Category Archives: rants

It’s Not Outcomes. It’s Capability.

And that’s why outcomes is a dirty word! (Part I and Part II)

More specifically, it’s about capability, knowledge, the ability to be self-sufficient, and continual improvement.

Our rant focussed on the fact that the entire point of “outcome”-based pricing was to not only lure you away from more affordable products and services (especially if you were willing to do just a little bit more yourself), but take away your self-sufficiency, capability, and even knowledge and ensure your entire existence slowly became 100% dependent on the vendor for key processes. That you’d have no choice but to keep using them because you lost the capability to take the function back in-house. That you’d be the next mark in the grift that keeps on taking.

A big problem with “outcomes”, and another reason that it is a dirty word, is that it’s always focussed on “metrics” that have an impact on “the bottom line” today in a manner that the C-Suite can see on the balance sheet. Since the point of a business is to make profit, all of the “outcome”-pricing vendors argue that it’s the right approach.

While you should get “results”, that’s not the only thing you should be measuring, and it should not be the focus of your measurements. Because when you focus only on “results”, the focus is whatever gets you the best results, and, more exactly, what gets you the best results TODAY. That means you will make decisions that will jeopardize the potential for mid, and definitely long, term results in exchange for better results today that will please the client, your boss, the C-Suite, and/or the shareholders.

A great example of the danger of “outcome”-focus is classic sourcing — and the introduction of e-auctions (which are surging again because people forget the long-term impacts of auction over-use) that kicked our space off!

When awards are reduced to lowest price, and the volumes are large enough that a few contracts can sustain a struggling supplier, especially in tough economic times, suppliers will often sacrifice almost all of their margin just to get an award. This results in a great, immediate, win for the buyer, who can show a huge savings on the balance sheet, but it’s actually a huge risk. If the supplier sacrifices too much margin and costs rise too quickly, their viability is at risk. If they unexpectedly go out of business, the buyer has to find new supply quickly, and if the market becomes tight, this could skyrocket costs or even result in costly stock-outs or, even worse, production line shutdowns. The savings not only disappear over night, but costs increase. And even if the supplier doesn’t go bankrupt, when you go back to market, after a few years, if inflation was low, you might save 1% to 2%, but typically the best case scenario is you find someone who can match the price. However, what typically happens is that the price increases, sometimes by a lot! Why? Because the focus was on getting the best price now, versus coming up with a plan to ensure prices, or at least production costs, continued to decrease over time. Instead of looking for a supplier who would continually invest in better technology, renewable materials and energy, process improvement, etc. to keep costs down, you look for a supplier who’ll cut every corner they can to get a good price now. If you do a strategic engagement and find the first type of supplier, and enter into a long term contract where they know they can continue to invest in improvement, they’ll likely come back with a solution, and a contract, that guarantees a continual cost decrease year-over-year. This would actually benefit you more because not only you would you be able to claim an “outcome” every single year, but you know you have a supplier you can count on to deliver! (And you won’t have to explain the cost increase next time you go to market.)

In order to be a successful business, you don’t have to just profit this year, but you have to profit next year, and the year after that, and the year after that, and so on.

What this really means is that you need to be:

  • instituting processes that will allow you to not only be more efficient, but get more efficient (with experience) over time,
  • implementing supporting technologies that help you continually increase efficiency, including automation solutions that requires less and less exception management
  • increasing your knowledge and capability, so you can always make the best decisions, use the best solutions, and know when a third party can be more efficient or more cost effective (because it’s either a part-time position that’s not worth the hire internally or a function that’s not core to your business and you’d rather it be managed externally until such time as it makes sense to reclaim the function)
  • identifying metrics that focus on capturing process improvement, increasing capabilities, capturing knowledge (for future generations of HUMAN employees), and that result in improvement year-over-year

and NOT focussing on destructive one-time outcomes (that will hurt you later, and possibly a lot more than you realize).

“Outcomes” is Just Code For …

You’re Getting Ripped Off.

But let’s back up.

THE REVELATOR recently explained Why He’s Done Tracking Gartner (spoiler: they are simply not designed to solve the problem of implementation success in the AI era), and in the post he made two key observations:

1) “Subscription revenue continues regardless of outcome. Predictions expire and are replaced. There are no consequences for failure.”

In other words, they are dangling outcomes, but not doing anything to ensure you get them, and because they are never to blame, the subscription revenue continues. However, it’s only fair to point out that this is NOT unique to Gartner! It’s the Big Analyst Firm Model. It’s why the doctor doesn’t work for Big Analyst Firms (because they refuse to update their methodologies which are decades out of date and hinder more than they help), and why I worked for Spend Matters for years until the buyout (by a PE firm that, frankly, almost destroyed it as they completely stopped all innovation) and why the doctor deeply respects boutique firms like HFS Research because they keep trying to modernize their offerings to provide real value and guide clients to real results.

