Category Archives: Forecasts

Where is Global Trade’s Groove?

A recent headline over on the World Trade Magazine site that asked whether or not global trade still has its groove got my attention because, even though the global economy tanked from 2008 to 2010, a lot of leading companies are focussed on accelerating the development of Global Business Services centers (which was one of the foci of the recent Hackett Group Best Practices conference) in order to take advantage of lower labour rates in other parts of the world. Plus, I haven’t seen any drop in services outsourcing to India or product manufacturing outsourcing to China. And there has been a resurgence in interest (though not necessarily much in the way of action yet) in moving or creating new manufacturing locations in Mexico and Brazil by US (and even European) companies. So while Global Trade may not have grown as fast as we were predicting back in 2008 before the global recession, it does not appear to have taken any backwards steps by any stretch of the imagination.

Nevertheless, it’s always good to check the pulse. The article addressed the question from a risk, optimism, and emerging market viewpoint.

Risk
The eruption of Eyjafjallajokull in Iceland, the disaster in Japan, and the political upheavals in Egypt, Libya, Bahrain, Algeria, and even Albania are placing risk front and center in the Supply Management landscape. Plus, the consistently high price of oil, which could go even higher due to the instability of oil-exporting countries, puts global sourcing of certain goods at risk as the cost of transportation could soon make some global buys unaffordable. In addition, as more of the household budget goes towards fuel, consumers will have to spend less on unnecessary consumer goods. Then we have price increases across certain categories of raw materials as countries like China implement quotas on rare earth metals and create global supply constraints.

Optimism
The article has an interesting quote from Carlos Rice, Vice President of Supply Chain Services for Crowley Logistics who says that we’ve seen an upturn in the economy recently and we are watching the emergence of new markets — not only in India and greater China — but closer to home in Central and South America. What is happening with Brazil’s economy today is almost unprecedented. So, we see lots of opportunities not just east-to-west, but also north-to-south as well. Plus, there has been continuous growth in the trans-Pacific and Asia-to-Europe markets for some logistics carriers, balance is returning to many global trade lanes, and some carriers are seeing up to 20% growth in logistics to emerging markets that are creating a consistent demand for commodities. The expectation is that container trade will be at upper single-digit growth as a whole.

Emerging Markets
Adrian Gonzalez, director of Logistics Viewpoints, notes that the traditional economic powers like the U.S., Japan, China, and Germany are all looking at other developing areas as opportunities for future growth and you see these countries starting out first as sources of low-cost labor in much the same way as China began its development. Then you see the development of a middle class that begins buying products. And we have the situation where countries like China and India are now able to grow and thrive independently of richer countries. In fact, the World Bank states that developing economies were responsible for 45% of world growth in 2010.

So what’s the projected return on equity (ROE) for those invested in global trade? According to Paul Bingham, economics practice leader at Wilbur Smith Associates, barring another unexpected calamity, the [logistics] industry anticipates a slow yet steady global economic recovery. Right now, about 20% of what comanies manufacture is consumed in other parts of the world. Carlos Rice expects that this number will grow to 80% in the next 10 years or so. I personally think this is a bit ambitous with the high price of fuel, but don’t doubt that it will continue to rise as multi-nationals find new low-cost locales to produce in and new markets to sell it. I think the big difference is that there will be more near-sourcing from neighboring countries, or at least countries on the same continent, than there will be global sourcing from locations halfway around the world. What do you think?

S&OP Must Be Integrated “Within and Across” The Organization

Proper Sales and Operations Planning (S&OP) is critical to supply chain success. If the forecasts are low, the organization stocks out and loses sales (and profits). If the forecasts are high, the organization gets stuck with excess inventory, that soon becomes obsolete (and that has to be sold at a loss just to move it). Supply chain success comes from accurate forecasts, which requires good Sales & Operational Planning.

But S&OP is more than just getting the product line managers to sit in a room and agree on a forecast, and it’s more than using good modelling and simulation software (which is a must). Proper S&OP planning is getting sales & marketing and operations (& product line management) together in a room working collaboratively towards a realistic and trustworthy forecast. All of these conditions are necessary.

1. It is not S&OP if you do not invite sales and marketing.
You can have the best forecasting models and software in the world, but they are still useless without the right demand data, which is only going to come from sales & marketing who can tell you what is selling and what changes in the market are likely to lead to increases or decreases in demand.

2. It is not S&OP if you are not working together as a cohesive group.
Just being in the same room is not enough. Both teams must be working towards the same goal, must believe in the process, and must trust the capabilities and insights of the other team. Just like operations must trust sales and marketing to provide real POS data and demand projections based on current campaigns and the state of the market, sales and marketing must trust that operations can build good models based on the data and schedule production and distribution accordingly.

