Category Archives: Procurement Innovation

Cornerstones of Strategic Procurement

Yesterday I pointed you to Bob’s post on Smart Working Capital Management where he pointed out the pitfalls of being preoccupied with DPO (Days Payable Outstanding) and how a DPO focus can be counter-productive. Specifically, the requests for DPO extensions that tend to result from the DPO focus tend to leave untested the willingness of suppliers to entertain aggressive discount payment terms in exchange for early payment by the customer.

Today I want to remind you of a post Bob wrote back in early January that you might have missed if you returned late from the Christmas vacation. In the evolving landscape of low cost country sourcing, Bob outlines the three fundamental requirements of strategic procurement:

  1. fact-based approach based on a thorough understanding of current reality and anticipated trends
    that should be based on whatever data you have available
  2. an investment in the appropriate skills and enough of the right resources to develop and execute the strategies
    including the right technology to perform the necessary analysis
  3. constant monitoring and adjustment to optimize results in an ever-changing world
    that should include simulation and modeling software where appropriate

For more information on strategic procurement, be sure to check out Bob’s new book on Next Level Suppply Management Excellence, hitting the (e-) shelves on June 28, 2011.

The AchieveGlobal Model for an Innovation Culture

A recent article over on Chief Executive outlined “The “Six C’s” Model for Building A Culture of Innovation” from AchieveGlobal. The model was created by examining the practices and behaviors of the Boston Consulting Group’s top 100 innovative firms around the world and is worth a review.

  1. Collaboration
    Innovation now requires the collaboration of large, diverse groups of people. Not only has the size of research teams grown by 20% per decade over the last 50 years, but a paper is six times more likely to get at least 1,000 citations if it comes from a team, which should be made up of a socioeconomic mix of people at all levels up and down your supply chain, from different departments, functions, divisions, brands and plants.
  2. Customer Centric
    A culture of innovation requires a deep commitment to understanding customers’ expectations and providing them with value. In addition, it looks for user innovation and situations where users use products for unintended purposes or refine the products for particular needs.
  3. Context Rich
    Leaders in innovation put lots of effort into the development of formal and informal systems to collect and share information throughout the workforce.
  4. Curious
    Innovative leaders encourage their employees to question authority, to question their assumptions, to ask why, why not and what if? Innovation leaders give their employees time to research, explore, and even wander down blind alleys.
  5. Confidence Focussed
    Businesses that excel at innovation actively increase their employees’ capabilities and self-esteem. Innovation requires the confidence to explore, experiment, push-through the darkness, and succeed.
  6. Challenge Culture
    Innovative companies focus on meeting challenges and aiming for new heights. They are never content with good enough or solving today’s problems. They strive for excellence and solutions to tomorrow’s problems.

TradeCard: Transaction Management for the Global Supply Chain Part II

In yesterday’s post we introduced you to TradeCard, a supply chain management services and trade finance company that provides an end-to-end SaaS transaction management solution that connects over 4,000 buyer and supplier companies across the world with local support in over 50 countries. This solution, which implements end-to-end transaction management from the cutting of the Purchase Order to final settlement (including chargebacks) with support for financing, document management, 3rd party freight forwarders, and factory floor shipment packaging, is one of the most extensive SI has seen with respect to visibility into the three critical supply chain flows — financial, physical, and information.

We discussed the financial flow, which supports pre- and post- export financing, payment protection, invoice discounting, and settlement with their Procure-to-Pay solution; the physical flow, that is supported by their collaboration, Factory Xpress, and document management solutions; and the information flow, which is supported by the aforementioned solutions along with the TradeCard Advantage and Custom Objects Toolkit solution. Today we are going to dive into the physical flow and the solutions that support it.

We’ll start with the collaboration solution. Designed with forecasting and supply planning in mind, the solution allows for forecast and purchase order data to be pulled from your ERP / forecasting system / system of record of choice and pushed back when the production plan and/or purchase order is complete. Forecasting revolves around (rolling) supply plans, that can be completed from a material, supplier, forecast, inventory, (material) commitment, or demand view. Buyers and suppliers, who are given permission, can edit the forecast, and the revised forecast can be maintained along side the original forecast. The forecast can be at the product level, or the component material level, as the platform has equal support for component and 2nd tier raw material suppliers, who can also be given (read or edit) access if relevant or key. The system also allows the scheduled production runs to be collaboratively decided upon (and updates the projected inventory automatically). There are no built-in forecasting models at this time, but that may change in a future release. (In the interim, Tradecard can integrate any forecasting system that can provide data in a standard format such as EDI, XML, or CSV.)

