Category Archives: Supply Chain

What can we learn from Keiretsu? (Strategic Supply Management)

Keiretsu, which can be briefly described as a long continual business relationship, in one way or another has been a significant force in the Japanese economy for over sixty years and despite its long and varied history, criticisms, the Structural Impediments Initiative, and economic downturns, is still a strong foundation for many supply chain relationships in Japan.

“Japan’s Keiretsu as a Strategic Relationship with Suppliers”Therefore, even though some economists would argue that it contradicts the basic principles of the free trade of capital, there must be something to it. Therefore, I think the issue is worth exploring, with the goal of taking away lessons that can be used to improve our supply relationships, especially considering that current markets and supply chains are now filled with volatility and risk. And a great starting point is , a study released by the CAPS Center for Strategic Supply Research Supply Management Research Group last year.

The report indicates that a Keiretsu relationship can be defined as a series of repetitive transactions that occur long term between two or more entities in an asymmetrical relationship where one entity uses its position to govern the relationship. A Keiretsu relationship is based on a close and stable business collaboration between affiliated entities. There are different forms of the relationship, and the term is difficult to narrowly define, but all forms center on a long continual business relationship.

This report, which points out that Keiretsu has a long and varied history starting in world war two, covers the major evolutions over the last six decades and notes that changes in the competitive corporate environment leads to diversity in the Keiretsu system. Sometimes external circumstances force a company to end or restrict some of their Keiretsu subordinates if the relationship did not meet the demands of the increased competition and other times a company could use the circumstances to its advantage to work within the confines of its Keiretsu relationships to increase its competitive edge.

Keiretsu relationships in Japan generally display a number of common features:

  • long-term trade relationships that often prevent third parties from participating freely in the market;
    although this can stifle free-trade relationships that depend on competition, this can also create excellent economic efficiencies and make sense among companies that specialize in a particular product
  • companies often hold significant amounts of each other’s stock to prevent other companies from acquiring shares;
    although this seems to contradict the basic principles of the free trade of capital, this can create stability in the stock market and provides protection against hostile takeovers
  • fixed non-symmetrical trade between companies
  • “dispatching” executives into the Keiretsu
    it is such a common practice, once a parent company’s executive or chief executive retires, to dispatch that person to another company in the Keiretsu that it is a defining characteristic of Japanese Keiretsu
  • supplementation and replacement through business sharing;
    a parent company, with cooperation of the subcompany, establishes guidance systems governing production technology and quality control methodology

Furthermore, Keiretsu is often established to

  • move low-value-add production to subsidiaries
  • ensure continuous high quality production capability to avoid excess production and consumer problems
  • improve risk management, especially with regards to variable or uncertain demand
  • ensure that increased sales mean a corresponding increase for subsidiaries
  • prevent technological information from being disclosed to competitors through close continuous relationships

A close examination of each of the above points is based on an underlying idea that can improve your supply chain. Specifically:

  • strategic long-term trade relationships with key partners with a long-term focus on process improvement can generate excellent efficiencies
  • a minor position in your key partners demonstrates commitment, and it can help provide financial stability in unstable times
  • non-symmetrical trade stabilizes the relationship
  • seasoned executives have a lot to offer, and should consider consulting beyond retirement from full time positions
  • companies with more resources and established processes should transfer those capabilities to their strategic suppliers to improve processes and reduce costs
  • a company should be focused on high-value-add production, and since value-add production is relative, low-value-add production for one company might be high-value-add production for its supplier
  • the best way to maintain quality is to maintain relationships with suppliers who consistently produce quality
  • risk can be shared among partners and reduced
  • strategic relationships can insure that your key suppliers succeed and remain stable
  • forming key relationships with key suppliers that can adapt to changing demand minimizes the spread of trade secrets

Thus, even though over-applied Keiretsu can lead to closed markets, correctly applied Keiretsu teachings can rejuvenate your supply chain.

EyeForTransport Supply Chain Security Report

 

With the recent news about the terrorist plot against trans-atlantic airliners once again reminding us of the fragility of our supply chains – I thought it was timely to let you know that you can receive an up-to-date benchmarking report about the latest trends in supply chain and cargo security – Over 300 industry executives were polled on their views on this topic, and you can read the results of the survey by downloading the report now from EyeForTransport.

