Category Archives: Auctions

The Sourcing Maniacs 2008 Vendor Tour Part 20: Ketera

This post is a wee bit lengthy, so I’ve broken it into kidding and Ketera.


Kidding

  the maniacs are enjoying themselves somewhere in Alberta
Wakko Hee Haw!
Dot That was a classic, wasn’t it. Did you know it had Canadian roots?
Wakko Yippie Ki Yo Yippie Yay!
Dot We’re in Alberta, not Texas, Wakko!
  ring, ring
Yakko Yakkos Yiddish Yamakas … cheery caps for cheery chaps!
Australian Accent G’day, Mates! You wanted a demo of Ketera?
  if you’ll recall, back in part 12 (Kinaxis) the maniacs asked Ketera for a demo … they were too busy at the time, but promised to get back to the maniacs
Yakko Yes, we did.
Australian Accent Ace! Could you do it now?
  neeiiggghh!
Australian Accent Is that a Brumby I hear? Is this a good time for you blokes?
Yakko It’s just fine. I’ll fire up the satellite and we’re good to go!
Australian Accent Bonzer!
Are you out in the bush, mate?
Yakko No, we’re just enjoying the ranch.
Australian Accent Texas?
Yakko Alberta.
Australian Accent You’re in the Back of Bourke, aren’t you?
Yakko I guess you could say that.
Australian Accent You’re sure it’s a Mickey Mouse time for you?
Yakko No problem. I’m ready.
Dot I’m ready.
Yakko We just need to wrangle Wakko. One sec.
Wakko!
Get your strides over here now!
Wakko Why?
Yakko It’s time for the Ketera demo!
Wakko Now? Here?
Yakko We got sattelite internet, remember?
Wakko glumly
o. k.
Dot You can get back to having fun as soon as we’re done!
Wakko cheering up
A’ight!
  Wakko moseys on over.
Yakko We’re ready to give it a fair go!



Ketera

Australian Accent switching to his best American for the demo
Today I’m going to run through our new e-Sourcing application. It’s pretty straight-forward, so it won’t take much time.
  unlike the maniacs’ walkabout …
Yakko No problem! Take it away.
Australian Accent I should start off by noting that what we noticed was that a lot of people were spending a lot of money on enterprise sourcing applications without using the full extent of their capabilities … most of our catalog, procurement, and supply network customers were just using e-RFX and e-Auction and most of those customers were just using single round RFXs and traditional reverse auctions … not the dozen or so variants that have sprung up over the last ten years.

We saw the need for a low-cost 80% solution that would give the market what we felt it needed most … a basic sourcing solution for small and mid-size companies without large budgets or sophisticated software needs. And that’s what we built.

Our e-Sourcing solution is just RFX and Reverse Auction … and unlike many enterprise applications that take hours, if not days, to set an event up … our solution allows an event to be configured in minutes using a very simple 3-step process.

Step 1: Create a new event.
Step 2: Specify the items and item details.
Step 3: Invite suppliers.
  Then you just sit back, and watch prices tumble.

Yakko If it’s that easy, is it really an 80% solution?
Australian Accent Think about it. How much does an e-RFX and e-Auction solution really have to do?
Yakko Well, one thing we learned from talking to Source One about WhyAbe is that, for many categories, and many small to mid-size companies, it doesn’t have to do that much.
Australian Accent Precisely. And their offering is actually a good starting point to understand our offering.
Yakko So how does your offering compare to theirs?
Australian Accent Quite good. We both have the bare minimum requirements for e-RFX and e-Auction, but whereas, in our view, they’re more of a 60% to 70% solution, we add a few features that, although they sound like bells and whistles, are actually necessary for an 80% solution in today’s global e-Sourcing marketplace.
Yakko Like what?
Australian Accent Localization. Contract tracking. Fine-grained scoring on RFX questionnaires. Microsoft Excel integration. Templates. Instant-Messaging and Alerts. Customizable dashboards. Supplier Master Management. Wizards for each step of the process. The little things that make it easy, useful, and a pleasure to use — all embedded in a streamlined application with a carefully designed UI that buyers want to use.

And, unlike many other e-Sourcing platforms, it’s a low-cost, self-service, pay-as-you-go platform.

