Category Archives: rants

It’s 2016! Welcome Back to the Industrial Age of SRM!

State of Flux just released their 8th annual supplier relationship management research report entitled Digital SRM: Supplier Relationships in the New Technology Landscape and while it reveals the handful of leading supply chain organizations are, or are moving towards, digitization, it reveals the majority of organizations are not only stuck in the past, but moving back towards the industrial age in their supplier (relationship) management processes. Scary!

So scary in fact, that I hope that the purchasing wizard Pete Loughlin of Purchasing Insight does a follow up to his piece on how “we are now arriving in the digital economy – turn your watch back 40 years” entitled we are moving forward in the digital economy, turn your watch back another 40 years because some of the practices many global organizations are still practicing with respect to supplier relationship management could literally be straight out of Marshall Monroe Kirkman’s classic The handling of railway supplies. Their purchase and disposition.

And I’m not joking.

Many organizations are still doing nothing more than inviting bids by public advertisement for a year’s supply and taking the advice that the pulse of the market should be continually felt and, clearly, not thinking about the importance of managing relationships after the purchase order is cut.

And while it looked like we are making progress last year, the simple facts that:

  • the number of businesses failing to invest in any SRM-related training rose from 26% in 2015 to 39% in 2016
  • 80% of companies are not achieving on-going benefits from external spending (compared to what they could be)
  • 87% of companies are still using Excel (which is essentially just an electronic version of a general ledger at most companies) as their primary SRM tool

demonstrate that, for the majority of organizations, the digital age (which for the consumer has been here for almost two decades) is still decades away.

After all, why are Purchasing Manages still panicing when they receive the 2:00 am phone call from the CFO informing them that their primary supplier in China just filed for bankruptcy and the company needs to know ASAP what the impact will be. If they had modern supplier relationship management systems, it wouldn’t take them 48 sleepless hours pouring through accounting systems, ERP systems, and spreadsheets to figure out what products come from the supplier. With modern supply management best practices it wouldn’t take them weeks to identify a new supplier and months to switch. And with good supplier relations, they definitely wouldn’t have to absorb the price doubling mandated by the receivership for continued supply of the critical product lines.

With proper supplier relationship management, you know as much about the (financial) health status of your strategic supplier as you know about your own organization. With proper supplier relationship management, you know all the products that are being provided, in what volume, in what consumer product lines they are being used, and what the impact of a stockout or termination of the line will be. With proper supplier relationship management, a company knows which other suppliers it is using that could also produce the product, how long it would take to switch, and how much it would cost. And with good relations, the last thing the supplier personnel would be comfortable with is charging their best customers an unexpected, possibly contract violating, unmitigated price increase, and would fight any suggestions by the receivership management to increase prices to any degree.

And the sad thing is there is no shortage of basic SRM systems these days. Not all are industry leading like (and not all will deliver anywhere near the value of) State of Flux’s Statess solution, but there are so many ways for an organization to enter the digital age that it’s shocking just how hard they fight to stay in the industrial age.

Hopefully, now that the results have been demonstrated for eight years in a row, they’ll finally accept SRM is not a passing fad, its the foundation for a new reality, buy in, and go for it. At the very least, hopefully they’ll check out “Digital SRM: Supplier Relationships in the New Technology Landscape” and realize what could be.

Just What Does Modern Sourcing Need?

Every year vendors, analysts, and even bloggers come up with their view of what next generation sourcing is, and what is going to get us there. This year, there is a big push towards AI (Artificial Intelligence) and not just predictive, but prescriptive analytics. Apparently, the Sourcing (and Procurement) of the future will be managed by computers, and not by experts. This is not only unnecessary, but a bit scary.

Why is it scary? Because computers run on algorithms and algorithms are not intelligence. Even though it’s theoretically possible for a sufficiently powerful computing platform to pass the Turing test*, all it does is point out the insufficiency of the Turing test for assessing the intelligence of a computer program. While computers can process significantly more data than we can, and modern predictive (trend) models, given enough data, can be more accurate than our intuition, they cannot detect when they are likely to fail or there is information or factors that need to be considered not baked into the model.