This report has been written in conjunction with the 5th Cargo Security Forum which is taking place in Washington DC on September 6-7 at the Washington Hilton Embassy Hotel — see the conference website for full details of the event.

Dave Thomas
eyefortransport

Demand Driven Supply Networks IV: What SAP has to say

Hot off the SAP presses is a new white paper called “Demand-Driven Supply Networks: Advancing Supply Chain Management” (@ KnowledgeStorm, Registration Required) that notes that being “demand-driven” requires an instantaneous sensing of customer demand and an immediate supply chain response to get the product to the customer when the customer wants it and that the critical element is collaboration among partners in the supply chain. Furthermore, it notes that Demand Driven Supply is the next step in the advancement of supply chain philosophy and translates into real money on the bottom line. Specifically, according to customer studies, analyst comments, and industry polling, SAP determined that consumer products companies can

  • increase fill rates by 3% to 10%
  • increase production efficiencies 1% to 5%
  • decrease freight costs 5% to 15%
  • improve personnel productivity 7% to 12%
  • reduce obsolescence and waste 35% to 50%
  • reduce inventory levels 7% to 15%
  • improve asset utilization 10% to 15%
  • decrease cash-to-cash cycle 10% to 30%
  • reduce deductions by increasing perfect order fill
  • make better use of promotional funds based on more accurate information
  • increase the effectiveness of product introductions (and phase outs)

No surprises, since this is more or less what AMR and Aberdeen have been preaching for years, but what is surprising is that SAP is not only embracing DDSN, but already has solutions that enable DDSN by combining existing technology, such as advanced planning and optimization, with the following capabilities:

  • Dynamic Sales and Operations Planning (DS&OP)
  • Global Data Synchronization
  • Radio Frequency Identification (RFID)-enabled processes
  • Point of sale-based analytics
  • Integrated Trade Promotions Management
  • Responsive Replenishment
  • Multi-tiered collaboration and shared scorecards
  • Adaptive Manufacturing
  • Event Management
  • Innovation and Design Collaboration

… and doing it while DDSN is still relatively early in its lifecycle. Considering SAP usually plays it safe and introduces new technology later on the innovation curve, this is a bit of bold move for SAP.

Although the paper does not cover anything that hasn’t been covered before, it does a good job of covering many of the key points. For instance, it notes that managers can respond proactively to deviations caused by internal and external events instead of spending their time gathering information, responding to problems, or preoccupied by ancillary tasks under demand driven supply. And more importantly, it notes that while manufacturers have always believed that long production runs lead to higher profitability, this is no longer the case since production runs that are theoretically less efficient may actually post a better ROI with DDSN because of the ability to shift manufacturing quickly to the most profitable products. Finally, DDS spans the entire consumer products supply chain and seamlessly connects all facets o the network. The future demand driven organization integrates all supply and demand elements to provide a seamless flow of real-time information to support valid decision making.

In addition to rehashing the definition of what DDS is, the SAP whitepaper also provides four steps that an organization can use to begin its journey.

  1. Harmonization
    standardize processes, data, and technology
  2. Advanced Planning
    integrate key supply and demand elements including logistics, production, new-product introduction, and trade management, refine forecasting techniques, and implement advanced planning and scheduling based on optimization
  3. Increased Responsiveness
    focus on the network by driving forecasting and visibility past the distribution center to the source of demand
  4. Adaptability
    refines the integrated network capabilities to adapt effectively and quickly to changes

These steps mesh will with our previous recommendations for each stage of the supply chain, which can each be classified as harmonization, advanced planning, increased responsiveness, or adaptability.

All in all, it’s a good introduction to demand driven supply and worth a quick read.

(Note: Parts I (An Introduction), II (Stages and Implications), and III (Challenges and Implementation) were posted on e-Sourcing Forum [WayBackMachine] this past weekend.)

Customer Data Management

About the same time Aberdeen released “The Spend Intelligence Benchmark Report: Turning Data into Action”, which we discussed last Sunday in There’s No Such Thing as Spend Intelligence, Aberdeen also released “Customer Data Management: How Leaders Attain Tangible ROI” that found more than 85% of survey respondents plan to invest in Customer Data Management solutions within the next 24 months.