Yakko How low?
Australian Accent $39.99/month for unlimited RFIs, RFPs, RFQs, and reverse auctions. Plus, you get instant access to thousands of suppliers in the Ketera network.
Yakko Beaut!
Australian Accent Too right!
Yakko Anything else we should know?
Australian Accent It’s very easy to administrate, and the item and supplier master views support numerous filters for quick location of the appropriate item or supplier. It’s straightforward to enter proxy bids on behalf of a supplier. All of the reports have decent graphic capabilities. We support the UNSPSC schema for item categorization. And it has basic project tracking capability — you can quickly see your open events, events requiring bid evaluation, and recently evaluated events at any time.
Yakko So it really is a decent sourcing solution for small and mid-size companies just starting out on their e-Sourcing journey, or those companies without sophisticated sourcing needs.
Australian Accent We think so. And, as I said before, very easy to set-up a sourcing event.
Wakko I’m out of baloney. How long to set up an event to source a 3-months supply?
Australian Accent Five minutes. Watch.
  five minutes pass as the salesperson demos the tool
Wakko That’s it?
Australian Accent That’s it!
Wakko Fair suck of the sav!
Apparently, Wakko has his Aussie down pat! If I didn’t know better, I’d say he was from the Never Never!
Yakko Well, thanks for the demo. It certainly is an interesting take on the e-Sourcing space. A sourcing tool that every business can afford.
Australian Accent Thank you. Hooroo, Journo!
Wakko Hooroo, mate.

On the Sixth Day of X-Mas … (Cost Reduction Strategic Sourcing Strategies)

On the sixth day of X-Mas

my blogger gave to me
tactics for saving,
five golden rings,
four little words,
tri-focal lens,
two boxing gloves
and a lesson in strategy.

Six tactics that you can use to save in today’s marketplace are:

  • Reverse Auctions on Commodity Categories in Competitive Markets
  • Sealed Bids on Strategic Purchases of Custom Goods or Services
  • Decision Optimization on High Value Goods
  • Process Re-engineering with Strategic Partners
  • Lane Optimization
  • Distribution Center Optimization

Reverse Auctions on Commodity Categories in Competitive Markets

A recent post on Supply Excellence asks “if you are not sourcing, why not?” … and it’s a good question. Many key commodities that go into the parts you buy, and the energy your suppliers are using to convert raw materials into finished goods, recently hit two, three, and, in some cases, four year lows thanks to the recent decline in global demand. For some categories, it’s the best sourcing market we have seen in years as far as reverse auctions are concerned. So review the reverse auction selection criteria over on e-Sourcing Forum, where you can also find details on reverse auction strategy and reverse auction basics, brush up on the key steps to successful e-auctions, and get sourcing!

Sealed Bids on Strategic Purchases of Custom Goods or Services

If the category is strategic, and you can not use a reverse auction or open-bid methodology and have suppliers compete solely on price, because quality will be just as important, use a sealed bid.

Decision Optimization on High Value Goods

As outlined in my recent posts on e-Sourcing Forum and here on Sourcing Innovation where I asked if you can really afford to leave millions on the table, strategic sourcing decision optimization typically saves you 12% above and beyond what you will save with your best reverse auction, and, even today, still saves you up to 40% on some categories … which is an awful lot of bling if we’re talking about a 100 Million category. So review the decision optimization wiki-paper, select an appropriate solution, and start saving.

Process Re-engineering with Strategic Partners

Streamline processes and increase productivity. This allows you to increase spend under management and the savings you can generate. And if you’re worried about resistance, check out this post on overcoming worker resistance in process improvements.

Lane Optimization

Make sure you are using the right lanes at the right service levels from the right carriers. Otherwise, you could be considerably overspending on your transportation. As Dan Kowal pointed out in his recent Supply Excellence “sourcing opportunities during recession direct indirect logistics” post, the Baltic Panamax Freight Index has dropped 90% since May of this year. The market is rife with opportunities.

Distribution Center Optimization

An inefficient distribution network is costly. Save big by optimizing your network. For details on how, see my post on Bob’s Unique Talents.

