Category Archives: Event

A prediction from the doctor with regards to Big Procurement Events

In a recent post over on Spend Matters UK on “eWorld Procurement and Supply” by Peter Smith, he made a number of observations on the event that happened last month. A few of these might have been unexpected by the average practitioner, but are not really surprising when you think about it. First we’ll cover them and then we’ll discuss why the doctor does not think these observations to be all that surprising.

Mr. Smith’s observation number two: There was also a good number of suppliers, although there seemed to be quite a few of the bigger software firms missing this time.

Mr. Smith’s observation number three: The standard of the presentations is still highly variable.

Mr. Smith’s observation number four: The other thing that might help on that would be a little more detail on the content in the programme.

Mr. Smith’s observation number seven: Ultimately, there is considerable value to delegates in eWorld, particularly if you are smart / lucky enough to choose the right sessions ….

Let’s start with observations number three and four. When you have an event that relies on lots of vendors forking over lots of dollars, you can’t always be that fussy when it comes to whose dollars you accept. And since those dollars come at the price of a presentation, it’s obvious that since vendors are of various quality, the presentations, as well as the descriptions of such presentations, will be of various quality. And as a result …

Mr. Smith’s observation number seven is a logical consequence. As a result, the value to delegates will be entirely dependent on those delegates choosing the right sessions, which, with limited information, will depend as much on a delegate’s luck as the delegate’s skill in picking the right presentation to attend. But the most important observation is …

Mr. Smith’s observation number two — the lack of bigger software firms. Not only does the doctor not find this surprising, but expects more and more absences from the leading firms in the year to come. Why? The ROI of this event for a leading provider is less and less every year. The more providers who are present, the less mindshare each provider gets. The bigger the event gets, and the more practitioners who get to go at little or no cost, the more the vendors have to pay to attend. In other words, vendors end up paying more for less every year. Especially when the practitioners who are attending the big events not only range in seniority from Junior Buyer, with no buying influence, to CPO, with ultimate buying authority, with the majority being on the Junior Buyer side of the scale.

And if you are a large, best-in-class, vendor, with a decent education budget, you have enough to finance and attend a much smaller event with a larger percentage of Director’s, VPs, and CPOs, where you are not only going to get more mind-share, since there will be fewer vendors at this smaller event, but more potential marketshare, since every individual that shows interest is one with actual buying authority.

Furthermore, since the even larger best-in-class vendors can host their own Procurement education days, with thought leaders, client case studies, and hands-on training sessions, these best-in-class vendors can get 100% mindshare for a limited time from every person who attends. So what’s the better value? A big event like eWorld or ISM where vendor capability ranges from simple e-Negotiation capability to full-fledged Source-to-Pay with little hope the average attendee will have time to figure out the difference? Or a smaller, focussed event, where the limited number of vendors have similar capability, more time to educate the participants, and a chance to educate more senior participants? Obviously, the latter, and, as a result, it’s only a matter of time before the number of absences at big events like eWorld and ISM from big, leading vendors increases. And that’s the doctor‘s prediction.

Source-to-Settle – The Sourcing and Procurement Kettle

Source-to-Settle is the end-to-end integration of sourcing and procurement, starting with spend analysis and ending at spend analysis. It is the integrated workflow that starts with sourcing event identification, proceeds through e-Negotiation and Award, and ends with the creation of a purchase order, the receipt of goods and an invoice, and the e-payment for goods received and includes everything in between.

There’s a lot involved in the source-to-settle process, and often a lot more than can be found in most sourcing and procurement modules and stand-alone best-of-breed suites. As indicated in our last post, there is the need for accuracy — to insure that savings are not lost and the right categories are identified. There is also the need for compliance — with insurance and regulatory requirements, with contracts and pricing, and, most importantly with SOX. And results only come from efficiency and performance — which requires integrated, streamlined processes, supplier performance management, and collaboration.

It’s a tall order, but an organization that doesn’t keep PACE never realizes the value that results when there’s one integrated workflow, one complete spend repository for spend analysis, and one, 100% accurate, view of the truth.

For deeper insight into how an end-to-end integrated Source-to-Settle solution can allow your organization to keep PACE and deliver value beyond what you may have thought possible, download Sourcing Innovation’s latest white-paper on how An Integrated Source-to-Settle Platform Brings Unparalleled Benefits to Supply Management and register for Ivalua’s upcoming webinar on how to Help Build Your Business Case Today on January 28 @ 11 PST / 14 EST / 19 GMT!

Source-to-Settle: More than Just a Set of Service Modules

Having Source-to-Settle capability involves having more than Source-to-Contract and Procure-to-Pay solution modules. As explained in our last post, if an organization wants to achieve the best results, just having both solutions is not enough. Certain categories of savings and value only materialize when the Source-to-Settle solution is integrated end-to-end.

For example, due to the existence of multiple, disconnected solutions which rely on multiple, disconnected databases, there are huge accuracy issues.

