Category Archives: Forecasts

Can We Harness the Wisdom of Crowds in Supply Chain Forecasting?

How Do We Harness the Wisdom of Crowds in Supply Chain Forecasting? A little over two years ago, I posed this question to you. I got a few responses, mostly private, who were thankful that I pointed out that you cannot just blindly follow the wisdom of just any old crowd, because expert judgements often demonstrate logically inconsistent results, but not a lot of advice on how we could successfully approach the task of integrating the wisdom that crowds could provide in our supply chain processes. The reason that we wanted to tackle this problem is because it is true that teams of forecasters often generate better results (and decisions) than individuals as long as the teams include a sufficient degree of diversity of information and perspectives.

But this is the caveat. The wisdom of crowds only holds if the crowd is large enough to contain the necessary diversity of information and perspectives in a statistically significant way. In other words, you will need a lot of people, and these people will need to be from diverse backgrounds and possess diverse skill-sets. But even this might not be enough in some situations.

As pointed out in this great blog post over on the World Future Society blogs by Thomas Frey from last August on The False Wisdom of Crowds, the decision between flying on a plane piloted by a single AI or the combined intelligence of 3,000 people is not as simple as you think. While it is true that the combined IQ and skill-set of 3,000 people is much greater than any AI on the planet, as you Next Generation Trekkies aware of the quick adaptability of the Borg will be quick to point out, it is also true that if all 3,000 of these people are farmers from the MidWest, it is likely the case that not one of them will know how to fly a plane! In contrast, the AI might be the best autopilot software in the industry, successfully used problem-free on tens of thousands of flights. The only way you’d beat that is if you had a collective of 3,000 of the best airline pilots in the industry. But the statistical likelihood of selecting that crowd from the global population is astronomical.

As Drew Curtis, founder of Fark.com, points out, “Crowds are dumb. The reality is that, while people are very good at knowing what they personally want, they are generally very bad at understanding the truths of the world around [them]. If you want proof, consider the examples given by Thomas and Drew, which include:

  • In the ’50’s, it was common knowledge that if a nuclear bomb went off in your city, you’d be safe if you simply learned to “duck and cover”.
  • Until 2007, it was a well-known fact that real-estate was a great investment where you would virtually never lose money.
  • Only once percent of Web comments have any value and the rest are just garbage.

In other words, diversity is not enough. You need expertise. And you need the right expertise. But as pointed out in SI’s post from 2010 and Thomas’ blog post, ‘social influence’ diminishes the range of opinions and tends to lead crowds in the direction chosen by the most respected and/or socially powerful individuals. So you have to gather data from a “blind crowd” that cannot see each other.

In other words, when you put it all together you need:

  • diversity, as addressed in our previous post,
  • privacy, as partially addressed in our previous post,
  • expertise, as demonstrated by Thomas’ blog, and
  • statistical significance, as not adequately addressed yet.

Taken together, these requirements pose a bit of a problem, which is made clear in Thomas’ post where he quotes a recent study by McKinsey and Company that calculated an immediate shortage in the US of almost 200,000 people with analytical expertise and 1.5 million managers and decision makers with the skills to understand and make decisions based on the analyses provided by the analytical experts. Overall, we’re starving for expertise in Supply Chain, as evidenced by the fact that less than 10% of companies truly employ advanced sourcing techniques! The average company just doesn’t have enough people to meet the diversity, expertise, and statistical significance required to guarantee that a crowd decision will be better than the decision of their “leading expert” in that area. And since most firms don’t want to share expertise, sourcing processes, or suppliers, especially where strategic or high-value categories are concerned, they’ve essentially cut-off external sources of expertise. The result: beyond non-strategic / low-value categories they would be willing to hand off to a GPO, their chances of truly harvesting the wisdom of crowds for many Supply Management processes are low, at best — and this leads us to wonder if we really can harness the wisdom of crowds in supply chain forecasting in practice.

New Thoughts? Comments? Criticisms?

Supply Chain Planner — Here are Three Solutions to Nearly Every Problem

A recent piece over on Supply Chain Cowboy on “Three Silver Bullets to Solve Nearly Every Supply Chain Fire” simultaneously enthralled and shocked me because I cringe every time I hear that air freight is one of the three solutions to your current supply chain dilemma, as it is a prime indicator of a major supply chain issue — specifically, lack of planning.

But there are ways to avoid the issue. The first one is:

Supply Chain Forecasting Systems

A good, modern, supply chain forecasting system is the best way to figure out not only what you are going to need, but when you are going to need it and when you are going to have to get the orders in and production started in order to meet shipping deadlines and avoid the need for air freight.

