Category Archives: Supply Chain

The Secret of Supply Chain Management Success

Back in May, Jaume Ferrer and Johan Karlberg of Accenture published “Supply Chain Management: How to Build a Successful Global Operations Model” in the Accenture Outlook Journal where they noted that despite the facts that 93% of respondents to a recent survey reported global operations to be a central component to their business strategy and 97% were attempting to upgrade their global operations, only 50% of respondents reported successful implementation of critical capabilities. (The results were based on 305 online interviews with sales, marketing, and supply chain executives and almost equally split between the United States and Europe, and are thus statistically significant.)

According to the article, the reason for the lack of success was that most companies have been attempting to establish a global footprint by working through functional or regional silos when they should be taking an integrated, global approach. Brining together the worlds of product, market growth and operations strategy is a prerequisite to success in both new and existing markets. Companies that attempt to penetrate new markets without a specific product portfolio redesign and without rethinking channel approaches, make-or-buy strategies and back-office capabilities are in for a rough time.

In addition, the article notes that although there is non one-size-fits-all approach to global supply chain management success, there are six key capabilities that are required at the foundation level.

  • An effective global, integrated sales and operations planning process for key markets to ensure customer service, time-to-market, inventory and cost objectives.
  • A procurement, manufacturing, distribution and R&D network designed to deliver a quality product, in the scheduled time frame, at a target cost-of-goods sold and time-to-market objectives.
  • Tight links with customers and suppliers to enable improved demand visibility, customer service, and reduced working capital and cost-of-goods sold.
  • Logistics partnerships to ensure efficient and time-effective low-cost-market sourcing and penetration.
  • Effective supplier recruitment, certification and alignment programs to ensure quality and service objectives in addition to cost.
  • A go-to-market strategy (product portfolio, channel, network, make or buy) for emerging markets.

In brief, integrated sales and operations planning, procurement-based manufacturing and distribution R&D network, tight-linkages with partners up and down the chain, logistics partnerships, effective supplier management programs, and a go-to market strategy. It certainly sounds like it covers all of the bases, right?

Not really. Although each and every one of these elements is necessary for a successful global supply chain, just like each and every one of these elements is necessary for a successful regional, or even local, supply chain, there is one implicit, core foundation, element that is missing.

Understand your supply chain.

Before you begin any transformation process, you should fully understand your supply chain. And by this I mean that you should have your supply chain fully mapped out from sources (suppliers) through to sinks (retailers and customers) at multiple levels of detail and from multiple viewpoints. For example, you should have a distribution map that maps the primary routes and transportation methods from your suppliers to your plants and from your plants to your customers. You should have a process map that maps the flow of materials as they enter your facilities to finished products. Etc. The distribution map should detail the third party logistics carriers used and usual transportation times. The process map should detail the equipment used, the business units involved, and the process times.

This way, you can fully determine the ramifications of a potential change before you make it and insure that every affected party is appropriately dealt with. For example, before you switch to a new supplier, you could determine that production is going to need more lead time, you are going to have to find a new third party carrier, and the impact on your cost models. You could get change specific feedback from sales and marketing with respect to the expected lifetime of the product. You can much more easily work out the impacts and required changes with respect to the six core elements of success outlined in the Accenture article. After all, they key to reaching your destination efficiently is to know where you are starting from.

The Long Tail Wags the Dog

Dave Stephens, author of Procurement Central [WayBackMachine]  isn’t the only blogger who likes to muse about Procurement’s Long Tail. As you may recall, Doug Hudgeon of Vendor Management (renamed Contract Capital Management [WayBackMachine]) prognosticated on the issue in Are your vendors the Spice Girls or Arcadia? and I wrote about some of my own musings last month in my post Build To Order.

However, for those of you who want some in depth discussion of the “long tail”, a new book about entertainment, technology and statistics that predicts that popular culture-and the business associated with it-will be transformed by the internet entitled “The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business is Selling Less of more” by Chris Anderson is now available.

Now I’ll admit that I haven’t had a chance to read the whole book yet, although I have read the original article that the author wrote back in 2004 a number of times, but I have read a number of reviews, including a great article in a recent edition of The Economist entitled “What the long tail will do” (subscription required). The article points out that one of the main points of Mr. Anderson with respect to entertainment is that the niche, the obscure and the specialist, will gain ground at the expense of the hit. As evidence, he points to a drop in the number of companies that traditionally calculate their revenue/sales ratio according to the 80/20 rule—where the top fifth of products contribute four-fifths of revenues. Ecast, a San Francisco digital jukebox company, found that 98% of its 10,000 albums sold at least one track every three months. Expressed in the language of statistics, the experiences of Ecast and other companies such as Amazon, suggest that products down in the long tail of a statistical distribution, added together, can be highly profitable.

