Category Archives: rants

Just like there was no Æther, there’s no data fabric either!

In a recent LinkedIn posting just before the holidays, THE REVELATOR asked a very important question. A question that may have gone overlooked given that many people are busy trying to get their work done before the holidays so they can get a few days off. And a question that must NOT be forgotten.

1. How does the old technology phrase “garbage-in, garbage-out” apply to Gartner’s Data Fabric post?

Data files. Databases. Data stores. Data warehouses. Data lakes. Data Lakehouses. And now … the data fabric … which is, when all is said and done, just another bullsh!t organizational data scheme designed to distract you from the fact that your data is dirty, that data storage providers don’t know what to do about it, but these data storage providers still need to sell you on something new to maintain their revenue streams.

You see, the great thing about today’s SaaS middleware enabled apps is that they don’t care where the data is, what organizational structure the data is stored in, etc. As long as the data has a descriptor that says “this field, which is in this format, in this db stores X” (where X describes the data) and an access key, the SaaS middleware can suck the data in, convert that data into the format it needs, and work with that data.

However, now that we are in the age of “AI”, the most important thing has become good, clean, data. However, just “weaving” your bad data together doesn’t solve anything. In fact, with today’s technology, it just makes things MANY times worse. We are now at garbage in, hazardous waste out!

Unfortunately there’s nothing we can do if the AI zealots are now adding hallucinogenics to their kool-aid, because it sounds like they are trying to bring back the magical medeival Æther … *groan*

THE REVELATOR then went on to ask …

2. Why does Gartner confuse more than inform and enlighten?

At the end of the day, you have a better chance of appearing as an enlightened Guru to someone who is lost and confused than to someone who is clear headed and confident in one’s direction!

Like the other big analyst firms, they profit off of being the Gurus the executives turn to when they can’t make sense of the hogwash filled marketing madness they are inundated with every day!

More specifically, their sales people need to say: “Our senior analyst has all of the answers … and they can be yours at the low, low introductory price of only 9,999,99 USD a day*.” So they don’t really care about whether or not they are confusing more than enlightening, as long as the sales are coming in. (In fact, they aren’t even looking to see how they are doing as long as the money keeps rolling in …

* one day only, after that, full rate of 29,999.99 a day applies …

But the questions didn’t stop there. The next question was:

3. Why are Data Problems Solved Downstream?

The answer to this is not as easy or straightforward, but when you consider that:

  1. it’s hardwork to solve the problems at the source and
  2. most of these analyst firms are staffed with analysts with little fundamental understanding of technology or the domains they are analyzing the technology for, don’t want to admit it, and are happy to take guidance from the vendors cutting them the biggest cheques and spending the most time “educating” them on the paradigm the vendor wants to see …

What should one expect.

Case in point. Did IDC just happen to come up with a “Worldwide SaaS and Cloud-Enabled Spend Orchestration Map” on its own at the same time a whole bunch of these solutions hit mainstream? (Especially when it takes person years of research and development to design a new map and analyze vendors, at least if you want to try and get it right.) Especially when they don’t have enough senior analyst talent to adequately cover core S2P?

Another case in point. Did Gartner merge it’s P2P into a S2P map because it honestly believes the entire market is heading there (FYI it’s not, look at the Mega Map), or because it doesn’t have enough analyst talent left to attempt to cover the market fragmented?

At the end of the day, it takes many years and many degrees to get a fundamental understanding of modern technology (which all runs on math, by the way) and many more years to get expertise in a business domain … so what can you honestly expect of kids straight out of school who make up significant portions of analyst teams???

Which led to the next question.

4. Can innovation co-exist with exclusivity?

Innovation happens, but then big stalwarts in the space scoop it up to try and remain competitive enough to keep their current customers locked in, a vacuum is created, and the cycle starts anew.

Until Trump dismantles them entirely, the US, like most of the pseudo-free first world, has enough anti-monopoly laws to ensure the cycle continues.