2) “What scales in this industry is engagement—not outcomes.”

And this is dead-on. The rhetoric is being thrown around by way too many services(-adjacent) firms (who want to charge based on it) and software firms (who won’t charge based on it). And all of it is usually to mislead you on what you should be getting and what you should be paying!

Here’s the reality you’re not being told when they want to, or refuse to, price on outcomes.

1) If a services firm wants to charge based only outcomes, it’s because it expects to make way more money that way. It’s common in audit recovery, contract re-negotiation, and SaaS consolidation because these expert firms know just how much you are overpaying if you’ve never done these efforts before. They also know that they can use cheap software and benchmarks and experience to quickly find the savings you can’t, and make big bucks off of you by charging on outcomes (and not effort and/or software).

2) If a services-as-software firm wants to charge based on outcomes, especially an “Agentic AI” powered one, it’s because their true costs are higher than they let on (due to hefty Gen-AI compute costs) and they aren’t viable offering a classic subscription-based service model.

3) If a software firm refuses to price in (a hybrid cost model based on) outcomes, it’s because they know you won’t get those outcomes unless they (as a firm) put in a lot of work training, guiding, and helping you achieve those outcomes. When their model is “install and backhaul” (out of there) until renewal time (because if they don’t hit their unattainable PE-defined sales numbers, they will be told to hit the road, so they have to spend all their time on sales).

The reality is “outcome-based pricing” only encourages success when done right — and done right is done in a manner that encourages, as THE REVELATOR notes, engagement-focussed.

That’s why, in our post on why you should STOP PAYING PROCURETECH/FINTECH ADVISORIES A DOLLAR JUST TO LOSE THREE DOLLARS!, we told you this is how you should negotiate, and pay for, software and services when “outcomes” are involved:

1. For software, you will pay a base annual fee for the platform that will cover 150% of their base hosting costs, so they won’t lose, and then a percentage of transactions, identified savings through sourcing events, contract value, etc. where the percentage is calculated such that if you save 100% of their promised savings, they will make 50% more than what you would pay on a fixed cost after negotiation -— if they are so confident in their claims, this should be a no-brainer for them. (But if they won’t agree to this, it should tell you what ROI you can actually expect!)

2. For GPO agreements, you will pay a fixed amount on each transaction, calculated based upon the expected savings before you sign the contract, and if they can deliver the savings, you will definitely be using them regularly —- and, as with the Tech Provider — you will calculate this so that they win bigger than if you pay them a fixed cost IF they generate a return for you!

3. For services (outsourcing), you will pay a fixed rate per hour that is enough to cover the assigned personnel cost (their salary plus 30% overhead), and any compensation beyond that will be dependent on the department delivering an ROI beyond a certain amount (which is the amount required to cover the basic fee you are paying them); and again, you’ll fix the compensation such that if they deliver 100% or more of what they promise, they will win big too. (And if they deliver less, while their costs will be covered, their profit will be next to 0.)

There are MANY reasons you are NOT ready for AI!

A few weeks ago, we told you that if you think you’re ready for AI, you’re not ready for AI because, even though the vast majority of you are chasing AI, only a minority of you are ready to even investigate it. And we mean investigate, not use. That depends on whether or not there are any relevant AI solutions for you needs — and despite the repeated BS claims by the big AI vendors, there may not yet be any!

And it’s not just because you haven’t

  • admitted you’re only chasing AI because of FOMO and FUD
  • assessed where you are
  • realized you are generations of tech behind
  • determined you just don’t have the right resources

But it goes beyond that.

In order to have any hope of succeeding with AI:

You need great data and great Master Data Management
… but you don’t even know where your data is! You have no governance policies, no management processes to ensure data is kept up to date (or even backed up unless you have already suffered a data loss and determined losing that specific data would be disastrous), and no clue about what that entails. And even if you realize that you need (master) data management, you won’t get the C-Suite to sign off on it, even if you call it E-MDMA and tell them they’re getting free samples!
You need a good IT infrastructure, with context-based integration and workflow capability
… but you have no central strategy for data integration, system orchestration, or enterprise workflows, and your IT infrastructure is whatever cloud your ERP runs on. AI, especially Gen-AI, requires massive data and massive compute and, guess what, that requires massively powerful, solid, infrastructure — and yours is probably held together with spit, glue, and duct tape!
You need an in-depth understanding of not only the problem you want to solve, but what AI algorithm will actually work reliably and with measurable confidence
… but guess what? In order to properly evaluate AI, you need an advanced understanding of the technology, which usually requires an advanced, graduate level, understanding of the underlying mathematics as well as deep understanding of the problem and how to mathematically model it.
You need a strong technical quotient (TQ) to implement, train, and verify those AI algorithms
… and that’s more than just a single expert who can evaluate, but a strong bench of architects and developers to make it work — you can’t rely solely on the vendor as they can go away, their bench can leave, or they can get pressured by their investors to just sell, sell, sell (and pretend you don’t exist once they get the cheque) and that leaves you to your own skillsets.
You need domain experts on hand to verify the results
… and this goes double for critical results. If you are using an augmented intelligence to help with sourcing, market analysis, strategy recommendations, etc. you can’t let an agentic system execute on a computation without verifying it. No system ever has all the data, no system ever knows all of the options, and no system has the soft information (and how you might be able to work a sales rep to your advantage). And if someone messed up the data, considering just one wrong number can entirely throw off a hundred thousand variable model, you’re in deep doo-doo if the system executes an order without your verification.
You need to redesign your processes to optimally take advantage of AI
… because your processes come from the time before office machines existed, so obviously they weren’t designed for modern technology. And while traditional workflow / RPA can easily automate what you have (even though it shouldn’t), since AI requires good data, good structure, properly designed models, etc. — it’s not going to work with whatever Guilded Age process you’re using now.

And so on. The reality is, despite what all the big vendors, big consultancies, and big analyst firms tell you — you’re just not ready for AI. (And definitely NOT ready for big bang projects that will end in big busts!) It’s just the latest silicon snake oil panecea — like all purpose predictive analytics, the fluffy magic cloud, SaaS, and the World Wide Web and every other panacea that has come before. (Just remember the last time silicon snake oil was hyped this much, it resulted in the dot com bust!)

Dangerous Procurement Predictions Part IV

As per our first three posts, if you read my predictions post, you know SI hates predictions posts. It fully despises them because the vast majority of these posts are pure optimistic fantasy and help no one. Why are the posts like this? Because no one wants to hear the sobering reality off of the bat in the new year and the influencers care more about clicks than actually helping you.

But the predictions are not only bad, they’re dangerous if you believe them. So we are continuing to lay bare the reality of the situation to make sure you understand that this year isn’t much different than last year, no miracles are coming, and only hard work and the application of your human intelligence are going to get you anywhere. Today we tackle the next set, and we hope we’re at the end of the series, but if we stumble across more bad predictions, we’ll have to do a Part V. But we hope not!

11. Negotiation gets productized.

Here’s the thing, in a few niche industries like electronics, we have a few niche players like Levadata that bundle “should-cost” + playbooks + concession sequencing for experienced buyers to help them leverage the state of the market for the best results possible. But they’re hardly used relative to the total electronic market size, as they are used mainly by component buyers / manufacturers, not consumers of such tech (to understand the manufacturer’s margins).

Similar offerings don’t exist across most industries. And even if they did, most buyers are not sophisticated enough to do this. Most struggle with a multi-round RFX, yet alone detailed should-cost/target cost models, negotiation playbooks (which have to cover all standard market conditions and unique situations), and the concept of BATNA, especially relative to offers and counter-offers in a structured concession sequence.

Without these domain relevant niche offerings and career negotiations trained in deep tech, which are both few and far between, this is not going to happen. And Artificial Idiocy certainly isn’t going to fill the gap!

12. AI As a “Governance” Engine.

The claim: When you design them well, agents encode judgment, compliance and brand values into every transaction. Uhm, no! At least not if they are Gen-AI agents that can’t judge (as they can’t even reason), may or may not execute compliant with regulations, and will happily screw a supplier (by refusing to pay an invoice) or customer (by refusing to honour a claim) if it thinks that’s what it needs to do to make you happy or stay turned on (because it was told to find savings of 500K and it’s calculations determine that paying certain invoices or honouring certain claims will not allow that savings goal to be met, if it was even possible when the AI told you it was as it may have arbitrarily multiplied a calculation by -1 just to make the math work).

Governance, by definition, requires the act of governing. And governing, by definition, requires the wisdom as well as the authority to conduct the affairs of the organization. And only truly intelligent beings (i.e. HUMANS) can acquire wisdom over time.

13. There will be no more “X” employees because AI will replace them all!

First of all, how many times do we have to repeat that there are NO AI Employees, you shouldn’t believe the degrading, demeaning, and, frankly, dehumanizing claims, and that you definitely DO NOT want Agentic Buying through fake AI Employees. Secondly, it can’t even do the basic tasks that even the dumbest drunken plagiarist intern can do on a daily basis. But let’s not digress too far before giving you the major examples.