Long-tail enthusiasts argue that the whole of culture will benefit, not just commercial enterprises. Although many people appear to be quite happy to watch and listen to what the mainstream provides, if individuals have the opportunity to pick better, more ideally suited entertainment from a far wider selection, they will take it, according to the theory of the long tail. For example, YouTube is now serving up 100 million videos a day.   (And I personally buy more music in mp3 form from AudioLunchBox, Mperia, and related sites then I do traditional CDs these days.  Post-Edit: As of last link verification, the doctor highly recommends you check out Bandcamp, especially if you like American Pie. )

Interestingly enough, Mr. Anderson, who developed the long tail theory in the aptly named Wired article “The Long Tail” back in 2004, has backed away somewhat from his original take in which he suggested that the long tail would be a bigger market than the hits. His book says, more cautiously, that “all those niches can potentially add up to a market that is as big as (if not bigger than) the hits.”

The article in the Economist indicates that one weakness of this otherwise excellent book is that it tries to apply the theory of the long tail to fields far beyond entertainment and e-commerce. The article notes that Mr. Anderson sees long-tails in labour (offshoring) and national security. Although I am inclined to agree in that the application of the long-tail theory to national security is too much of a stretch, I disagree with the author of the Economist article and believe that the long-tail theory does apply to labour. However, even though outsourcing is part of the distribution, I would classify Crowdsourcing as the long-tail of labour.

Even though I do not think that any one author, reviewer, critic, analyst, researcher, or futurist really understands long-tail in its entirety, and that no one can fully predict what the long-tail future will deliver, I believe that as time goes on, we will see it taking a greater hold of many marketplaces, not just entertainment and e-commerce. Furthermore, I think the open-source movement will continue to significantly contribute to the long-tail in the technology sector and redefine the sector as a whole as it contributes to the emerging “non-monetary economy” that seems destined to emerge at the end of the long-tail.

For more insight, you can check out CNet’s interview with the author. I found the most interesting parts to be the following questions and answers:

What was the most surprising thing you came across in your research?

The most surprising thing was industries that understood the long tail that I hadn’t anticipated. When you think of the long tail, it’s basically a large number of niches that compete with one-size-fits-all mass-market products. There are so many precursors. You know, fashion has always had boutique and couture. And you can think of that of as a long tail of clothing.

In food, we’ve seen the rise of organic and artisanal food as the long tail of agriculture in a sense. It used to be difficult to have that in the supermarkets. But what I learned is that even in the supermarkets because of efficiencies and supply chains and stock management technology, there’s been more than a doubling in products on the shelf. Even Wal-Mart is now offering organic, which is a day many thought would never come.

Who are the most important people in the long tail?

The producers. I mean the long tail is made up of millions and millions of people who are creating content and finding an audience for it. Look at all the bloggers out there. They have essentially extended the tail of media a millionfold because it’s so easy to do so and they have something to say.

So I think that the real lesson of “The Long Tail” is that that notion that professionals produce and amateurs consume is really being blurred and we’re realizing that amateurs often have as much as to contribute as the professionals do and there are so many more of them. Wikipedia, I think, is perhaps the best example of that.

In other words, the long tail is just about everywhere and each and every one of us is carrying it forward. Now that’s food for thought.

Supply Chain Direction: Collaboration is Key

Back in April, EyeForTransport, the organizers of the Supply Chain Directions Summit 2006: Strategies & Tactics to Optimize Inventory and Supply Chain Visibility, released a report entitled “Supply Chain Directions 2006: How Fortune 500 shippers overcome their supply chain challenges”.

This report analyzed the results of a survey of almost 400 logistics professionals who were primarily executives from Fortune 500 manufacturers and retailers in charge of their companies’ logistics and supply chains and sought to identify the biggest supply chain issues and the methods that these companies were planning to employ to overcome those issues. The largest supply chain issue identified as relevant, by a whopping 62% of respondents, was a lack of collaboration. Furthermore, a whopping 59% of respondents identified enhanced collaboration schemes as the most likely method for decreasing their supply chain woes, 10% more then the runner-up option of optimizing warehouse management.

So how can you improve collaboration? One approach is to deploy new technology. In particular, Transportation Management Systems (TM) and Supply Chain Management Software (SCM) with built in collaboration capabilities can go a long way towards meeting these goals. In fact, these were the two leading systems identified by respondents as the most likely technologies to enhance their supply chain performance (at 56% and 44%, respectively).

