Category Archives: Vendor Review

State of Flux Has the Treatment for Your SRM Ailments: Part II Chicago

In Part I we noted that while State of Flux had the treatment, before we could talk about the treatment, we had to talk about the ailments, but before we did that we needed to give a bit of background on State of Flux’s recent SRM event in Chicago which was the US launch for their most recent Global SRM Research Report, The Business of Supplier Relationships (which is their 7th annual research report on the subject). But before we could talk about either the event or the research, we needed to start with the need — which we nicely summarized using the research from Planning Perspectives which have been doing detailed research in the automotive sector for the last fourteen (14) years, and who found that not only does gross profit per vehicle increase as working relations improve, but that 71% of the positive change is contributeable to changes in the supplier relationship. Let’s repeat that yet again: 71% of profit increase in the automotive sector can be directly correlated to improvement in supplier relations.

The impact of good supplier relations is not restricted to the automotive sector. A major oil and gas company, which also invests heavily in supplier relationship management and innovation, identifies over 100 innovations a year working with their suppliers and realizes an average return of over 750,000 per innovation. Some innovations return millions of dollars to the bottom line. The company realizes almost a billion dollars a year in value from better supplier relations. That’s a damn big number.

How does it do this? It has a good supplier relationship management program. What is this program? While we can’t give specifics, as permission has not been granted for deep coverage, we can give an overview of the solid foundations. Moreover, in addition to a presentation by the major oil and gas company that realizes almost a billion dollars a year in value from better supplier relations, there was also a presentation by a major electronics corporation which also realizes hundreds of millions of dollars a year in returns from their advanced supplier relationship management program. By combining the best advice and insights from both presentations, we can provide a great foundation for your SRM efforts.

FIDO MARC.

Find

Find an opportunity where the organization would benefit from an improved supplier relationship — either through performance analysis, need identification, brainstorming, or even open submissions from employees and suppliers for potential value chain improvements.

Identify

Identify the different ways to take advantage of the opportunity. For example, if on time delivery is poor — does the supplier work with the supplier to lean production, take over shipping (possibly through a 3PL), or work with the supplier on better demand projection so orders can be placed earlier. If production costs are high, does the buyer lead a lean initiative or challenge the current supply base to find a better, cheaper, method with the promise of additional award, or award shift, to the best supplier.

Do

Once the different options are identified, select the best one for implementation and implement it.

Oversee

Manage the process from kick-off through major deliverables, performance improvements, and other milestones. Don’t just set-it-and-forget-it, that never works.

Measure

Measure improvements on a continual basis against an appropriate scorecard identified upon initiative implementation.

Accelerate

Once all of the key stakeholders are on board and everything is going smoothly, accelerate implementation or, if appropriate, replicate (a variation of) the initiative with another supplier that could also benefit.

Reward

Reward suppliers for their success, either with an increased margin or additional business and publicly recognize them either at annual supplier recognition events, publications, or on the company website.

Collaborate

Continually collaborate with the supplier to look for additional improvements that can be made to tweak the process and additional opportunities that can be pursued in the future.

SRM is really a simple process. However, as with every other initiative that can bring great value to an organization, the devil is in the details. In our next post, we are going to discuss some of the tips and tricks that these, and other, organizations have used to accelerate their SRM programs and achieve great results, including some of the tips and tricks outlined in State of Flux‘s publications.

State of Flux Has the Treatment for Your SRM Ailments: Part I The Need

But before we talk about the treatment, we’re going to talk about State of Flux‘s recent event in Chicago which was the US launch for their most recent Global SRM Research Report, The Business of Supplier Relationships, which is their 7th annual research report on the subject. We’ll talk about this report too, but first, let’s talk about the event, or more appropriately, the need for SRM as explained by the event.

Large organizations, including those desperate for savings, around the globe are leaving millions on the table on a regular basis. Some of this is due to a failure to capture negotiated savings (as per AMR’s classic series on Reaching Sourcing Excellence), and some of this is due to a failure to maximize the value of supplier relationships.

The heart of the matter is that the value delivered by your organization to its customers is ultimately dependent upon the value created and delivered by your suppliers that manufacture the product, pack the product for delivery, and provide warranty and repair services for the product. If the product is poor, delivered late (which results in stock outs and lost sales), packaged very poorly (which results in a large number of damaged units on delivery), or the warranty and repair services are slow and leave much to be desired, your customers won’t be happy with you, and there goes your perceived value and future revenue.

In other words, suppliers are critical to delivering the value that you promise your customers. But they are also critical to delivering the value required by your organization. Regardless of how good the products are, your organization needs higher quality products at a lower cost, new products to attract new marketshare, leaner production, lower cost delivery, and other renovations and innovations that add to the top line while shaving from the bottom line. This won’t happen without supplier involvement.

And suppliers won’t be involved unless the relationship is collaborative. Even though CAPS Research (Japan) has been telling us for almost a decade that collaborative supply management is the key to success, the concept hasn’t taken off much (yet) here in North America. While collaborative supply management has penetrated the Hackett Group top 8%, it’s not daily practice in the Sourcing and Procurement groups at many companies. But it should be.