So yes, innovation can coexist with exclusivity, it just takes decades to realize what could happen in less than one decade as a result of having to start over so many times.

Finally, this led to the final question:

5. Does the VC investment model of: for every ten investments, seven fail, two are mediocre, and one “hits pay dirt” have anything to do with the 80%+ technology project failure rate?

It most certainly does! The fact that VCs are happy for seven investments to fail entirely (and then just move the good people to other investments if those people want to keep working) doesn’t help the project failure rate … especially since so many companies don’t survive long enough to master models that will lead to success, instead of failure, 80%+ of the time or to take the time to gauge, plan, and do implementations properly (because, if they don’t sell the next deal within a quarter, the investors will drop them faster than a hot potato).

One of these things is not like the other — it’s the right choice!

This originally published March 6 (2024).  It is being reposted due to the criticality of the subject matter (and the fact that One Trillion was wasted on services last year).

Note the Sourcing Innovation Editorial Disclaimers and note this is a very opinionated rant!  Your mileage will vary!  (And not about any firm in particular.)

Three bids for that spend analytics project from the three leading Big X firms come in at 1 Million. One bid for that spend analytics project from a specialized niche consultancy you pulled out of the hat for bid diversity comes in at 250 Thousand. Which one is right?

Those of you who only partially paid attention to the education Sesame Street was trying to impart upon you when you were growing up will simply remember the “one of these things is not like the other” song and think that any of the bids from the Big X firm is right and the niche consultancy is wrong because it’s different, and therefore must be thrown out because it’s too low when, in fact, it’s just as likely that the three bids from the Big X firms that are wrong and the bid from the niche consultancy that was right.

Those of us who paid attention knew that Sesame Street was trying to show us how to detect underlying similarities so we could properly cluster objects for further analysis. What we should have learned is that the Big X bids were all the same, built on the same assumption, and can be compared equally. And that the outlier bid needed further investigation — a further investigation that can only be undertaken against an appropriately sized set of sample set of bids from other specialized niche consultancies to compare against. And without that sample set of bids, you can’t properly evaluate the lower bid, which, the doctor can tell you, is just as likely to be closer to correct than what could be wildly overpriced Big X bids.  (Newer firms often have newer tech and methods — and if these are the right methods and tech for your problem … )

As per our recent post, if you want to get analytics and AI right, most of these guys don’t have the breadth and depth of expertise they claim to have (as most don’t have the educational background to know just how broad, deep, and advanced AI and analytics can get, especially when you dig deep into the math and computer science and all of the variable models and strengths and weaknesses, and instead are trained on what is essentially marketing content from AI and analytics providers). In the group that sells you, there will be a leader who is a true expert (and worth his or her weight in platinum), a few handpicked lieutenants who are above average and run the projects, and a rafter of juniors straight out of private college with more training in how to dress, talk, and follow orders than training in actual analytics … and no guarantee they even have any real university level mathematics beyond basic analysis in operational research (and thus a knowledge of what analytics is and isn’t and can and can’t do).  And unless you know what you need, and why, you can’t judge the response.  (Furthermore, you can’t expect them to figure out your problem and goals with only partial information!)

While there was a time big analytics projects were (multi) million dollar projects, that was twenty years ago when Spend Analysis 1.0 was still hitting the market; when there were limited tools for data integration, mapping, cleansing, and enrichment; and when there weren’t a lot of statistics on average savings opportunities across internal and external spend categories. Now we have mature Spend Analysis 3.0 technologies (some taking steps towards spend analysis 4.0 technologies); advanced technologies for automatic data integration, mapping, cleansing, and even enrichment; deep databases on projects and results by vertical and industry size; extensive libraries for out-of-the-box analytics across categories and potential opportunities; and a whole toolkit for spend analysis that didn’t exist two decades ago. This new toolkit, built by best of breed vendors used, and sometimes [co-]owned by these best of breed niche consultancies (that don’t try to do everything, and definitely don’t pretend they can), allows modern spend analysis projects to be done ten times as efficiently and effectively, in the hands of a master — a master that isn’t necessarily on your project if you hire a Big X or Mid-Sized Consultancy without doing your homework, vetting the proposal, and vetting the people. [See when should you be using Big X.]

