the doctor stopped reading the daily tariff news about a month ago, because it was too depressing. (Especially since he had already told you that, since you didn’t start preparing years ago, your only real solution was BTCHaaS.) But now it’s unavoidable with the 90 days expiring, few deals done, and “letters” supposed to replace deals. Moreover, the news hasn’t improved any since the rumours in May that the Big Three Automakers were going to scale back and shift global production outside the US. (EEEK!)

These trade wars aren’t helping America. They’re hurting America. Every day more and more American small businesses close their doors. Every day an average lower class or working class American pays more and more taxes on basic necessities that cannot be sourced from within America’s borders. And every time an American Government representative attacks Canada with false claims of hostility, 400% tariffs on US imports, huge trade deficits (which don’t exist, as per yesterday’s post), and so on, more and more Canadians go elbows up and forget about the pain an average American is experiencing and how important it is for Canada and the USA to work together to combat global threats and maintain a strong North America.

Anyway, back to the point, you need to get a plan and sign your trade deals fast because if

• small businesses continue to fail,
• the 12% lower class and 31% blue collar working class have to continue to pay 10% to 30% more on food and necessities they need just to survive, then your poverty rate (which is already 11% and quite high for the richest country in the world) is going to explode, and
• trade partners continue to look elsewhere to trade their products and services

then America is losing out!

It’s important to remember that there are two, and only two, good reasons for tariffs:

1. Tax Rates in a Consumption-Based Tax Regime. (America, like Canada and most first world countries are Income-Based Tax Regimes.)
2. Protection of core/critical industries by ensuring third parties can’t dump massive amount of cheaper (and usually inferior) products and services into your country and damage your industries.

In other words, in America, and Canada,

1. there should ONLY be significant tariffs for products and services that the country is capable of meeting it’s total domestic need for,
2. there should ONLY be moderate tariffs for products and services where the country is close to, but not yet capable of meeting, the domestic need (so that the remaining need can be met, but outside products and services will only be chosen to meet the gaps)
3. there should ONLY be low tariffs for products and services that the country can not (come close to) meet(ing) the domestic need for, but where the government has to ensure safety, quality, compliance with laws etc. (e.g. outside food needs to be regularly inspected by the FDA, for example)
4. there should be essentially no tariffs (beyond minimal inspection/processing fees) for products/services the country cannot produce domestically

Anything else hurts the populace. Also, since American economists didn’t do the math, a Canadian economist did. And the outlook for (sustained) tariffs above 10% is NOT Good! See this article. Or, if you don’t like economics and math, note that it more-or-less reinforces what the doctor said above. Low tariffs (on the majority of products and services) are actually good. They reduce trade deficits (presumably by discouraging dumping) and encourage real GDP growth (as current factories have the chance to maximize production and local markets with some protection), but only to a point! Somewhere between a 5% and 10% tariff rate, any and all benefits from tariffs cease.

So get those deals, and get the tariffs down to the right rate for the category of good or service (and country of origin) in question. Next to nothing for basic foods (like mangos) you don’t produce locally. The 5% to 10% range for raw materials (like aluminum and steel) you can produce of lot of domestically, but not totally meet your need for. 10% for industries that are strong and you need to protect (and grow). But please remember that you can’t build a new factory overnight, and in most modern manufacturing industries, and hi-tech electronics in particular, it takes 5 to 10 years to build and get a factory up and running. In the interim, you have to buy those products elsewhere.

In other words, you need a detailed plan, not just broad goals, reactionary policies, or a belief that if you will it hard enough, it will happen. Just because you want to play baseball, that doesn’t mean the world does. And, unfortunately, the nature of trade is you have to work with your partners (while, and this is key, making sure they work with you — don’t just get agreements for reciprocal trade, encode penalties into those agreements where if they don’t increase their purchasing, the tariff will go up every time the trade deficit fails to decrease by a pre-determined amount. Remember that some countries, like China, like to make broad promises, like they did in your President’s first time, but then fail to follow through).

The last thing Canada wants to see is this come crashing down, which would result in millions of layoffs (outside the tech industry), big manufacturers relocating production to the global market outside of the US, or global partners dumping American holdings or the American dollar as the default currency. It’s important to look at history and remember that while America was globally one of the richest countries the last time tariffs were high in the Gilded Age, the average American was quite poor. Furthermore, the short-lived Progressive Era that followed ended in the Great Depression, and that’s something we never want to see again! Short term trade wars can be a good thing if it leads to a re-stabilization of a drifting global economy, but long term trade wars aren’t good for anyone — and the country that started it in particular.

So please, get your deals, establish a new operating norm, and let everyone get back to work. Thank you!