Why? Maybe it’s because Aberdeen research reveals use of timely, complete, and accurate information leads to improved customer service levels, reduced operational costs, increased revenues, and higher customer satisfaction and retention rates. In addition above average performers attained >20% annual improvements in these key metrics:

  • Customer retention rates (84%)
  • Data accuracy / match rates (76%)
  • Partner/customer satisfaction rates (68%)
  • Revenues (56%)

Or maybe it’s because good customer data leads to good metrics and good forecasts, and creating the right product at the right time in the right quantity is one of the keys to overall supply chain success. After all, the wrong product results in lost opportunity, an insufficient quantity results in lost sales, and the wrong time results in stale inventories. Moreover, this hurts your customer as well as you, who might leave you for another provider.

Regardless, customer data management is important, and it has a lot in common with the development of a spend intelligence solution, to use Aberdeen’s terminology. Consider the top three challenges identified by the Aberdeen report:

  • Extracting & Normalizing Customer Data Captured from Multiple Sources
  • Verification of Data Accuracy or Completeness
  • Extracting & Normalizing Customer Data Stored in Legacy Data Marts

These are essentially the biggest challenges in implementing a good spend visibility solution

  • Extracting & Normalizing Spend Data Stored in Multiple Systems
  • Verification of Accuracy and Completeness
  • Extracting and Normalizing Legacy Spend Data for Historical and Trend Analysis

Therefore, if you are considering an enhanced spend visibility solution and an improved customer data management solution, you might want to take advantage of the synergies and tackle both projects simultaneously. Chances are, you’ll need to integrating a lot of the same feeds and systems, so you might as well tackle all of your data needs at the same time.

Aberdeen’s Global Supply Chain Benchmark Report

Aberdeen Group’s “Global Supply Chain Benchmark Report: Industry Priorities for Visibility, B2B Collaboration, Trade Compliance, and Risk Management” report, released in June, contains an alarming statistic, especially in today’s information technology driven networked world. An astounding 90% of all enterprises report that their global supply chain technology is inadequate to provide the corporate finance organization with the timely information it requires for budget and cash flow planning and management.

Furthermore, 79% of large companies say that the lack of supply chain process visibility is their top concern. Considering that, as we pointed out in yesterday’s post, understanding your supply chain is key to success, this is a serious concern. After all, if you have no visibility into your supply chain, how can you map it out and understand the real impact of any decision you might make with respect to your supply chain?

Fortunately, this excellent report also contains some solid recommendations for action to get you started.

  • Extend supply chain visibility.
    Move to exception-based management of global supply chain activities and slowly increase the number of milestones you monitor. Start executing against a longer-term roadmap that adds escalation policies, inventory pipeline visibility, mobile asset management, root cause analysis, and financial settlement and financing integration.
  • Scale business-to-business collaboration.
    The most productive collaboration processes are collaborative forecasting, inventory management, and replenishment, so focus on scaling those first.
  • Go corporate-wide with trade compliance.
    Move toward a single corporate-wide trade compliance platform and comprehensive origin and trade agreement management. Smaller companies should look to on-line tools for restricted party screenings and total landed cost calculations.
  • Institutionalize risk management.
    Make risk assessment and contingency planning part of your standard operating procedure. Institute supplier remediation programs for high-risk providers and increase logistics and supply agility to improve recovery capabilities.

Of course, before you can improve collaboration, and identify key milestones, you need to know where to begin. This is where next generation spend analysis systems that provide true visibility into your spend and the inter and intra organization and product relationships, often referred to as spend intelligence systems, and described in Aberdeen Group’s “The Spend Intelligence Benchmark Report: Turning Data into Action” that also came out in June, play a significant role.

This report also had some solid recommendations to get you started on the road to improved visibility.

  • Securing Executive Sponsorship.
    This is critical for just about any major undertaking, especially one involving an extensive information technology investment. If you don’t have a project champion who can make the case to senior executives, find the one who can offer the most clout.
  • Building a cross-functional team for enterprise-wide spend intelligence.
    Have an intelligence-gathering plan and key stakeholders in place to draw up the goals and expectations of a spend intelligence program.
  • Demonstrating quick hits by assessing spend intelligence opportunities in one or two spend categories.
    Showing the results of a small pilot program can help make the case with senior executives.

Support has to come top down, everyone needs to be involved, and you have to start small and work your way up. But the effort is worth it. After all, the report found that best in class companies reduced sourcing cycles by 19 to 25% while increasing contract compliance rates by 31 to 35%.