In contrast, a dedicated niche consultancy should have all these tools, and only have masters on the project who do these projects day in and day out. Compared to the bigger consultancies who don’t specialize in these projects, which will have a team of juniors using the manual playbook from the early 2000s, and one lieutenant to guide them. That’s often why sometimes their project bids are five times as much — and why you should be inviting multiple niche best-of-breed consultancies to bid on your project as well as multiple Big X consultancies (including those that are truly focusing on analytics and AI, and you can identify some of these by their recent acquisitions in the area) and be focusing in just as much on the six figure bids for the one that provides the best value, not just the seven figure Big X bids.  (And, FYI, if you invite enough Big X, you might find some come in at six figures and not seven because they have acquired the newer tech, took the time to understand your request, and figured out how they could get you the same value for less cost, leaving you funds for the follow on project where you should consider the Big X!)

(This is also the case for implementations. The Big X always have a rafter on the bench to assign to any project you give them, but there’s no guarantee any of them have ever implemented the system you chose before, or if they did, no guarantee they’ve ever connected it to the systems you need to connect to. You need specialists if you want a new system implemented as cost effectively as possible, especially if its a narrow focused specialist application and not a big enterprise application the Big X always implements. At the end of the day, even if you’re paying those specialists 500 or more an hour because getting a system up in 2 months at 40K is considerably better than a small team of juniors taking 4 months at 200 an hour and a total cost of 80K.  But again, mileage will vary — if the solution you select is a Big X partner, then the Big X will be best.  If it’s a solution they never heard of, you will need to evaluate multiple bids from multiple parties. )

Remember, where any group of vendors on the same page are concerned, All of us is as dumb as One of us!

Don’t fall for the Collectivism MindF6ck! that if multiple parties agree on something, that’s the right answer!  the doctor does NOT want to do say it again, but since a month still is not going by where he’s hearing about niche consultancies being thrown out for “being too cheap” or “obviously not understanding the problem” (which means the enterprise throwing them out is too uninformed and not recognizing that the Big X bids could just as likely the outliers because they aren’t inviting enough expert consultancies to the table), apparently he has to keep writing (and screaming) this truth. (the doctor isn’t saying that you can’t get a million dollars of value from some of these consultancies, just that you won’t by giving them a project they are not suited for;  again, see when should you use big X to identify when that million dollar project will generate a five million ROI — it’s people doing these projects at the end of the day, and where are those people?)

Remember, most of these firms got big in management, or accounting and tax, or marketing and sales consulting, not technology consulting. The only reason these big consultancies started offering these services is because of the amount of money flowing into technology, money which they want, but while the best of the best of the best in more traditional accounting, management, and marketing fields flocked to them, the best of the best in technology flocked to startups and c00l big tech firms  Now, some of these firms double downed, went and recruited those people, built small teams, learned, bought tech companies to expand the team, and now have great offerings in a number of areas.  But we have tens of thousands of tech companies for a reason, not everyone can build every type of technology, and not everyone can be an expert in every type of technology.  So while they will have expertise in some areas, they just can’t have expertise in all areas.  No one can.  Find the best provider for you.  Sometimes it will be Big X.  Sometimes Mid-Market.  Sometimes Niche.  It all depends on your problem at hand.)

And yes, sometimes the niche vendor will be wrong and woefully undersize the project or your needs.  But as per the above, if you don’t do give them a chance, and deep dive into their bid, how will you know?