The UI is similar to many web-based supply management platforms, and includes a “taskboard” that keeps track of all of the current tasks for the current user, which can be ordered by action type, transaction, or assignment date. With respect to transactions, which the suite is designed around, a user can query and track transactions by purchase order, invoices, payments, packing & shipping, financing, (goods) receipts, contracts, adjustments, events, and customs filings in addition to supply plans. Purchase orders are extremely detailed and can contain all of the information required by the supplier, freight forwarders, and any customs authorites (including order terms, parties, freight terms, destinations, items, components, additional terms, and required documents). This allows for the easy generation and submission of appropriate trade and customs documents (with over 10 import and export document formats supported out-of-the-box). The system maintains complete document history and allows an authorized buyer to query exactly who did what when. Events allow the buyer to track the transaction after the PO is issued and record actual production, shipments, receipt, distribution to warehouses, returns, chargebacks, and other relevant events.

Factory Xpress is the “shop floor” solution that is designed for the personnel who are actually packing and shipping the orders. The users can access, and (if they have permission) edit the packing plans, create and print packing slips and/or shipping labels, and even scan appropriately barcoded labels to indicate when an order has been packaged and shipped. In addition, orders for packing labels and materials can be sent directly to Avery Dennison, whom the solution was developed in conjunction with. The system supports bulk packing, multi-packing, and free-packing plans and can automatically regenerate packing plans based upon changes in order quantity, delivery location, carton sizes, or item mix. Once the shipment has been packed, packing manifests can automatically generated from the packing plan and purchase order.

One very neat feature of the platform is the “discrepancy preview” that a supplier can run before finalizing the invoice. When the discrepancy preview is run on a draft invoice, it compares invoice data to shipment/packing manifest data and PO data and reports all discrepancies in pricing, order quantities, factories, origins, destinations, and other comparable data and checks that all terms and/or documents have been completed. This allows the supplier to correct any data that can be corrected before the invoice is sent, minimizing the chance of the buyer rejecting it or sending it back for correction. It also allows the buyer to verify that the invoice they received is consistent with what they expected, or if its not, immediately determine what the discrepancy is and whether or not it was approved (due to a change in forecast or demand).

With respect to reporting, there are dozens of built in report types and the user can select the attributes and value ranges for each report, but TradeCard does not yet possess a generic report builder tool, although custom reports can be created by way of their Common Objects toolkit if required. However, complete export of all in XML and CSV format is supported and the buyer can use a third party data analysis and reporting tool to construct whatever report they want for more detailed analysis.

Finally, the TradeCard platform currently supports English, Traditional, and Simplified Chinese with Spanish coming later this year, and most implmentations, which includes integration to your ERP and forecasting systems, and onboarding of 80% of your relevant supply base, and user training, are accomplished in 90 days. It’s a solid solution and one worth looking into if you need to manage end-to-end transactions across the global supply chain.

TradeCard: Transaction Management for the Global Supply Chain Part I

In yesterday’s post on how it’s sourcing, procurement, and global trade management, we mentioned how a critical part of global trade is finance and document management. One company that facilitates this process is TradeCard, an end-to-end SaaS transaction management solution that connects over 4,000 buyer and supplier companies across the world with local support in over 50 countries. And while they aren’t the only company that facilitates this process, with notable competitors being Integration Point and their extensive suite of import, export, and supply chain compliance solutions and TradeBeam with their import, export, and visibility solutions, they are the first solution that I’ve seen that implements end-to-end transaction management from the PO to final settlement (including chargebacks) with support for financing, document management, 3rd party freight forwarders, and factory floor shipment packaging. Furthermore, their solution, which supports the physical, financial, and information flows from all parties, focusses on the alignment of the flows.

The financial flow is supported by way of a procure-to-pay solution that enables pre- and post- export financing solutions, payment protection, invoice discounting, settlement, and chargebacks. Through agreements and alliances with over 25 banks, insurers, and other third parties, the TradeCard platform allows a suppier to request financing as soon as the purchase order is received. Then, depending on the supplier’s credit rating and the amount of the request, the request will be forwarded to one or more financing partners who will offer financing at standard terms or the TradeCard credit line, where the TradeCard platform can automatically grant certain financing requests under standard terms on behalf of the partners in the financial network.

The time of the financing request is flexible. The supplier can request financing at any point from the receipt of the purchase order to the receipt of goods by the buyer, and might even be able to request financing beyond receipt of the goods by the buyer, depending on the buyer’s standard payment terms. In addition, the platform allows the supplier to offer invoice discounting on early payment by the buyer as soon as the invoice has been accepted. Finally, the platform allows for electronic payments, which completes the end-to-end financial lifecycle of the transaction.