Regardless of what direction, or directions, you choose, I’d recommend you check out the speaker list for EyeForTransport’s Supply Chain Directions Summit 2006 (November 28-29, 2006 in San Francisco, CA, USA) which reads like a who’s who list in the logistics and SCM trenches with speakers like Scott D. Burnette, the Director of National Transportation for Coca Cola North America, Ashley Hall, the 3PL Sourcing Manager for Intel, David Pieper, Supply Chain Strategy Principle, and Mike Passon, Director, Global Logistics, Program Management at Hewlett Packard, Arun Kumar, Director, Americas Logistics and Worldwide Compliance at Dell, Walter Gimenez, the Logistics Director at Nike, and 28 other confirmed speakers.

It appears to me that despite only being in its second year, the Supply Chain Directions Summit could be on its way to becoming recognized as one of the premier annual SCM events around the globe. The only advice I would give EyeForTransport is to consider doing what SAP did for SAPPHIRE, and fly in some leading bloggers to cover the event. This will help boost the event’s profile and visibility this year, as bloggers notify their ever growing reader lists in advance on their plan to be there, and next year, as those who do not attend read about what they missed. After all, I’m sure Jason Busch’s coverage of Ariba Live on Spend Matters probably provided more visibility for Ariba with almost 2,000 dedicated readers every day than a fistful of traditional publications. It’s a thought.

Supply Risk Management IV: WisdomNet’s Point of View

As mentioned in Jason Busch’s recent post Another Perspective on Supply Chain Risk* on SpendMatters , WisdomNet recently published a whitepaper that serves as a good introduction to Supply Chain Risk, and a good companion to my introductory posts on Supply Chain Risk (An Introduction, Risks and the Need for Resilience, and Managing Risk) that ran this weekend on e-Sourcing Forum [WayBackMachine]. Although I agree that there are not any breakthrough findings or thoughts in the work, I also found it to be quite a worthwhile read — a perfect supply risk management 101 type of study, if you will. As such, I’m going to highlight the key points made by the author as a comparison and contrast to the key points that I made this weekend (in an effort to encourage you to read more).

According to the white paper, five key factors have an impact on supply chain resilience:

  1. Supply Chain Design
  2. Business Process Management (BPM)
  3. Demand and Supply Visibility throughout the Supply Chain
  4. Supplier Relationship Management (SRM)
  5. Culture

Supply chain design is the primary driver of resilience, and the level of risk in a supply chain is affected by process structure, level of vertical integration (that results from make or buy decisions), the location of supply, the concentration of capacity, and inventory decisions. Process structure is dictated by the choice of make to stock, configure to order, make to order, and design to order. The extent to which suppliers that cannot be easily replaced perform critical steps in the vertically integrated supply chain increases the level of risk. Sourcing outside of the local market in which the goods are to be sold adds considerable transportation and delivery risk. Concentrating supply to a single region, country, or city adds considerable risk and risk (which includes obsolescence, quality, shelf-life, and loss) increases with the number of inventories in the chain.

Resilience can be added to the supply chain design by:

  • using common components and configure to order processes whenever feasible,
  • avoiding sole source arrangements,
  • reserving capacity, implementing maintenance and spares strategies when single sourcing must be used, and allowing for process redundancy,
  • distributing supply among multiple cities, countries, and regions
  • centralizing safety stocks regionally,
  • holding inventory in unprocessed states for flexibility,
  • consistently and regularly measuring and improving forecast accuracy,
  • rationalizing product lines,
  • building rapid re-supply provisions into supplier contracts,
  • collaborating with customers for “early warning” of potential needs,
  • using performance-based contracts with Service Level Agreements, and
  • sourcing locally within your target market to facilitate site visits, minimize cultural differences, and increase manageability.

A focus on business process management can enhance capability through the supply chain. Participants whose processes are controlled and reliable are less likely to induce supply chain disruptions internally than those whose processes are not under control. Operations where statistical process controls and improvement programs, such as Six Sigma, are in place tend to have more predictable processes and introduce less variability when compared to those operations without such controls.

Resilience is the result of business process management that includes

  • using fact-base process improvement and control techniques like Six Sigma,
  • working with partners to build the same process disciplines into their operations (as your supply chain is only as strong as your weakest link),
  • focusing improvements on reducing economic order quantities to increase flexibility, and
  • building the ability for flex capacity.

Enhancing visibility through the supply chain improves your ability to deploy appropriate levels of resources where needed and reduces the risk of internally generated disruptions. Also, the more open the participants are about providing early warnings about (potential) disruptions, the more likely the chain can either avoid them altogether, or at least reduce their effect and duration.

Resilience results from increased visibility when you

  • implement collaborative forecasting, planning, and replenishment,
  • use partner agreements to provide inventory visibility,
  • implement systems that integrate data feeds in (near) real-time, and
  • (contractually) require suppliers to provide immediate and specific notification of (potential) disruptions as soon as any event of significance occurs.