 

Did you ever try eating a mitten? the doctor bets some of those clients did! (He feels you’re not all there if you think glorified reporting projects should still cost One Million Dollars by default and might actually try to eat your mittens! [Joking, but you get the point.]  Deep analytics projects that require the most advanced tech, especially AI tech, will cost a lot, but standard spend analysis, sales analysis, etc. where we have been iterating and improving on the technology for two decades should not.)

DEAR ENTERPRISE PROCUREMENT SOFTWARE BUYER: THERE ARE NO FREE RFPs!

This originally published June 29 (2024) and is being reprinted due to how important it is to remember as you enter a new budgetary year and seek out new technology.

This shouldn’t have to be said (again), but apparently it does since Zip has relaunched the FREE RFP madness in Source-to-Pay (that began in 2006 when Procuri first aggressively launched the Sourcing, Supplier Management, Contract Management, and Spend Analysis RFPs) with an RFP that is intake heavy, orchestrate light, process deficient, and, like many RFPs before, completely misses some of the key points when going to market for a technology solution. (Especially since there isn’t a single FREE RFP template from a vendor that isn’t intrinsically weighted towards the vendor’s solution, as it’s always written from the viewpoint of what the vendor believes is important.)

the doctor has extensively written about RFPs and the RFP process here on SI in the past, but, at a high level, a good RFP specifies:

  • your current state,
    it does NOT leave this out leaving the vendor to guess your technical and process maturity
  • what you need the solution to do
    NOT just a list of feature/functions
  • what ecosystem you need the solution to work in
    NOT just a list of protocols or APIs that must be supported
  • where the data will live
    and, if in the solution, how you will access it (for free) for exports and off-(vendor-)site backups, do NOT leave this out
  • what support you need from the vendor
    NOT just whether the vendor offers integration / implementation services and their hourly / project rate
  • any specific services you would like from the vendor
    NOT a list of all services you might want to buy someday
  • what the precise scope of the RFP is if it is part of a larger project
    NOT a blanket request for the vendor to “address what they can”
  • what regulations and laws you are subject to that the vendor must support
    NOT just an extensive list of every standard and protocol you can think of
  • what languages and geographies and time zones you need supported
  • any additional requirements the vendor will need to adhere to based on the regulations you or the vendor would be subject to and additional requirements your organization puts in place
    NOT endless forms of every question you can think of that might never be relevant
  • your goal state,
    it does NOT leave the vendor to guess what you are looking for (note that “goal” defines what you want to achieve, it is up to the vendor to define how they will help you achieve it)
  • what (management) processes you use to work with vendors — and —
  • what collaboration tools you make available to vendors and what your expectations are of them

And it is only created after a current state assessment, goal state specification, and key use-case identification so that it is relatively clear on organization needs and vendors have no excuse to provide a poor response.

Furthermore, a good RFP does NOT contain:

  • requests for features/functions you don’t currently need (but you can ask for a roadmap)
  • specific requests for a certain type of AI/ML/Analytics/Optimization/etc. when you don’t even know what that tech actually does — let the vendor tell you, and then show you, how their tech solves their problem
    (after all, there are almost NO valid uses for Gen-AI in S2P)
  • specific requests on the technology stack, when it doesn’t matter if they use Java or Ruby, host on AWS or Azure, etc.
  • requests for audits (tech, environmental, social welfare, etc.) when you haven’t selected the vendor for an award, pending a successful negotiation
  • requests for service professional resumes when you haven’t selected the vendor for an award that includes professional service, pending a successful negotiation
  • requests for financials, when you haven’t selected the vendor for an award pending a successful negotiation
    (because these last three [3] will scare some vendors off and possibly prevent the best vendor for you from even acknowledging your RFP exists)

And, a good RFP, goes to the right providers! This means that you need to select providers with the right type of solution you need before you issue the RFP, and then only issue to providers that you know offer that type of solution. (You can use analyst reports here if you like to identify potential vendors, but remember these maps cannot be used for solution selection! You will then need to do some basic research to make sure the vendor appears to fit the criteria.)

