simple, and that their map, chart, or infographic will solve all your problems — delete it, because unless they also take the time to qualify the context in which that map, chart, or infographic applies, it is worse than useless for you (and doubly so if it presents a dangerous and dysfunctional dashboard) and may even cause organizational damage if blindly followed.

Finally, just remember, just because it ain’t simple, that doesn’t mean it ain’t easy. It just requires a bit of brainpower and effort to get it right, and, moreover, an amount thereof that is well within our capability!