First of all, there is a proliferation of manual errors due to duplicate data entry. When data has to be manually re-entered into other systems, or selected for export and import to other systems, human error always creeps into the process. The average error rate for keystroke entry is approximately 1%, as tabulated by Raymond R. Panko at the University of Hawaii, and this human error can be very costly. For example, assume the contract pricing for laser cartridges has been erroneously entered into the Procurement system as $70 a unit when it should be $60 a unit. Further assume that the organization buys 1,000 of these a year and that the old rate was $69.95. If the Procurement system has a tolerance of error of 0.1%, then it will never detect if the Supplier continues to charge the old rate and the organization will overspend by $11,940. Now assume that the organization buys 10,000 units a year and all of a sudden the organization is out $119,400!

But this is just the tip of the iceberg. With multiple systems, there is no single version of the truth. So, if there is disagreement between the P2P and the ERP system, which system is correct? And which system do you run the analysis on to identify the target categories for sourcing? It makes a difference. The greatest value comes from identifying the category with the greatest opportunity. And that can only be done with complete, accurate data.

For more information on these missed opportunities, along with fourteen other opportunities that only materialize with an integrated Source-to-Settle solution, download Sourcing Innovation’s latest white-paper on how An Integrated Source-to-Settle Platform Brings Unparalleled Benefits to Supply Management and register for Ivalua’s upcoming webinar on how to Help Build Your Business Case Today on January 28 @ 11 PST / 14 EST / 19 GMT!

Prove Your Mettle with Source-to-Settle

We all know the importance of having both Sourcing and Procurement* solutions as neither solution on its own is sufficient to enable an organization to extract the savings and value inherent in each sourcing and procurement project. For example, the savings that result from the best negotiated contracts in the world as a result of an intense strategic sourcing project will never be realized when a lack of good procurement processes and systems results in over 30% maverick spend. Similarly, the best procurement processes and systems in the world are useless if the organization is unable to take advantage of the data and inherent efficiencies to source better contracts next time around.

However, if an organization wants to achieve the best results, just having both solutions is not enough. Certain categories of savings and value only materialize when the solution is integrated end-to-end. What do we mean by this?

Consider the situation that occurs when an organization has separate Source-to-Contract (S2C) and Procure-to-Pay (P2P) solutions. In this situation, what typically happens is there are two code-bases, relying on three separate databases, that rely on the ERP, the Vendor Master database it controls, and the Inventory Master database the ERP connects to, which is generally under the control of the Logistics and Warehouse Management solution.

In this situation, in order to accomplish a task, the Supply Management professional may need to consult three databases to find the information she needs, use two completely different workflows to issue an RFQ and then issue a PO, and use two completely different solutions to extract the relevant transactions for analysis and do the analysis. It’s not efficient, and, moreover, since data has to be entered in (at least) two different solutions, it’s error prone. As a result, the organization is missing out on up to sixteen different efficiencies and benefits that would otherwise be available to it.

What are these efficiencies and benefits? To find out, download Sourcing Innovation’s latest white-paper on how An Integrated Source-to-Settle Platform Brings Unparalleled Benefits to Supply Management and register for Ivalua’s upcoming webinar that will Help Build Your Business Case Today! on January 28 @ 11 PST / 14 EST / 19 GMT!

Remember, it’s Sourcing and Procurement!

It’s Illegal to Burn Money, But Yet Your Organization Does It Every Day! (So Find Out How to Do Something About It!)

Title 18, Section 33 of the United States Code says you shall not mutilate, cut, disfigure, perforate, unite or cement together, or do any other thing to any bank bill, draft, note, or other evidence of debt issued by any national banking association, Federal Reserve Bank, or Federal Reserve System, with intent to render such item(s) unfit to be reissued and if you do, you can be fined or imprisoned for up to 6 months. But yet, every day, organizations everywhere collectively flush billions of dollars down the drain, overpaying suppliers, including foreign suppliers, millions of dollars that can not be recovered and reissued by the organization for other business purposes.

If it wasn’t for the fact that the vast majority of these organizations don’t intend to overpay and waste money, since this money (and evidence of debt) flows through the American banking system, I would otherwise be inclined to argue that, technically, this gross incompetence in management of corporate funds is criminal.

For proof that the average organization wastes money, we simply have to look to the audit recovery industry which recovers, on average 1% to 1.5% of annual spend. And, typically, this is just what they can find with a quick, mostly manual, review of the top n suppliers that account for 2/3rds (66%) to 3/4ths (75%) of external organizational spend using a very loose interpretation of the 80/20 rule. And that’s just overspend. What about spend that should never of happened in the first place (because it was off-contract and 15% higher than contracted rates)? Or unrecoverable losses due to a key supplier not having mandatory insurance policies in place? Or gross violations of the T&E (Travel & Expense) policy (that border on criminal malfeasance) where the VP of Sales decides that a dinner costing 2K / head at the local strip club is a valid use of the organization’s P-Card?

But most of these situations are easily preventable by a Procurement system that is designed to not only enforce compliance, but make it easy. To find out how, check out Sourcing Innovation’s New White Paper on The Procurement Marketplace and the Power of Compliance (registration), sponsored by Vinimaya.