And if there are a lot of potential providers, you may need to do a RFI — Request for Interest / Intent (to Bid) — where you specify at a high level what the RFP you intend to issue is for, and if you get a lot of positive responses, do an initial call with the providers to confirm not only interest but the solution offered is relevant to your organization. (After all, at the end of the day, as The Revelator is quick to point out, it’s as much about the people behind the technology as the technology itself if you expect to be served by the provider.)

And even if you don’t need to an RFI before the RFP, you should still reach out to the vendors you want to respond, let them know the RFP is coming, and let them know you’ve done your research, believe they are one of the top 5 vendors, and are looking forward to their response. (Otherwise, you might find you don’t get as many responses as you’d hope for as vendors prioritize RFPs that they believe they have a good shot at winning vs. random unexpected RFP requests from unknown companies.)

At the end of the day, if you don’t know:

  • what the main categories of S2P+ solutions are
  • what the typical capabilities of a solution type are, what’s below, average or above
  • who the vendors are
  • how to determine your current state of process maturity (and how that compares to the industry, market, and best-in-class) and what a solution could do for you
  • how to evaluate a vendor’s solution
  • how to evaluate a vendor overall
  • how to write a good RFP that balances core business, tech, and solution requirements to maximize your chances of finding a good vendor for you

and the reality is that you most likely don’t (as less than 10% of Procurement departments are world class, as per Hackett research going back to the 2000s where they also determined the typical journey for an organization to become best-in-class in Procurement was 8 years, and that’s the minimum requirement to write a world-class technology RFP), then you should engage help from an expert to help you craft that RFP, be it an independent consultant or firm that specializes in Procurement transformation.

It is also critically important that the firm you select to help you needs to be neutral (not aligned with one solution provider who refers implementations to them in return for potential customer referrals) and that the firm does not rely on analyst maps either!

If you want help, the doctor has relationships with leading, neutral, firms on both sides of the pond who can help you, and who he will work with to make sure the technology / solution component is precisely what you need to get the right responses from vendors. Simply contact the doctor (at) sourcinginnovation [dot] com if you would like help getting it right.

Simply put, getting help with your technology RFP is the best insurance money you can spend. When you considering that, all in, these solutions will cost seven (7) or eight (8) figures over just a few years, you should be willing to spend 5% to 10% of the initial contract value to make sure you get it right. (Especially when there isn’t a single Private Equity Firm that wouldn’t invest in a technology player without doing a six [6], if not seven [7] figure due diligence first … and sometimes the firm will do this and then walk away! At least in your case, when you work with someone who can identify multiple potential vendors, you’re certain to find one at the end of the day.)

Are 45% of Enterprise Leaders Asleep at the Wheel?

According to a short recent article over on Supply Chain Brain on “Next-Gen Supply Chains: The Transformative Role of Supply Chain Leaders in Today’s Business” which quoted a GEP and Economist Study on “Next-Gen Supply Chains: The Transformative Role of Supply-Chain Leaders in Today’s Business”, 55% of enterprises anticipate a major supply chain disruption to strike at any time.

Are 45% of enterprise leaders asleep at the wheel? The chance of a disruption has been getting worse by the day for at least the last decade (if not the last two)! In 2014, Reslinc tracked almost 300 major global supply chain disruptions across natural disasters, factory explosions, labor disputes, power outages, chemical spills and geopolitical upheavals that impacted the supply chains of multiple global companies. That’s almost one major disruption a day, every day!

In 2013, at least 8 out of 10 companies had experienced a major supply chain disruption in the last two years (Supply Chain XChange). By 2014, one year later, 3 in 4 supply chain professionals admitted they experienced a chronic supply chain disruption. (APICS) Since then, natural disasters (fires, hurricanes, tsunamis, etc.) have increased year over year. Geopolitical conflicts, including wars, are on the rise. So are droughts, and now we have the double shipping whammy of the reduced capacity of the Panama canal part of the year and the ongoing Red Sea Crisis. We also have sanctions with unintended consequences, power shifting to the BRICs, world class pandemics, and a country Big X Consultancies made us 100% dependent on willing to shut down entire cities at a moment notice on an impossible zero-tolerance policy. We’re literally at the point where every company has an almost 100% chance of experiencing a considerable disruption in the next 12 months.