The second way to avoid the issue is:

Supply Chain Visibility

(Near) real-time visibility into where your stuff is from your suppliers, their suppliers, and their raw-material suppliers. All delays have ripple effects, and the best way to prevent a hiccup, or disruption, that will force you to have to use air-freight is to have real-time visibility all the way through your supply chain so you can be aware of a potential issue as soon as it happens.

And the third silver bullet, I’m sad to say, is:

Standby Air Freight

Good forecasting will significantly reduce the number of emergencies and the number of times you have to ship air-freight to meet a deadline, and good supply chain visibility will reduce this number even further as you will be able to order from secondary suppliers or ship through back-up carriers when hiccups or disruptions do arise to meet the deadlines laid out in your forecasting system. That being said, no technology will completely eliminate the need. There will always be unexpected events that will cause interruptions at the last minute where the only recovery option is to air freight reserve stock. If the Super Panamax ship gets delayed a week in port because of customs issues after your cargo is loaded, there’s nothing you can do. Or if a second tier supplier gets cut off because of a civil uprising and you have to arrange for the first tier supplier to get replacement product from another second tier supplier further away, there may be no other way to get the product fast enough. That being said, the number of instances where there is no way but up should be few and far between with good supply chain planning and visibility systems.

How Not to Excel at Forecasting

Simply put, use Microsoft Excel. It’s appalling that a recent survey by ToolsGroup and the Global Market Development Centre (GDMC) found that even though two-thirds of companies in the consumer goods supply chain consider demand volatility and forecast accuracy a high businesses priority, half still rely on Excel spreadsheets for forecasting.

Relying on Excel for forecasting is like relying on:

  • a Longship to get you across the Atlantic
  • your first guess on Let’s Make a Deal to be the right one
  • a shareholder proxy getting on the ballot at a Fortune 500
  • Florida surviving a hurricane season without any major city suffering damage
  • the price of fuel going down and staying down for an upcoming series of spot buys
  • natural resource supply to be consistent and predictable year-over-year
  • a flip of a fair coin to come up heads seven times in a row

Now, it’s true that:

  • the Vikings did make it across the Atlantic in a Longship, but a single storm could sink it
  • the first door you pick, with one-in-three odds, could be the right one, but the odds are actually twice as good if you switch
  • an activist shareholder can sometimes get a proxy on the ballot if he or she has enough time and money, but as pointed out by John Gillespie and David Zweig in Money for Nothing (How the Failure of Corporate Boards is Ruining American Business and Costing Us Trillions), examples are few and far between
  • even though no storms made landfall in Florida in 2011, this is Not a common occurrence
  • gas prices did consistently drop in the USA between September 2008 and December 2008, but have been otherwise steadily rising for the last five years
  • in some years the rice, sugar, and corn crops are almost the same as in the previous year, but given the increase in hurricanes, tsunamis, droughts, and other natural disasters in recent years, this is not a common occurrence
  • yes, heads can come up seven times in a row when flipping a fair coin, but the chances of this happening are less than 1%

In other words, you can forecast with Microsoft Excel, but your chances of doing well, especially given that 90% of spreadsheets have non-trivial errors (and collectively cost enterprises billions, as Fidelity and Fannie Mae found out), are (vanishingly) small (as the complexity of the forecast increases). One has to remember that there’s no intelligence behind a spreadsheet and they are just a source of peril that can cost your organization millions without anyone noticing.

World Trade 100’s Logistics Trends for 2012 — Do They Have Weight? Part II

Yesterday, we reviewed the seven trends for 2012 that World Trade identified for the logistics sector in a recent article and asked if they had weight. Today, we answer that question by presenting the reality (that SI perceives) with respect to these trends.

