Category Archives: Supplier Management

Is it time for Supply Driven Demand Creation?

For the past two decades, the goal was JIT DDS — Just in Time Demand Driven Supply — and the ultimate in Sourcing and Procurement was sourcing and procuring to optimize that mode of operation as it minimized costs and maximized revenue. In theory at least. And for a while, more often than not, it did in practice.

When predictability and reliability is high on both the customer side and the supply side, JIT DDS is the ultimate source-to-supply goal. Optimizing delivery time (JIT) minimizes inventory cost and waste, allows shipments to be right sized, and makes cashflow more predictable as spend appropriately correlated to sales. Accurate forecasting (DDS) optimizes sourcing events, minimizes stock-outs, and minimizes waste.

But what happens when:

  • customer demand is unpredictable due to rapid changes in inflation, employment, tarrifs, and other factors
  • supply lines get caught off with little to no warning thanks to strikes, pandemics, wars, and droughts
  • raw materials get scarce or suddenly become unavailable

Supply Stops. Then sales stop. Everything breaks. And there’s no quick fix.

Now, that’s why you have visibility, monitoring, multiple sources of supply, mitigation plans, etc. That works when there are alternate sources, alternate routes, and enough time to react — but when the sources depend on the same raw material or rare component, and that becomes unavailable, one or more of your product lines are brought to a halt. And there’s nothing you can do.

Except for preventing that situation from ever happening in the first place.

The only way to do that is to ensure you are not dependent on raw materials or rare components that could disappear literally overnight.

Which means that if you revenue is heavily dependent on products (and categories) that rely on these raw materials, you need to do your best to identify alternates wherever possible and if those alternates don’t allow you to make roughly the same product, you’ll have to work with marketing and sales to shift demand based on available supply.

In some categories, that won’t be possible — you can’t make certain electronics without rare earths, but you can shift to product designs that minimize them. Depending on the rare earth in question, any change in quantity will affect the design options — not just in material composition, but in size, performance, and cost. If the cost goes up, or performance goes down, it could be difficult to convince the market an alternate design or product is better, but if there are no other real options, that’s what has to happen.

Which is why success in turbulent times is dependent on supply driven demand — and, more importantly, an abandonment of JIT to balanced inventory where enough supply is kept on hand to survive the average delay expected by an interruption, with a buffer.

Managing Your Relationship Off of a Scorecard? I give you an F!

Unless it’s a two-way scorecard, then I give you a C- for effort.

Don’t get it wrong, SI likes two-way scorecards. It’s the only scorecard ever developed for Procurement that’s any good. There’s no other way to properly capture subjective opinions which can be just as important as objective relationship measurements. If there are misunderstandings or personnel issues, a focus on improving processes or efficiency based on objective measurements will be all for nought since whichever side believes the problem lies with the other will be adverse to making any effort (and if you’re only capturing one side, who knows if you’re capturing the right side).

But many SPM platforms define the (two-way) scorecard as their entire foundation of relationship management when it’s just a minor tool. A very important tool in the toolkit … like the measuring tape that a carpenter shouldn’t do anything without — as no relationship manager should be without a two-way scorecard, but still a tool.

But that’s just a tool to measure alignment. You need to focus more on ensuring there’s alignment to start with. This means you primarily need to:

  • ensure you select the right supplier in the selection process
  • clearly define what you expect from the engagement
  • define milestones and key metrics you will be monitoring and agree on the definitions
  • regularly meet to discuss improvement, stagnation, decline

ensure you select the right supplier in the selection process

Your selection process must ensure:

  • you vet them for any risks or red flags that go against your policies
  • you clearly define the product / service requirements
  • you analyze their offering against those requirements
  • you analyze their culture

Frankly, you’ll never have good performance if

  • the relationship ends up being short term because you missed a red flag that legal or risk management won’t put up with
  • you don’t define precisely what you need in functionality and service level requirements
  • you don’t ensure the supplier’s product or service isn’t a great fit for you
  • their culture doesn’t mesh with yours

clearly define what you expect from the engagement

It’s not just saying you want a product that does A through ZZZ or a(n outsourced) service that provides you a detailed transformation plan, takes over your procurement function for tail spend, or helps you onboard your suppliers. It’s a