The fact of the matter is there is considerable research, in addition to State of Flux’s Global SRM Research report (which has now been published 7 years in a row), that demonstrates the value of SRM. Consider the research undertaken by Planning Perspectives Inc. on the automotive sector over the last 14 years, which was presented at the Chicago event, which has not only found that the gross profit per vehicle increases as working relations improve (as per the Working Relations Index), but that 71% of the positive change is contributeable to changes in the supplier relationship. Let’s repeat that: 71% of profit increase in the automotive sector can be directly correlated to improvement in supplier relations. Not e-Procurement. Not spend analysis. Not strategic sourcing. Supplier relations. In addition, the more collaborative the working relation, the greater the price recessions offered up by suppliers in response to requested price reductions, even if the requested price reduction requested is lower than the average price reduction request. More specifically, companies with good supplier relations typically achieve 8% to 12% more price concessions than their peers.

Moreover, when there is a good working relationship:

  • suppliers are more willing to share new technology and innovations without the up-front assurance of a purchase order
  • suppliers are willing to invest in new technology in anticipation of new or additional business
  • suppliers are willing to communicate openly and honestly, which prevents surprises down the road that can lead to stock-outs or supply chain disruptions
  • suppliers are willing to support the organization above and beyond contractual obligations

And a good working relationship stems from supplier relationship management. In our next post we’ll delve deeper into some of the highlights of the State of Flux Chicago event before we reveal some of the most interesting findings from this year’s report.

Freightos: Flippin’ Freight Quotes Faster than a Fleet-Footed Feline on Guarana

A couple of years ago we introduced you to Freightos in our post on how they were helping to bring freight into the modern era. Even today, when we are over half-way through the teens, many Procurement professionals, when they call up a forwarder for a spot quote, still have to wait two or three (or even eight) days for a response. It’s absurd. (See this hilarious video on The Great Freight Experiment.) And when the buyer has to get a shipment from Shanghai to San Francisco, which requires a truck, ocean freight, and another truck or a truck, air freight, and another truck, it’s a nightmare waiting for all the quotes to come in.

Freightos was founded to deal with this problem. In order to address this problem and speed up the freight quote time, on or off contract, in the global market place, Freightos was built as a technology platform that enables an on-line network of global freight forwarders to provide instant spot-rate and on-contract quotes for point-to-point global shipments when a (potential) customer needs them.

When a forwarder, or freight-forwarder / 3PL, signed up for the Freightos network, and uploaded their standard buy and sell rate tables for ocean, air, and land-based shipping for all of the routes they serviced, customers could access the forwarder’s portal on the Freight OS network and get almost instantaneous quotes for the route(s) of their choice. All the buyer had to do was specify the origin, the destination, some basic load characteristics, the desired pick-up date, the allowable modes, whether or not the load is hazardous, if insurance is required, if a customers brokerage is used, whether or not nearby ports / airports can be used, and click quote. Within seconds, the buyer could get the quickest delivery quote, the cheapest quote, and some alternate options from any forwarder that had a rate table in the system and chose to make it public. They could also request custom quotes from a forwarder as well, which they might want to do if they were willing to commit to a certain volume over a certain period of time.

Since it’s launch, Freightos, which primarily targeted freight forwarders and 3PLs, has been extending its platform and its target audience, now also serving (and targeting) enterprise shippers (in traditional logistics divisions) and e-commerce shippers as well. Since it’s initial launch, Freightos has added two major features:

  • the marketplace
    where all forwarders can list their public rates and any buyer can easily search public quotes (without a forwarder having to share quotes with them), compare, and book quotes
  • contract management
    which permits a buying organization to upload all of their contracts, which are included in search results, if the route is covered, and allow a buyer to see their contracted rate vs. the market rates

As well as a few other valuable features for enterprise shippers that include:

  • tariff management
    that allows freight providers (including 3PLs and forwarders) to define all of the associated tariffs and buyers to include all the tariffs defined by their contracted routes
  • spend visibility
    that allows enterprise shippers to see how much is being spent by lane, forwarder, region
  • business intelligence
    that allows enterprise shippers to slice and dice the spend visibility and contract data
  • real-time multi-currency support
  • powerful filtering
    that allows an enterprise shipper to include or exclude forwarders, forwarders, transport modes (and specify ocean only or air only), select and deselect nearby ports, etc.

Freightos is a very powerful solution that will soon be Procurement’s best friend. How so? Stay tuned, as Freightos will be launching their Procurement portal early next year which will build on the powerful enterprise shipping portal they have now, but with features and functions targeted to make your life as a Procurement professional much easier when you are trying to build those total cost of ownership models during your multi quarter and multi-year sourcing events.

Shortlist.co Should Be On Your ShortList for Agency & Services Management

In our last post, we noted that most Sourcing and (e-) Procurement platforms are not appropriate for Marketing and Services Management. We gave a number of reasons for this, but the big ones can be summarized as:

  • lack of a creative, digital, or advertising suppliers in a supplier network
  • lack of an appropriate project definition for marketing projects
  • lack of an appropriate workflow for marketing or services projects
  • lack of appropriate collaboration for internal and external partners

Marketing, unlike Procurement, needs to be as focussed on the relationship and the creative as Procurement needs to be focussed on the cost and the deliverable. It’s all about the message, the delivery, and the brand. That’s more than just a DVD with 30 seconds of a TV spot, a zipped download of a new website, or a document outlining a new brand building campaign.