The physical flow is supported by their collaboration solution, which allows buyers and suppliers to collaboratively share current demand data and collaborate on forecasts and production plans, the Factory Xpress solution that allows for the creation and execution of detailed packing plans, and the document management solution that allows for the creation and transmission of documents that are required by freight forwarders, customs agents (for import and export), and distribution centers.

The information flow is supported by their Procure-to-Pay, Collaboration, and Factory Xpress solutions as well as their TradeCard Advantage solution that allows for queries and reports across the platform and the transaction data that it contains. It’s also supported by their new Custom Objects Toolkit that allows TradeCard to quickly create custom extensions — that can take the form of integrations, reports, or global trade documents — for customers on an as-needed basis.

By integrating the three flows, TradeCard provides a single view into the global supply chain for buyers, suppliers, factories, and partners around the world, which can be integrated into the platform as needed. TradeCard can, and has, integrated multiple ERP, best-of-breed, and home-grown sourcing, procurement, and global trade solutions into its platform in support of its hundreds of global Fortune 3000 customers. Furthermore, over 150 service providers already inject services into the platform in the form of financing, payment protection, inspection, and logistics, which a customer can take advantage of day one.

Tomorrow’s post will dive into the physical supply chain flow and the solutions that TradeCard provides.

It’s Sourcing, Procurement, and Global Trade

A few years ago, I took the time to remind you that it’s Sourcing and Procurement because it appeared that some vendors wanted you to believe that it’s e-Sourcing or e-Procurement, or some fractured combination of both, because that’s what they have and they want all of your business.

As I said before, e-Procurement and e-Sourcing are not the same thing. From a supply management perspective, they’re two halves of a whole, one tactical and one strategic. And while they bring value alone, combined they bring much greater value. Sourcing leads into Procurement, usually off of a contract, but sometimes after e-Negotiation or decision optimization alone, and Procurement leads back into Sourcing, through the analysis step. Without Procurement, the organization wouldn’t have a large transaction database and extensive visibility into spend, and without Sourcing, there would be no strategically negotiated contracts to buy against, leaving procurement managers the freedom to spend willy nilly.

But when it comes to supply management, Sourcing and Procurement are still not the full picture. While they are the full picture from the viewpoint of the buyer / analyst in a mid-sized or larger supply management organization, they do not address the supply side, or the fact that goods need to come from a supplier, sometimes by way of a distributor, and end up in the buyer’s warehouses for shipment to stores and/or end consumers.

The goods have to be packed, shipped, exported, imported, and, sometimes, financed. And the settlement function has to take into account invoice discounting and chargebacks, at a minimum. This doesn’t sound too bad until you realize that the average international shipment requires twenty or more documents for export and import, especially when the US or the EU is involved. Ever since the introduction of 10+2 and new advance cargo declarations in the EU, it seems that documentation requirements have been compounding ever since.

And while this functionality does not necessarily have to be in the e-Sourcing or e-Procurement system, it is needed by any company doing international business and it should be easy for a company to push data out from the e-Sourcing/e-Procurement system into the appropriate Global Trade Management system and pull the necessary data back in for analysis.

Because, when you consider the average transaction in today’s global supply chain end to end, this is what you usually end up with.

Sourcing – Spend Analysis (what needs to be sourced)
Sourcing – e-Negotiation (RFX, Auction – who will it be sourced from)
Sourcing – Decision Optimization (optional, to analyze the bids)
Sourcing – Contract Management (to store the awards)
Procurement – Requisition (for a Bill of Materials)
Procurement – Approval (for the requisition)
Procurement – Purchase Order (for the supplier)
Global Trade – Financing (can be pre or post invoice)
Global Trade – Packing (goods have to be properly packed and labelled)
Global Trade – Shipping (goods have to be shipped)
Freight Forwarder (if a third party handles the shipping)
Export Documentation (for the supplier’s home country)
Import Documentation (for the buyer’s home country)
Procurement – Good Receipt
Procurement – Invoice
Global Trade – Invoice Discounting (if the buyer pays early)
Procurement – Reconcilation
Procurement – Payment
Global Trade – Settlement (the purchase has to be settled in the source accounting system)
Global Trade – Chargebacks (chargebacks for penalties or returned goods have to be accounted for)
Procurement – Tax Reclamation
Sourcing – Spend Analysis (what needs to be sourced)