  • Buyers are expecting 3PLs to be the new Jack-of-all-Trades.
    While some of the larger organizations are adapting to their clients’ requests, this won’t hold true in all cases. Only where the requests are for services similar to what the 3PL is already offering and where the 3PL has the necessary expertise will the 3PL be able to successfully offer the service for the long term. As a result, some 3PLs will falter (and maybe even fail) and, ultimately, retrench on their strengths and smarter buyers will seek solutions from the right partners. (Going to the supplier to handle packaging, a best-of-breed software provider for a visibility solution, etc.) The 3PL as the Jack-of-all-Trades trend will be short-lived.
  • Mobility is King, the Cloud is irrelevant.
    Call it ASP, SaaS, Cloud, or Web 3.0 — smart buyers don’t care. They just want a solution that works on the go. They’ll settle for what works, and won’t be satisfied with who has the most buzzwords in their product description. That being said, buyers still on the learning curve may fall for “cloud” in the short term, but if they don’t get results, the services provider will wish they were up in the clouds far from the angry buyers’ reach!
  • Transportation is going back to intermodal.
    The trucking phenomenon is over. The value proposition of intermodal rail can no longer be ignored.
  • Capacity is climbing up the issues list — fast!
    Regulations and lack-of-drivers are severely limiting available capacity, air capacity is also limited, and low-cost ocean routes are not going to last forever. As a result, smart buyers always have an eye on capacity.
  • The rate of system/data integration is going to increase.
    As visibility is a necessity in today’s supply chain. Execution integration will also improve as lean and JIT continues to be applied to the logistics chain. But business integration will take time. Trust, and undisputable business cases, will have to lead the way.
  • Near-Sourcing will happen.
    The value proposition is back, and, like the value proposition of intermodal transportation, it can’t be ignored. It will take time, as you can’t switch suppliers, or end multi-year contracts, over night, but it will happen.
  • Sustainability will continue to lag.
    The reality is that at least 8, if not 9, out of 10 companies only tackle sustainability when forced to do so by regulation or pressured by customers. Very few tackle it for the long-term benefits it can provide an organization because, with the relentless Wall-Street focus on profit quarter-after-quarter, an average organization does not want to bear the up-front cost, no matter how great the potential year-over-year reward in the long-term.

And, most importantly, you’re going to see the following trend start to take shape later this year:

  • A renewed investment in logistics/inventory management/optimization software
    Leading, and better-than-average, organizations are not going to be content to let their 3PLs manage logistics after the fact, when most of the cost has already been locked in, but use advanced software to make sourcing decisions that, when sensible, optimize logistics and inventory costs up-front. Like all sourcing technology trends, it may take a year to pick up steam, but it’s going to happen. Too much money is on the line.

That’s what the doctor thinks. Any divergent opinions?

World Trade 100’s Logistics Trends for 2012 — Do They Have Weight? Part I

Earlier this year, World Trade identified the following seven trends for 2012. The question is, how many are taking shape and, of the ones taking shape, how many are relevant for your supply chain. And are any missing? Let’s start by examining the seven trends WT identified.

  • 3PLs are the new Jack-of-all-Trades
    Apparently, demand for 3PLs to play a role in capacity strategies, to provide technologies that optimize planning and enable visibility in increasingly complex global supply chains, and to increase operational agility is increasing. In addition, some shippers are seeking to consolidate their 3PL bases to relieve an administrative burden of managing multiple providers while leveraging a larger, indirect spend pool. And, some 3PLs are offering more value-added services such as contract and custom packaging, return disposal, and even individual store deliveries.
  • Mobility and the Cloud
    The use of M2M technology is increasing, and more software providers are certifying the use of their solutions for off-the-shelf consumer and ruggedized devices. And some are predicting that 2012 will be a big year for “cloud supply chain”. Supply chain technology vendors will seek ways to use the cloud to facilitate application integration and data visibility, and work with material handling equipment manufacturers to bring MHE automation closer to real world application.
  • Transportation Modes
    There will be more adoption of intermodal transport. This is because trucking faces predicted driver shortages, potential highway user fees, and changing governmental regulations — which is making intermodal rail an increasingly compelling proposition. As a result, new intermodal facilities are being built in several U.S. locations. This option can reduce fuel costs, increase delivery speed, and decrease reliance on OTR (Over-the-Road) trucking.
  • Trucking & Capacity Issues
    New compliance mandates for trucking, including CSA (Carrier Safety Administration) and HOS (Hours of Service) legislation, will further increase capacity challenges in 2012.
  • Partner Integration
    Disparate supply chain players will come together to form partnerships and work together to benefit the entire supply chain. This is because smarter commerce requires seamless integration with all partners in the end-to-end supply chain, particularly in the complex global supply chains of today. Furthermore, the expectation is that this partnership will span the business, execution, and technology layers of the supply chain.
  • Near-Sourcing
    There is an expectation that near-sourcing will likely increase, helped by unstable oil prices, rising labor costs in China (and India), the cross-border trucking program with Mexico, and NAFTA. Plus, Central and South America (and Brazil in particular), which are often on similar time-zones, are also viable sourcing options in many industries, and reachable through land-based inter-modal transport.
  • Sustainability
    According to the article, Sustainability will continue to be a focus for shippers and carriers alike, as long as there is a business benefit.

Not a bad list of trends, and some good arguments for. But what is the reality (that SI perceives)? Stay Tuned for Part II!