  • detailed description of what functions you are looking to transform, whether you are just looking for process redefinition support or the selection and implementation of new technologies and automation platforms, and how much project management and assurance you need
  • detailed definition of what tail spend is in terms of categories, amount, frequencies; what type of tail spend can be catalog/punch out, which should be quoted, and when it should be passed back and included in a (modified) category or treated as strategic spend; along with detailed platform requirements, the data collection and model requirements (for integration with your master data and analytics systems), and whether or not it’s okay to use a GPO
  • what processes you use now, the data required for every supplier as well as specific data requirements by category or region or spend, who is responsible for support during on-boarding and post-on-boarding and for what, what systems should be integrated with, and so on.

Just like there’s no success without clear requirements, there’s no foundation for a good relationship without clear requirements of expectations.

co-define milestones and key metrics you will be monitoring and agree on the definitions

In order for a party to perform well, they need to know precisely

  • what they are being judged on
  • how the metrics are defined
  • what the ultimate goals are

The reality is that what get’s measured gets managed, and the management that happens is that which aligns the performance to what improves, or at least maintains, the metrics — whether it is the right thing to do, or not. For instance, if your supplier is hooked on your early payment discount offering as a form of financing (it’s not, by the way, but that doesn’t stop most organizations from treating it like it is), and you make that availability contingent on a 95%+OTD metric, and every shipment that arrives the next calendar day, even if the difference is 4:00 pm for end-of-day unload vs 8:00 am for start of day unload, is counted as late, your supplier is going to do everything it can to not only be on time, but attempt to get all deliveries out early to make sure construction, weather, or unexpected delays don’t stop the shipment, even if that means paying a trucker to sit in a parking lot with unloaded inventory for 2 days! And if getting it out that early requires factory workers to go from 10 hour shifts to 12 hour OT shifts, which makes them tired and increases error rates after hour 9, so be it! End of the day, you’ll get your OTD and pay more for delivery and have to deal with higher defects and waste and all of the tracking and return costs incurred. If the goal in introducing OTD was just to minimize customer stock-outs, you didn’t exactly achieve it because if you end up having to reject a (considerable portion of a) shipment due to poor quality, you’re stocked out (and the OTD metric gives them a pat on the back).

This is why we said “co-definition” — both parties should work together to define (blended) metrics (and scorecards) that will not only achieve the goal, but allow each party to be measured fairly.

regularly meet to discuss improvement, stagnation, decline

Emailing your counterpart a scorecard and saying “You did great here, acceptable here, but sucked in these parts — Do Better” is not relationship management because it doesn’t even imply any sort of relationship. Relationship management is developing the collaboration and desire for both parties to work together, not just pointing out deficiencies in a scorecard and saying “do better”.

All of this means that if you want to do true relationship management, you need to build in relationship management into everything you do because just defining a scorecard-driven program after the fact when the supplier performance isn’t too your liking isn’t relationship management.

How Do You Execute Effective Supplier Performance Management in Today’s World?

This is an interesting topic. Many books have been written about this; dozens of specialized software vendors and consultancies have cropped up over the past two and half decades to address this; many top tier analyst firms have been putting out frameworks for almost three decades; and every Big X consultancy has their detailed methodology, 200 page strategy and implementation deck, and a dozen or so publications on their website documenting numerous benefits and case studies.

In fact, there’s so much material out there that if you asked your favourite clod or chat, j’ai pété instance to write you a book, put together an implementation plan, prepare an executive presentation, prepare an implementation plan for your team, and prepare a training plan for your supply base, chances are, believe it or not (and the author rarely does) any particular Gen-AI instance is likely to do a decent job of it because there is so much nearly identical material on the subject that the models are likely to be decently weighted to generate a decent facsimile of the material.