We Didn’t Start the Auction

Free Markets, Ariba, Procuri, Iasta
Perfect Commerce, PurchasingNet, B2E Markets

Ketera Tech, VerticalNet, Trading Partners, and Moai Tech
K2 Sourcing, the Commerce-hub, and e-Breviate

Emptoris, SciQuest, Sorcity, Synertrade
WhyAbe, eDynaQuote, and a Global eProcure

Procusoft, Quadrem, Co-exprise Marketplace
AECSoft, A.T Kearney, B2B Marketplace

We didn’t start the auction
It’s been always raging
Since the world’s been trading
We didn’t start the auction
Though we did ignite it
We just couldn’t fight it

Generally speaking, the conventional wisdom is to run auctions in loose markets where supply exceeds demand and the power resides in the hands of the buyer. However, auctions can also be helpful when supply is tight and commodity costs are rising, when the power theoretically rests in the hands of the supplier, especially if we have an inflationary market. Why? Even though demand may be tight, in an inflationary market, spending goes down, and demand will only remain high if consumers can ultimately afford the products being produced.

In these conditions, if you are unable to control prices, demand for your products will drop. And your suppliers, whether or not they want to admit it, recognize that demand could drop for end-user products at any time, and thus the components and materials they provide, at any time. This means that they are likely desperate to lock in business and should be willing to agree to an ethical auction.

This is good news, because a well-designed and well-run auction allows you to determine the true market price for a product or service, especially those where only part of the cost is due to commodities that have increased in price since your last sourcing event. If a supplier believes its business might drop, it might be a lot more willing to reduce it’s profit margin on the value-add component of its offering.

Thus, if the category is one that you’d normally auction, you should probably still do so. Don’t get jumpy and switch sourcing strategies just because the market has changed since the last time you examined the category. If your analysis indicates that the category is right for a sealed-bid negotiation, do a sealed-bid negotiation; if your analysis indicates that you need strategic sourcing decision optimization, use decision optimization; and if your analysis says that the category is appropriate for an auction, use an auction. As long as it’s well planned and well executed, even though your costs might not decrease, they could still be less than the average market cost. Good analysis and strategies withstand the actions of the market. So stick to them.

The e-Sourcing Handbook (Free e-Book)

The e-book edition of the e-Sourcing Handbook, co-authored and edited by yours truly, and sponsored by Iasta [acquired by Selectica, merged with b-Pack, rebranded Determine, acquired by Corcentric] (an e-Sourcing solution provider), is now available on request (through e-mail).

The e-Sourcing Handbook is your modern guide to Supply and Spend Management Success which utilizes and enhances strategic sourcing technology and best practices. Covering the full spectrum of the e-Sourcing cycle, the handbook helps you understand not only what spend analysis, e-RFx, e-Auction, decision optimization, and contract management are, but where and when to apply these technologies for maximum benefit.

Building on the resounding success of the e-Sourcing Wiki [WayBackMachine] and the e-Sourcing Forum [WayBackMachine] and Sourcing Innovation blogs, the handbook takes the concept of open access to knowledge and best practices one step further by compiling the best information on e-Sourcing to appear on all three public information sources into one definitive source. Furthermore, by mixing content from factual and informative wiki articles with blog postings that are both controversial and opinionated in an innovative manner, the juxtaposition of the two in the handbook allows the reader to see where the boundary lies between information and advocacy. It is the goal of the authors that, through this ground-breaking effort, the reader will gain a better understanding of e-Sourcing and how to take their supply and spend management efforts to the next level.

And, most importantly, unlike some of the recent e-books to pop-up, this is a real book – not a glorified marketing white paper doubled (or tripled) in size with a fancy (spaced-out) layout that contains dozens of colorful, yet useless, images. An exact mirror of the forthcoming print-book, it’s 220 pages of solid content backed up by a 4 page resource section, 8 page glossary, and 22 page bibliography for those who thirst for knowledge. The full table of contents and index are also included to help the reader quickly find what she is looking for.

But perhaps the foreward by co-author Eric Strovink of BIQ (acquired by Opera Solutions, rebranded ElectrifAI) says it best.

The e-Sourcing space has undergone a major transformation since 2000. Vendors who were once dominant or cutting-edge have failed. Many have undergone asset fire sales, become part of the walking-dead, or been absorbed into larger companies; and still others have been forced by their investors into mergers that make little sense to the outside observer.

 

These consolidations have brought about a dangerous commoditization of ideas, along with a slowdown of innovation. Even worse has been the obscuring – by over-enthusiastic and under-educated vendor marketing departments – of deeply important issues that sourcing practitioners must consider and understand in order to be successful.

