If you won’t admit your TQ (Technical Quotient) is rock-bottom, you won’t spend (or aren’t allowed to spend) budget on an outside expert focussed on Project Assurance, and decide to go ahead with selecting your own ProcureTech solution, then you should make a point to focus your selection around your best practice KPIs. First of all, your management will be happy if you improve against them. Secondly, some of the best KPIs actually require you to have good platforms in place if you are to improve against them.

To demonstrate this, we are going to take the 21 Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for Procurement that Tanya Wade shared because they are a good starting point (as you don’t want too many KPIs as THE REVELATOR pointed out in his analysis). Today, we’re going to start with the first 8 (even though 8 is clearly not enough).

Cost Management

These KPIs will require you to have an e-Sourcing platform in place with good reporting, and/or a spend analysis platform in place with good category management (since, theoretically, if you like the extra work and headache, you can continue to source using e-mail and PDF/Excel templates and get good results if you are guided by a good category management solution and have a good analytics platform to compare the results).

   Cost Savings

You can’t compute, track, and present the cost savings KPI in real-time without an e-Sourcing solution with integrated reporting, or a modern spend analysis solution that updates the cube on every synch with the CLM and ePro system. Both improve your Sourcing focus!

   Cost Avoidance

This requires understanding the current market price vs. the price negotiated, which might be higher than the previous price. If the price paid under the last contract was $1.00 per unit, the current market price, due to supply shortages, is $1.30, but you negotiate $1.15 per unit, you have a cost avoidance of $0.15 per unit, which can be substantial if you need 100,000 units and would have to pay market price without a contract. Without a spend analysis solution that can pull in these market prices and your negotiated prices, it’s very hard to show the cost avoidance your team secures.

   Spend Under Management

This requires a top notch spend analysis system that can suck in all organizational spend across systems, categorize it against a sufficiently defined taxonomy, link each category that is under contract to the associated contract, and then compute spend under management vs. spend available to be managed vs. all organizational spend.

Supplier Performance

These KPIs will require you to have a good supplier management system in place that goes beyond simple onboarding and relationship management system (which even the suites have, even if clumsy), and allows you to truly track supplier performance and supplier ratings.

   Supplier Lead Time

In order to track supplier lead time, you need a good e-Procurement platform that tracks the lead time promised in sourcing, the date the order was placed, and the date the goods receipt was logged in the system. This way, you can track the average lead time across all orders as well as against the promise, and if the supplier is not meeting the promise, you know you need to order earlier and kick off a supplier development project.

   On-time Delivery

You need a good e-Procurement system to track both the delivery date vs. the expected delivery date based on the lead time, but the delivery date vs. the promised delivery date in the acknowledgement, because if a supplier indicates they need extra time for a larger than anticipated order, and you don’t cancel, they are on time if they meet the promised delivery date.

   Supplier Fill Rate

You need a good e-Procurement system to compare the order to the goods receipt to track the fill rate over time. This is critical because if the supplier keeps underdelivering, you risk costly stock-outs, which become more costly if they shut down production lines in a manufacturing or cause customers to start shopping at a competitor’s (online) storefront because the competitor actually has the stock they promise.

   Supplier Defect Rate

You need a good e-Procurement system or a good Supplier Management System to track the number of defects and compare that to the fill rate to track the defect rate, which is very critical, especially if you have SLAs that you are depending on when you make your orders (as a higher than allowed for defect rate could result in stockouts and even expensive production line shutdowns).

   Supplier Rating

This requires a top notch supplier performance management solution (which is a small fraction of the supplier management platforms); a top notch spend analysis system that allows you to build and analyze performance, compliance, and risk cubes; or a top notch SXM+/TP(R/C)M solution that allows you to build Supplier 360 ratings, which is critical to understanding how well your supply base is serving you and how well you are supporting your supply base.

Come back tomorrow for the next set of KPIs that Tanya states you need to address and how they will help you select solutions that might actually realize value for your Procurement organization.