For example, if the prescriptive analytics relies on predictive analytics that relies on price trend modelling that simply takes into account price history, currency fluctuations, demand for related products or commodities, and demand for commodities that are usually used to hedge against price fluctuations in the product or commodity category, it will not detect when a natural disaster will result in a supply chain disruption that will result in less product or commodity availability in two months, which, of course, will have a drastic impact on price. As a result, the recommendation to spot-buy while the price is dropping is the wrong one, because as soon as supply drops, prices will skyrocket and it will be too late to lock in the current price.

But this isn’t the worst that can happen. If the AI that monitors multiple pricing trends, expiring contracts, and supplier performance not only ignores this blip but, instead, not only directs a resourcing for an expiring contract on an unrelated,but highly strategic, category, but encourages the inclusion of a supplier (that normally does not supply that category) that is currently in financial distress, the organization could end up blindly awarding a critical category (that is currently being served by a stable, reliable, reasonably low cost supplier) to a different supplier that is about to go bankrupt and then, seemingly without warning, stock-out on a critical product for months.

As you can probably guess, the doctor still believes that Sourcing and Procurement do not need AI and prescriptive analytics. What they really need are powerful and modifiable rules-based workflows, exception monitoring, suspicious transaction identification, and event monitoring.

The true power of a platform is to automate the tactical and streamline the strategic. Every minute of a professional’s time should be spent on strategic activities or issue resolution, not electronic paper pushing. Document matching, data collection and verification, contract monitoring, automated trend computation, etc. are all tasks that should be done automatically, but no actions with any strategic impact should be taken without intelligent human intervention.

A good rules-based workflow can allow tactical tasks, such as invoice matching and marketing monitoring, to be automated according to accepted rules and ensures that professionals only need to be involved when the parameters exceed the specified norms. Exception monitoring can insure that when something is out of expected norms, or exceeds ranges, or happens too often, it is immediately brought to the attention of the right individual. A suspicious transaction monitoring system, even if statistically based, minimizes the chances of duplicate payments, fraud, audit trail tampering, and so on. And event monitoring, even though it will produce a number of false positives, will enable a human to identify events that might impact the projected supply and cost trends for commodities and products purchased by the organization, and mark those for manual review and, possibly, re-sourcing if need be.

Modern sourcing does need better technology, but it doesn’t need artificial intelligence. It needs platforms that can help the sourcing professional focus appropriately, not guide the professional down a programmed path that will only give Sourcing and Procurement a false sense of security. The solution can track best practices for different situations, but the human still needs to determine if the system’s assessment is proper. Sourcing needs a system that empowers it with the intelligence it needs to make the right decisions, not a system that makes decisions and acts on those decisions (with automated contracts, orders, etc.) without human review and approval.

* A computer that is capable of sampling all conversations archived and currently taking place in real time, finding the one that best matches the conversation you are having, and providing that answer will provide a conversation indistinguishable from that provided from a real human, but it’s not intelligent. It merely proves the infinite monkey theorem.

3 More Terrible Reasons NOT to Use e-Procurement

Over on Procurement.World, the procurement dynamo gives us 3 Terrible Reasons NOT to Use e-Procurement, which, sadly, are still used by many organizations in the bottom 40% to 60%, to fight the implementation and adoption of e-Procurement systems.

If the reasons given in the procurement dynamo‘s post were the only reasons, that would be bad enough. But these are just a few of the reasons that Procurement organizations don’t use e-Procurement. In this post we are going to discuss other reasons, and, in particular, reasons that are a bit more believable — which are the worst kind of reasons.

1. Our Processes are Not Supported in the New System

While it’s true that the processes used by organizations that are still operating like it’s the last century are not supported out of the box, modern procurement platforms come with adjustable workflows that can be tailored to support just about any process the organization needs, good or bad. This may have been an excuse with first generation systems with fixed rules and workflows, but it’s not an excuse anymore.

2. The system won’t work with our current ERP or AP system

Most organizations require that all POs get in the ERP, all invoices in the AP, and all goods receipts in the inventory system. Because no recommended e-Procurement system will integrate with these systems out of the box, anyone against the implementation of such a system will insist it won’t work. And, again, wile this may have been an excuse with first generation systems that were almost impossible to integrate with anything, it’s not an excuse anymore when most e-Procurement vendors realize that their systems have to integrate with other systems and have published data models, open APIs, and middleware that enables the easy integration with such systems.