But here’s the question — is everything that has been defined, prescribed, optimized, and re-prescribed over the last two and a half decades the right approach? This might appear dumb on first read and sound dumber on first vocalization, but it’s actually pretty poignant. Just because whatever has been prescribed for the past two decades has worked just fine, that doesn’t mean it’s optimal. And just like modern drugs can deal with most symptoms of any ailment you might get, at least at first, that doesn’t mean they address the root cause. And if they don’t address the root cause, you can still get really sick, and even die if the symptoms the drugs are addressing are covering up a long term, slowly progressing, [incurable] cancer or autoimmune disease.

Plus, certain practices are designed to achieve end-states with certain assumptions in mind that are based on expected market conditions and activities that are expected to optimize to those conditions. In other words, its assumptions across the board (on what to do) based on assumptions across the board (on what is success) based on expectation across the board where the assumptions on what to do assumes that what got a result before will again (without any proper definition of the scenario in which it worked or proof that its effective) and the assumptions on what is success is only based on what has achieved the best results (and not the best results that could be obtained) and the expectations are simply hopes that what came before will come again.

Of course, given the reliability of some of the methodologies out there, the consistent results obtained by the best-in-class providers, and the wide-spread adoption of certain methodologies, it’s hard to argue with the assumption, the underlying assumptions, and the expectations because, for most organizations that adopt the methodologies, and stick to them, they get great results!

But what happens when the results flatline?

I’m asking because I expect there’s a chance it will happen, and possibly sooner than I expect, for companies who are already practicing good supplier performance management. There are a number of reasons for this. As per above:

  • effective is not necessarily optimal
  • you can get short-term results treating the symptoms, but you can’t get long term results unless you address the route cause
  • everything is based on assumptions, on assumptions, against expectations

and

  • market conditions are (drastically) changing
  • all good things must come to an end
  • managing after the fact is not the same as laying the groundwork for success

These are the reasons in particular I suspect there is a chance that current SPM frameworks and efforts might crash.

All Good Things Must Come To An End

This universal truth holds true for anything with a limit. Since every action has a limit when it comes to the minimum time required for completion, the maximum number of uses or lifespan of a product, the value that can be delivered against a metric, and so on.

Combine this with the definition of supplier performance management which focusses on measuring, analyzing, and managing vendor performance to cut costs, minimize risks, and drive continuous improvement, this means that SPM has a limit. This, of course, is nothing new — we’ve known this for decades. But, applied properly, SPM has worked spectacularly for decades because:

  • only so many suppliers can be measured, managed, and developed at a time … so there’s an endless supply of projects
  • suppliers constantly change … increasing the endless supply of projects
  • technology in our space has kept improving, allowing for slow, continual, improvement
  • the global trade situation was relatively static for two decades
  • most companies haven’t, and still aren’t, doing SPM in earnest
  • SPM is done by humans, who aren’t perfect and continuously make mistakes

It will continue to work spectacularly for the majority of organizations the majority of the time as a result of all of these reasons. But it may soon start sputtering for some organizations. The reasons being:

  • the suppliers not measured, managed, and developed are the ones that will need it the most and cause you the most problems
  • suppliers will suddenly become (effectively) unavailable unexpectedly — often before the contract expires
  • technology has stalled in SPM
  • the global trade dynamic has drastically shifted and has entered a new age of continual instability
  • those doing SPM are running on outdated assumptions
  • Agentic AI is being injected everywhere, and decreasing the reliability and effectivness

This means that the days might be numbered for SPM-in-a-box, which is pretty much what you get because most vendors / consultancies who do SPM just do SPM.

Which is concern #1.

More importantly, SPM is pointless if the supplier is going to suddenly become unavailable or unable to produce the products that you need.

A sanction, border closing (due to conflict or epidemic with pandemic potential), seaway closing, economic collapse, etc. can all take a supplier out of the picture overnight. Chances are you’re monitoring for this for your (most) strategic suppliers, can usually see it coming with enough warning to at least take some emergency measures.