In response to this, my co-author, Dr. Michael Lamoureux, launched the Sourcing Innovation blog with the specific purpose of educating practitioners and cutting through the marketing babble that had begun to dominate the discussion. Another co-author, David Bush, started the e-Sourcing Wiki (from which the bulk of this Handbook is taken) in a similar attempt to put fundamental e-Sourcing ideas and concepts into a publicly accessible forum. Over the years, David has also built Iasta’s e-Sourcing Forum blog into a credible and useful resource.

These efforts are laudable, but blogs and wikis are sometimes hard to navigate, and effort is often required to extract related information in a useful way. This Handbook is an effort to draw together the knowledge base of the Wiki, along with relevant blog postings, into a coherent and readable framework. Of course, one might argue that none of the authors are readable or coherent – and that may be a fair criticism – but we’ve made a best effort.

Because Michael is a strong and independent voice in the space, it’s appropriate that he is the editor of this Handbook. He has taken an interesting and unorthodox approach, choosing to mix factual and informative wiki articles with blog postings that are both controversial and opinionated. The juxtaposition of the two allows the reader to see where the boundary lies between information and advocacy. This is perhaps the first effort of its kind where two very different resources are interlinked in a constructive, and hopefully interesting, way.

 

I trust that this edition of the Handbook will be the first of many similar efforts, and that together we can collectively energize our space with accurate information and useful insights. Remember, the e-Sourcing Wiki is a public resource – anyone can contribute – so everyone should consider “sharing the wealth” and do so.

SourceOne scores a Grand Slam with WhyAbe

Gartner recently named Source One’s (acquired by Corcentric) free WhyAbe.com (sunset) platform as a Cool Vendor in Procurement and Finance for 2008. This is a big score for the sourcing and contract management toolset, when you consider that not many sourcing providers get this recognition from Gartner and that previous winners have included FreeFlow, Vinimaya (rebranded Aquiire, acquired by Coupa), and BIQ (acquired by Opera Solutions, rebranded ElectrifAI) – the latter of which are really cool vendors.

Source One, a Procurement Service Provider (PSP), is a fairly major player in the strategic sourcing & cost reduction consulting marketplace, having been incorporated back in 1993 – well before companies like FreeMarkets (now part of Ariba) made strategic sourcing vogue, and many of their consultants have over 20 years of experience in the field. They take the traditional approach to sourcing projects with a two part project team (consisting of Source One personnel who do the project and Client personnel who sponsor and manage the project on the client site), as compared to the resource augmentation approach some of the newer consultancies take. The approach may seem heavy to a smaller organization, but the results speak for themselves. With an average savings of 18% across 60+ categories (whose average savings range from 5% to 25%, while some outliers, like cash management, are as high as 90%), when they say their aggregated purchasing power allows them to secure exceptionally competitive pricing, they mean it. And from what I hear, they’re doing so well that it’s a daily struggle to keep up with a constantly increasing demand for their services. (P.S. They’ll be making a big announcement at ISM next month. You might want to watch for it.)

But let’s talk about WhyAbe.com. From a technology perspective, RFX, Reverse Auction, and basic Contract Management is nothing new … basic solutions for the former has been available for over ten years and a basic solution for the latter for at least seven years. There’s nothing new about cookie-cutter on-line stores or stripped down supplier networks either. What is new is the fact that it’s totally free.  WhyAbe.com is cracking the sourcing mold and offering a free solution that companies new to sourcing and sourcing technology can use and experiment to find out what works for them, what doesn’t, and what they need help on. It’s a great way for a company to test the water as it provides a quick start to e-Sourcing with a price that can’t be beat. Then, when an organization has identified it’s needs, and, more importantly, identified what it can do well in house – and what it can not, it can always upgrade to a more extensive e-Sourcing platform and retain a PSP, like Source One, to help it with those categories that it doesn’t have the experience, or the leverage, to get savings on. Furthermore, should it retain Source One, it can still use the tool as a way to work with the PSP. In other words, even though there’s nothing new from a technology perspective, the model is very cool and I think they deserve the Cool Vendor award for it. If nothing else, it will force some of the stagnant providers in the e-Sourcing space that haven’t done much with their solution for 2, 3, 5, and in some cases, 7 years to update their offering to provide real value for the $$s they’re charging, or fall by the wayside to make room for the new innovators. And that’s a win for the space you can’t argue with!