3. We don’t need Supply Management System X, we need Supply Management System Y.

Sometimes, knowing that a system they don’t want is inevitable, an opposing employee will suggest that a system is needed, but the system under consideration is not the right one and a totally different system is needed. For example, you are looking at a P2P and they will insist that a S2C is needed, or vice versa. Or they will insist that the ERP needs an upgrade. Or so on. But it will all be a distraction.

Systems will always be opposed, but when they are needed, they need to get implemented. The key is to select the right one. But with proper homework (and many posts on this blog will tell you how to do it), the right one can be selected.

London Bridge is Falling Down

But this time, it’s not the vikings*, it’s the procurement. And this is not a good thing. Bridges need to be built, not put on indefinite hold while enquiries are made into funding proposals. But then again, why does a foot bridge cost £185M?

As per a recent post by the public defender over on Spend Matters UK on how “Procurement and Funding [is] To Be Reviewed”, while a previous internal review by Transport for London did not find any evidence that would suggest that the final recommendations did not provide value for money from the winning bidders, the report did find major breaches of good procurement process. From allowing a supplier to submit a bid after the formal deadline, to a lack of documentation, to changing the evaluation process once bids were received, to treating suppliers differently – as we said, if any unsuccessful bidder had challenged in court there is no doubt that they would have won their case.

While this is bad, and provides a solid reason to put everything on hold for further examination and inquiry, this situation should never have happened in the first place. With so many resources on good public procurement available from the EU, the OECD, and private government oversight organizations, there’s no excuse, and no call, for any government procurement body in any advanced country to conduct an event like this — especially when there are good public procurement platforms (including, but not limited to Intenda, Causeway, Perfect Commerce, and others) to prevent situations like this from happening (and some are custom built for big procurement projects). Modern platforms block late submissions, allow evaluation criteria to be locked down before the bid goes out, allow initial submissions to be reviewed blind, and so on.

So, we beg you, before any more bridges fall down (or literally fall down because the funding to fix them has to be put on indefinite hold while the Procurement process is reviewed), learn the rules, follow the best practices, and put good platforms in place that prevent bad processes from ever happening in the first place.

* While the popular rhyme has to do with London Bridge falling down, the reality is that the rhyme might be the result of the destruction of (a) London bridge by Olaf the II of Norway somewhere between 1009 and 1014.

Platforms are Needed to Accelerate Procurement Agility – But Don’t Overlook the Offline Contributions

Over on Spend Matters UK, the public defender wrote a great post on “Why Platforms are Needed to Accelerate Procurement Agility” and discussed how the digitization of our everyday lives through cloud-based services served up over the internet is arguably the single greatest consumer trend of the modern era. In this post, he noted that the digitization trend has also worked its way upstream into B2B value chains and since businesses don’t want to be “digitally disrupted” by others they are searching for new supplier capabilities they can serve up as new customer-facing services.

This is a great use of digitization capability where it makes sense, but it’s not just online agility that is needed, it’s offline too. And this is where modern platforms can make the most impact.

Consider the NPD/NPI lifecycle. Right now, what typically happens is engineering works in their own little world designing a product, and when it’s mostly done, they contact procurement to help them find sources of supply and qualify their preferred manufacturing houses. This is typically done in CAD/CAM software, disconnected from everything, and can be a slow process.

Initial design might have to be slow, but the fact that its disconnected can really slowdown the NPI cycle. If design is not plugged in to the rest of the enterprise, and Procurement cannot be involved from day one, the engineers might choose discontinued parts, work with unfavourable suppliers, or even work on features that are not desired by the majority of current customers.

Then there is sourcing. Without advanced knowledge, Sourcing will not only need ramp up time to identify sources of supply, but might be stuck trying to source materials in limited supply that have a locked in price higher than the organization can afford if it wants to meet cost targets. Early involvement can help Engineering understand where the cost is and select the right design options when it has a choice.

Then there is inventory and manufacturing planning. Procurement needs to be plugged into marketing and sales to accurately estimate demand, and have to be in tune with supplier production capacities and shipment times to make sure orders are placed on time and stock-outs can be addressed quickly in times of demand surge.

The only way NPD/NPI time can be minimized is if the process goes smoothly. The only way this can happen is if Procurement is involved from the beginning and can connect with each impacted department in the organization at the right time and can communicate with suppliers quickly and consistently. This can only be done with a modern platform and illustrates why platforms are truly needed for Procurement agility.