That’s why marketing needs a solution that allows it to:

  • identify new suppliers it would not find otherwise that might be able to serve its creative, digital, or advertising needs to help it increase returns while keeping costs in line
  • define marketing projects in a way that allows for meaningful RFPs, evaluations, and workflows
  • allow Marketing to collaborate with Procurement, Engineering, and other internal stakeholders in a manner that is conscious of organizational strategy and budgets
  • allows Marketing to collaborate with suppliers and track progress, deliverables, milestone, and overall supplier relationship with marketing suppliers

Shortlist.co, which will be doing a major North American launch early next year, is a new web-based platform that will allow a Marketing organization to do all of this. This platform has three major elements:

Vetted, Indexed, Supplier Network

The platform contains thousands of global suppliers in the advertising, creative, and digital space that are vetted by Shortlist.co as real and capable of performing the advertised service offerings. They are indexed by location (from region down to city level), size, and offering.

Services Project Management

Everything in the platform revolves around a project. Project creation is quite simple, as all a user has to do is enter a name (which can be changed later), and optionally assign it to a campaign (which can be done later) and a category for budgetary purposes (which can be done later and changed later as well). Once a project is created, a user provides a description, creates and / or attaches an RFX, selects suppliers to distribute the request to, defines a response due date, and the project is launched. Alternatively, if this is a project that is undertaken on a regular basis, the user might just select a template, make a few alterations, update the supplier list, define the response dates, and launch. Then, the user defines a review team, sends out the review invitations, and when the responses come back, the review team can independently and collectively review and comment on the proposals. Once one has been accepted, the budget can be revised and recategorized, and at all times the team can see how much of the budget has been allocated year to date and how it breaks down into campaigns and categories (such as UX design, web site development, tv spots, internet video, social media campaigns, etc.).

Collaborative RFX Capability

While RFX is not unique to the platform, it is extremely well integrated into the project and has all of the functionality one would expect in the creation of a detailed RFX for services. In addition, the tool supports side by side comparison of multiple responses to make evaluation by each team member easy, and can aggregate the scorings from multiple team members to allow for organizational ranking, allowing each team member’s input to be taken into account during agency selection. Furthermore, the weighting adjusts to the actual number of reviewers who have commented on an item, so that if only one of three reviewers has an opinion, a 9 (out of 10) does not become a weighted 3.

Reporting

The insights capability is still being built out, but right now the platform also supports an initial set of project and partner comparison reports that allow an organization to answer, at a minimum:

  • how award allocations compare to budgets
  • how spend breaks down by category and campaign
  • which suppliers have the most projects
  • which suppliers have the most spend (by category)
  • the success rate of each supplier

The platform, which is being designed to be the marketing and service award, management, and collaboration tool between stakeholders and suppliers, fills a big need in many mid-size organizations today which have nothing to appropriately manage marketing and service spend, and even less that Marketing and Service Management can use. As a 100% multi-tenant SaaS solution, this allows a marketing organization to start immediately with no IT, or Procurement, support but yet involve IT and Procurement in all of their projects. Shortlist.co is definitely a solution that should be on your organization’s shortlist for agency & services management

Your Supply Chain is in Flux. Last Chance to Find Out How Big those Oscillations Are!

A few weeks ago we asked if your SRM was in a State of Flux because good SRM is critical to smooth supply chain operations. Later or sooner your supply chain is going to be disrupted, and without good supplier relations, you will not have any notice, or any help dealing with the disaster that is headed your way. (The chances of your organization NOT not having a major supply disruption in the next 12 months are less than 15%. Think about that.)

Then, a couple of weeks ago we remind you that your SRM, despite what you may think, is in a state of flux and that you should find out where. Especially now that you have the chance to do it for free. State of Flux, a provider of Supplier Relationship Management software and services, and the initiators of the ground-breaking SRM Research Report, are undertaking the seventh annual study which aims to understand not only the state of the practice in SRM, but what is needed for companies to get the executive sponsorship and support they need to not only master SRM but excel.

Last year’s 2014 publication was one of the most ambitious Supplier Relationship Management reports ever published — clocking in at 216 pages of data, results, and expert interpretation and full of valuable, actionable, insights that any organization can use to advance their SRM practices. This year’s study, which will likely have over 500 global participants, should be equally insightful and all those organizations that participate get full access to the results and underlying research ahead of the market. You can measure up against your peers, and improve, well before the average, laggard, organization (which will only have restricted data access if not a State of Flux customer), has a chance to register, download, and review the final report.

Considering that this study will only take about 45 minutes of your time, the reward is infinitely more valuable than the cost! But you’re running out of time. The deadline for participation in this year’s study is July 10th. (Next Friday.) Don’t miss out on this great opportunity — take the 2015 SRM Survey today!