So I ask again, are 45% of enterprise executives asleep at the wheel?

Dumb and Dead Company: The Series

For your convenience, here are links to the complete series, classic and modern:

2008 Series

Dumb Company

How Dumb is Your Company
Dumb Company
Dumb Company (The Lyrics)
Dumb Moments in Business not Aerospace, Automotive, or Bailout Related
Why Some Companies are Being Dumb

Dead Company

Dead Company
Dead Company II: If You’re Hoarding Cash …
Dead Company III: Fear is the Enemy
Dead Company IV: Avoiding the GraveYard
Dead Company V: More Ways to Avoid the GraveYard
Dead Company VI: New SI Offerings
Dead Company VII: Even More Ways to Avoid the GraveYard

Your Marketing Really, Really Sucks

Marketing is NOT Optional
How to Build a Bat House
The Brain Gives Pinky a Marketing Lesson
Web Marketer, Don’t Be Misled!

The Market Dilemma

The Market Dilemma I: The Key to Getting Out of this Recession
The Market Dilemma II: Vendors Provide the Vision
The Market Dilemma III: Consultants Provide the Clarity
The Market Dilemma IV: Buyers Win the Battles

… the doctor Can Help!

Vendor Void? the doctor Can Help!
Consulting Confusion? the doctor Can Help!
Buyer Bereft? the doctor Can Help

2024 Series

Prelude

Distant Early Warning: An “Avoiding the Graveyard” Prelude

Dumb Company

How Dumb Is Your Company?
You Admit You Might Be a Dumb Company. How do you avoid the fork in the road that leads to the Graveyard? Part 1
You Admit You Might Be a Dumb Company. How do you avoid the fork in the road that leads to the Graveyard? Part 2

Dead Company

Is Your Potential Vendor a Dead Company Walking? Part 1
Is Your Potential Vendor a Dead Company Walking? Part 2
So You Admit You Might Be A Dead Company Walking. How Do You Avoid The Graveyard? Part 1
So You Admit You Might Be A Dead Company Walking. How Do You Avoid The Graveyard? Part 2
So You Admit You Might Be A Dead Company Walking. How Do You Avoid The Graveyard? Part 3
So You Admit You Might Be A Dead Company Walking. How Do You Avoid The Graveyard? Part 4
So You Admit You Might Be A Dead Company Walking. How Do You Avoid The Graveyard? Part 5
So You Admit You Might Be A Dead Company Walking. How Do You Avoid The Graveyard? Part 6
So You Admit You Might Be A Dead Company Walking. How Do You Avoid The Graveyard? Part 7
So You Admit You Might Be A Dead Company Walking. How Do You Avoid The Graveyard? Part 8

Zombie Company

Zombie Companies Exist Too!

Smart Company

We Want To Be A Smart Company. What Else Can We Do Part 1
We Want To Be A Smart Company. What Else Can We Do Part 2
We Want To Be A Smart Company. Is That It? Part 1
We Want To Be A Smart Company. Is That It? Part 2

M&A Mania

Marketplace Madness
M&A Mania is Coming Again … but will it be the same as last time?

Software Success (or Lack thereof)

Don’t Fall for the Buzzwords!
Demystifying the Marketing Madness for you!
The Procurement Space is Filled with Hogwash! It’s Time We Start Calling It Out!
Want Procurement Technology Success? This is Your Anthem!
Why Do Successful Solution Providers Ruin Everything By Becoming Tech Companies?
Technology DOES NOT Solve Your Talent Problem!