Competency in Supplier Relationship Management is the key to building and maintaining a strong supply chain team. SRM skills enable an organization to reduce supply chain interruption risk by strategically spreading business among multiple suppliers and multiple locations. SRM techniques include good performance measurement processes, collaboration and supplier development, and solid category management programs wherever sole sourcing is required.

With regards to performance measurement, it is important to establish clear expectations, provide timely feedback when performance falls short, and manage consequences. Reward suppliers that succeed and penalize suppliers that fail. Performance is increased when joint efforts with strategic suppliers are undertaken to optimize cost, inventory, processes and flexibility. Manage key categories with a sound understanding of the underlying commodity markets and devise substitution options when you foresee an impending shortage or crisis.

Resilience results from Supplier Relationship Management when you

  • establish supplier performance measurement processes and apply them consistently,
  • invest selectively in strategic supplier development,
  • manage categories for strategic and single-sourced components,
  • use supplier segmentation to guide relationship management, and
  • move toward performance-based contracts that build risk sharing into contract pricing.

Culture is used to refer to the level of trust, delegated decision-making structure, and rapid information movement. In order to build resilience:

  • participants need to share information about demand, inventory positions, capacities, and vulnerabilities,
  • lower levels of the organization need to be empowered to sound alerts regarding problems or potential problems (as the sooner a problem is found, the cheaper it is to fix, and the smaller the duration of the associated disruption), and
  • processes should be in place to enable timely information flow.

In addition to the steps that have been outlined above to improve resilience, there are actions that can, and should, be taken by an organization to prepare for a disruption. These are:

  • Identify potential risks, possible ramifications, and associated likelihoods.
  • Explore risk-reducing measures and decide on actions to mitigate risk, investing more in plans and processes to mitigate high likelihood and high impact risk scenarios.
  • Prepare business continuity plans that address both emergency response and plans for business resumption.
  • Practice drill the continuity plans against different scenarios to uncover and address potential weaknesses before a crisis happens.
  • Work with critical suppliers to make sure they are prepared and have business continuity plans in place.
  • Update plans regularly and as conditions change.
  • Respond to disruptive events as they occur.

In addition, the business continuity plans should include:

  • event impact analysis,
  • organizational roles and responsibilities for crisis management,
  • crisis communication plans,
  • well defined procedures for the evacuation of personnel,
  • consideration for means to provide food, water, shelter, clean air, security, and basic medical, and
  • secure back up of key business data and systems required to run the business and service your customers.

Events that cause supply chain disruptions are inevitable. The impact of these events, however, can be minimized by proactively taking steps to build a resilient supply chain and by preparing for disruption. For an in depth discussion, I refer you to WisdomNet’s white paper “Managing Supply Chain Risk: Building in Resilience and Preparing for Disruption” (registration required).

* All posts prior to 2012 were removed in the Spend Matters site refresh in June, 2023.

Product Information Management

Product Information Management, or PIM, according to Wikipedia, refers to the providing of product information for use in one or more output media and/or distribution channels, potentially involving multiple geographic locations. It involves ensuring that all of the data in your different systems, and those of the parties you interact with, is synchronous and synonymous. Even though it sounds like an easy problem to solve, just reference a master copy, it is still one of the biggest supply chain challenges. Global Logistics & Supply Chain Strategies on SupplyChainBrain.com magazine recently ran an article entitled “The Long Journey Toward One Version Of The Truth” describing how the inefficiencies in product information management are significant contributors to supply chain inefficiency and that data synchronization, internally and externally, can significantly help companies achieve one version of the truth.

PIM sounds simple enough:

  1. link to third party and legacy applications and import data into a centralized model,
  2. transform data by identifying and resolving duplicates and errors and enrich the data with external info, and
  3. synchronize the data by capturing all updates into the central master and pushing updates to the linked applications,

but when you consider that many organizations have dozen of systems with dozens of data formats and protocols for interfaces, its quite a challenge – especially when your suppliers, customers, and partners use different systems with different data formats and protocols.

I think the future of PIM lies in the exchange – where a third party maintains the master product information on behalf of a supplier and all of the users subscribe to this party to obtain the correct data. However, this does not resolve the integration issue, but I think this issue will eventually go away as on-demand SaaS (Software-as-a-Service) goes mainstream and the True SaaS providers integrate to the exchanges on your behalf.

After all, as reiterated in the article, the benefits are clear and well documented and include increased sales due to faster time to market, improved on-shelf product availability, improved productivity in the maintenance and publication of product masters, fewer errors to reconcile, lower transportation costs as a result of lower error rates, and more tax credits due to the ease in which they can be identified.

Feel free to share your thoughts.