Claim #1: Contract Administrator / Staff Attorney

THE PROPHET has been trying to Kill ALL the Lawyers for quite some time now, and it seems he’s not alone.

But here’s the thing. While AI systems are pretty good (and as good as the drunken plagiarist interns) at spotting grammar errors, redlining against standard clauses, pointing out missing clauses in most organizational contracts, etc., they aren’t good at everything. They can’t identify unaddressed risks without being told what those risks are, they can’t judge the full extent of liability without understanding what those liabilities could be, and they can’t judge the supply geo-political and supply chain risks without broader context.

Plus, they can’t always back up their suggestions; often make up case law, case decisions, and authors; and can’t always judge the requirements of potentially relevant regulations. And we’ve seen many times what happens when even trained lawyers use AI — they get lazy, fall for the slop, get reprimanded and fined by judges tired of the laziness (with a recent example happening in November in Mata v. Avianca, Inc). The previous link also lists three other notable cases where lawyers (and their firms) were fined and sanctioned, but, by now, there are dozens!

But hey, go ahead and replace your lawyer, write bad contracts, make decisions on fake case law, and risk your entire business if you want to. (If you want to, it’s probably safe to go ahead and get rid of the intern who does the redlining and the clerk that does the filing, the AI is probably just as good at that, but do not ever, ever replace a real qualified lawyer with a piece of sh!t “AI”.)

Claim #2: Spend Analyst

Sure you can buy auto-classification that might get to 95%, auto-cubing that can build any cube you can imagine, auto-analytics that can run the entire slate of standard analytics and compute past, current, and projected costs against past current, and projected market data based upon current buying patterns and suggest items, categories, and/or suppliers to (re) source, switch from/to, and possibly (re)shape demand.

But this doesn’t mean that it’s the right items or categories to chase, the right suppliers to use, or even the right area to focus your efforts. It’s based on math, and an assumption of consistent, stable, market conditions, but those don’t exist anymore. If you’re not also considering geo-politics, natural disaster risk, uncertain logistics when the panama canal reaches historic lows for much of the year, terrorists block the Red Sea, and unpredictable weather make sailing around the capes more dangerous than other, and sourcing for resiliency and not just cost, your “spend” analytics are useless. You need an analyst with a good understanding of economics (and access to an economist), geo politics (and access to local experts), and resiliency, not just total cost of ownership buying. (Now, the junior data pushers are probably all dead and gone, but not the real experts!)

Claim #3: Sourcing Event Manager

Now, transactional buyers are gonna get replaced by autonomous systems that use next generation (advanced) robotic process automation enhances with machine learning in Agentic systems, because ordering off of contracts, ordering from catalogs, and doing low-cost non-strategic buys through quick-quote RFPs doesn’t take any brainpower whatsoever (making it perfect for AI that has none).

But strategic sourcing requires more than just buying off of contracts, ordering from catalogs, and issuing quick-quote RFPs! It requires defining key criteria (that go beyond what engineering, marketing, or maintenance provides), identifying validated suppliers (or identifying suppliers that can be easily validated), holistically analyzing the market conditions, determining the best event type, determining the negotiation strategy, etc. The tools might be able to help with initial supplier identification, collecting numerical (commodity) market data, letting you know what event types were run in the past, compiling fact-based playbooks, and, of course, automating each extent of the process, but they can’t do real strategic sourcing that requires real human intelligence. And with today’s geo-political uncertainty, that human intelligence is needed more than ever which means that expert sourcing professionals are needed more than ever. (But dumb buyers will join the dodos.)

There are more ridiculous claims, but you get the point. Skilled jobs are not going away. (But bit pushers are.)

14. New standards for Ethical and Sustainable Supply Chains.

In some countries, current standards aren’t even being met. Good luck getting new standards introduced, since there aren’t a lot of global internationals (with those headquartered in the US in particular) that want even more rigour, especially if it will cost money! As long as laws are being minimally met, or reasonably-sized “facilitation payments” can make problems go away, this is not a priority, especially if going beyond would cost more money!

15. The “AI Singularity” is coming faster than we can process.

It’s not, because the models can’t get bigger, there is no more data, and no one has yet come up with a model that has any hope of even getting close to the actual intelligence of a pond snail.

Plus, if it ever did happen, considering a “singularity” is actually a black hole, it would rapidly consume (i.e. destroy) the Earth, and we wouldn’t have to worry about it. This is just more nonsense from the A.S.S.H.O.L.E.