Before your mind wanders off in the wrong direction, I’m talking about your manageable external spend size. (Not your company size, or revenue size, but your actual external spend size!)
You see, not every solution fits every company, and it’s not just a matter of company, process, and Procurement Maturity; not just a matter of what is being bought and for what; but a matter of spend size.
Here’s the thing, sourcing strategy depends on three primary factors:
- the category
- current market conditions
- spend size
The third is critical. If you’re only spending 100K, you’re not going to do a multi-stage RFP with multi-objective optimization analyzing multiple factors against multiple award scenarios and spend 10K in personnel time and cloud costs for a 5K savings. If you’re spending 100M, you’re going to do a multi-stage event with deep supplier and product vetting, should and target cost analysis, multi-objective optimization models against multiple potential award scenarios, multi-round negotiation, and so on.
This is very important. If you’re a small mid-market that only spends 20M a year externally, and your largest category is 200K, your sourcing scenarios are going to be pretty simple. Even though those categories are strategic for you, they are not strategic sourcing in the enterprise sense of the word, which is the sense the big suites try to sell you. All you need is an e-Procurement+ solution with simple RFPs for your big categories and RFQs for the rest.
Now, if you’re a mid-mid-market spending 100M a year with categories 1M plus, that’s not enough. You need sourcing support, but it’s not full fledged strategic sourcing as defined by an enterprise suite. It’s sourcing execution. You need some onboarding, some qualification, some multi-round RFP support with feedback, some basic analytics, and some negotiation support. You don’t need deep optimization or a top-of-the-line analytics solution, an end-to-end third party risk management and compliance solution, or extensive integrated contract creation and redlining support — you just need Word document support as you’re redlining in Word.
In other words e-Procurement isn’t enough. You need some supplier management, sourcing, analytics, and contract document management. And it should all be integrated cohesively. But it’s not a suite.
Now, if you’re a large global organization, spending 500M plus with 10M to 100M categories, that’s different. You need broad and deep. Full multi-stage sourcing with auto-RFX generation, scenario support, and sourcing optimization, which needs to be deeply integrated into the deep supplier and third party management module with extensive onboarding, compliance, risk, and performance support; the analytics module that can analyze offers and compare them against historical, project, should, and target cost scenarios; and the contract lifecycle module that manages the full negotiation, indexing, tracking, and execution of the contract.
This is all very relevant because it determines two things
- what type of solution you need
- how much you should expect to pay
So how much should you pay? Stay tuned.