Good examples of how not meeting these conditions can lead to failure are provided in Dr. Terry Esper’s recent article in the Supply Chain Management Review on Demand and Supply Integration: “Within and Across” Integration – The Key to DSI. Despite the introduction of yet another acronym to our space (DSI), and a bit of a long-winded introduction to the issue, it makes some good points and is definitely worth a read. It also provides three ideas to help you create a more cohesive S&OP team and process, which are worth noting:

  • Better Performance Measures
    the performance measures must facilitate integration
  • Ownership Structure
    there must be ownership of the S&OP process that includes both sides of the table
  • Corporate Leadership
    there must be leadership attention and focus on integration

Cross-Functional Tactical Planning Matters

Because if you don’t get tactical planning right, you cannot align cross-functionally, as pointed out in a post over on Supply Chain Shaman by Lora Cecere who said Enough!

So how do you get tactical planning right? According to Laura, you need to address four attributes:

  • Assessment
    Tactical planning aligns functions beyond the enterprise with market drivers and insights using outside-in thinking. It goes beyond a corporate silo.
  • Action
    The team must be knowledgeable and have the authority of line management to act.
  • Accuracy
    Companies need to have access to the right data model and recognize the different value networks because one model does not fit all supply chains. The appropriate risks and opportunities are only identified when tactical options for a strategy are evaluated against market drivers.
  • Timeliness
    Analysis needs to happen within a finite window of actionability.

Then you have to understand the success requirements. According to Laura, to be successful you need to first answer three questions:

  1. What is the goal?
    Good tactical outcomes cannot be reached if the company is not aligned on the strategy. The goal has to be well understood.
  2. What does good look like?
    How are incentives aligned cross-functionally to achieve the goal? The answer is more than rewarding organizations for the same-old same-old.
  3. What are our risks and opportunities?
    Has a proper sensitivity analysis been performed? Has the right data been used?

Once you have the answers, you can start proper planning. Until then, the questions need to be addressed and re-addressed until they are understood.

Why Your Supply Chain Needs To Be Flexible

Thanks to economics, your forecasts will be right only 30% to 40% of the time, as per this recent article over on BBC News that asks why do economists get it so wrong. Whether you care to admit it or not, all forecasts implicitly assume that the general economic condition will stay the same, since that determines not only how much money your potential customers will have, but how much they will be willing to spend. But since the foundation of the economy — humans, resources, wars, natural disasters, technology, etc — are in a constant state of change and flux, all of the models used to describe the economy are flawed.

Thus, your forecasts are only likely to be right at the macro level. Since nearly every economic forecast will be right at some point, every product line forecast will be right at some point, but like a broken clock, may only display the correct volume 0.13% of the time. If you have years of past behaviour, you’ll be able to create a good forecast at the macro (year) level, but it will get less and less reliable as the time period shrinks, no matter how much you throw into your model. That’s why you need an adaptive and flexible supply chain that allows for relatively quick replenishment — so you can ramp up production and distribution when you need to, but not have too much inventory on hand when you don’t.

Why It’s Time to Take that Leap of Faith

Lora Cecere, of the Altimeter Group, just published a great piece on the Supply Chain Shaman blog on why it’s time to take a leap of faith as far as using POS data to drive actionable replenishment is concerned. Yes, it’s time to move from PUSH to PULL using real demand and insight and not just seat-of-the-pants forecasts.

The post, which is over 2,100 words in length, is too in-depth to do justice in a short summarization, so I won’t try, but I will point out a few keen observations that often go overlooked in most discussions and add one or two of my own.

First of all, as Lora keenly points out, you can’t prove ROI for an initiative before the initiative is done, which means if you want a proven ROI, you can’t be an innovator … and the big returns in this space will go to the innovators, not the renovators. You have to take that leap of faith.

There aren’t a lot of predictive analytic solutions on the market, but there really don’t need to be. If you get better data faster, you can re-run and correct your forecasts on a regular basis and minimize the the divergence between macro-level estimates and reality. That alone could save you millions.

You have to get close to the customer and get good at using the data in the sales relationship. If you don’t get close to the customer, learn their pain points, and figure out how you can use their data to help them, they’re not going to be that interested in helping you get access to it on a regular basis.

You have to build a cross-functional team led by business unit leaders focussed on innovation, or the initiative isn’t going to pick up enough momentum to make it. You have to break through mental barriers built up over years, or decades, of doing forecasting and inventory planning a certain way, and that’s not easy to overcome.

However, if you follow Lora’s advice, the rewards could be significant as stockpiles of obsolete inventory will quickly become a thing of the past. More importantly, and this is the one point the article should have really emphasized, so will costly long-term stock-outs. If you have access to daily POS data, you will not only see what is selling fast, and what’s not, but you’ll be able to run cluster analysis to see what products are selling well in what locales, and how the demand is spreading (outward or inward). This will not only allow you to quickly refill inventory on a popular, high-margin, item like a cellular phone or tablet PC, at a location about to run out, but predict which neighbouring locations should also be stocked up, and sense demand surges earlier in the cycle, giving you more time to ramp up production to prevent lost sales that could make or break the quarter.