However, chances are that this sub-tier supplier, or it’s sub-tier supplier, aren’t monitoring for potential disruptions like you are. What happens when those suppliers suddenly shut down or become unavailable. Then your supplier is unable to produce the products you depend on, and it’s essentially the same as that supplier suddenly becoming unavailable.

Which means you need Supply Chain Visibility in order to not only select appropriate suppliers, but ensure your suppliers are selecting appropriate sub-tier suppliers and, if not, help them to do so. However, not only are most companies still not adopting SCV solutions, but they aren’t part of standard SPM.

In addition, it’s not just availability, it’s supply line, and dependency. Rare earths are becoming more rare, oil keeps going up, and many renewable commodities in the food stuff categories are in relatively short supply due to population increase, droughts, and wildfires. Sufficient supply demands that dependency on any one raw material be minimized to the extent possible. This means that PLM, and especially design, alternate designs, and substitution capability is becoming more and more critical. But this is completely ignored by today’s SPM that just focusses on making the production process more efficient, not the product.

In other words, while the classic SPM theory is fine, and the implementation close to flawless in a handful of suppliers, the impact will soon be minimal to non-existent if they continue to address the wrong problem or try to address the right problem in a vacuum.

Now that process performance is often not the critical problem, the effectiveness of traditional SPM may begin to wane — fast.

Which brings us back to the starting question:

How Do You Execute Effective Supplier Performance Management in Today’s World?

I don’t have a good answer yet, but I believe you need to find one before the question becomes relevant.

It’s Time For a Resurgence of Keiretsu!

Keiretsu, which can be briefly described as a long continual business relationship, in one way or another, has been a significant force in the Japanese economy for over four decades and, despite its long and varied history, criticisms, the Structural Impediments Initiative, and economic downturns, is still a strong foundation for many supply chain relationships in Japan. But now it needs to be the foundation for supply chain relationships the world over.

Twenty years ago we were in a period of (rising) globalization. Opening markets with the (first) cold war behind us. Limited, contained, conflicts. Relatively stable fuel prices. Piracy (off the Ivory Coast) was being curbed. And with the introduction of modern e-Sourcing and e-Procurement tools, it was easier by the day to invite more (and more) suppliers to events, to swap them out on a whim for (semi-)commodities, and keep supply lines fluid.

Relationships went on the decline for all but the most strategic suppliers because they weren’t necessary. But that was then, this is now.

Now we have anti-globalization and isolationism. Sanctions and closing markets. Escalating conflicts and closures of seas, straits, and critical shipping lanes. Rising and unpredictable fuel prices. A resurgence of piracy. Suppliers failing as a result of a myriad of tariffs, trade wars, border closings, shipping lanes, etc. Carriers failing as a result of rapid rising in fuel prices, insurance, increased theft, seizures, and blockades.

Suppliers who can actually fulfill your orders that you can actually receive products from that were once a dime a dozen to add to the RFP are now few and far between.

That means, now, more than anything, with risk and volatility increasing by the day, relationships matter again. Relationships that are:

  • long term: to create economic efficiencies that can help both parties survive the economic storm
  • knowledge sharing: workforce and even executives
  • business sharing: both parties buy from each other when possible and introduce throughout their partner networks
  • stock sharing: of the financial or physical variety — that reinforces each partner’s financial status when relevant or ensures security of cross-supply when stock-outs must be avoided
  • mutually beneficial asymmetrical trade: that works best for both parties

And relationships that can:

  • move low-value-add production to subsidiaries
  • ensure continuous high quality production capability to avoid excess production & consumer problems
  • improve risk management, especially with regards to variable or uncertain demand
  • ensure increased sales mean a corresponding increase for subsidiaries that are essential to the parent company’s survival
  • prevent critical confidential IP and technological information from being disclosed to short-term suppliers that may not be so obliged to keep it in the future, despite agreements

Which can help keep your supply chains running smooth in these troubled times.