Category Archives: Procurement Orchestration

“The Suite Was Supposed to Settle Everything.”

This is a requested response to Paul Marty’s inquiry: Is Source-to-Pay Dying.

We’ve heard the “one app to rule them all myth” since the late 60s when IBM said the MRP would control the operations and no other app would be needed. This was rekindled in the mid 80s when Oracle said the ERP would control the organization and no other app would be needed. Then in the late 90s when the web would provide a common interface to everything. Then the late noughts / early tens when the Suite would solve everything. It’s the myth that keeps on giving.

The reality is that any new monolith application model only solves all the problems that came before, not the problems you have now, and not the problems that are coming.

That doesn’t mean suites don’t have value, or that suites won’t provide more value than any other alternative, just that it’s not a panacea. Determining whether it provides more or less value requires understanding the true total value realized (taking all costs and benefits into account) compared to the true total value of the alternatives, many of which are unproven.

“Is The Economic Value Moving Somewhere Else?”

First off, let us note that, fundamentally, the new AI orchestration craze is no different, as it ultimately depends on a protocol that can bind everything together. This isn’t new either. Remember CORBA? Probably not, as most of you probably don’t even know what it is. Look it up. At the dawn of the dot com era, it was going to solve everything. It made all the same promises MCP is making now.

The reality is that the fundamental truths of technology have not changed.

> If it sounds too good to be true, it is.

> Technology can’t advance any faster than discovery (either mathematical computing theory or practical scientific discoveries that allow for new engineering that can build better machines to support better models), and that has, and will, always be slow. How many hundreds of thousands (or millions of years) has it taken us to compute a theoretical warp bubble, and how many decades/centuries more before we can achieve it? (We’ve went from conjecture with the introduction of Star Trek 60 years ago to theoretical possibility 5 years ago … but now we need to create the energy source, the materials that could withstand it, etc. etc. etc.)

> … businesses not only need to make money every year, but are punished by the capitalistic economy if they don’t; so even if all they have is the same old sh!t, they still need to sell it, and the best way to do that is to slap a new coat of paint on the old Mustang and tell you it’s a brand new model (even though the engine hasn’t changed in almost a decade)

This doesn’t mean that AI orchestration doesn’t provide value, just that it’s not the ultimate answer and that you have to truly understand it’s true cost vs its true benefits and, where autonomy is granted, true risks before you can make a decision.

“What if the employee does not need to enter the procurement system at all?”

That doesn’t change the fact you still need a procurement system.

Just because an intake layer can work across applications, and just because an AI agent can complete a routine workflow without ever displaying the myriad of screens suite vendors spent years (if not decades) refining, that doesn’t mean that the core functions go away. Either those have to be part of the intake/orchestration system (in which case it’s really a suite with a new kind of interface) or you still need the underlying best-of-breed / suite systems, which are only accessed through their APIs.

In the latter case, the true economic value remains in the best-of-breed/core systems … and the only value of the intake/orchestration/AI agent is the cost of user time reduction (i.e. 5 FT AP agents to manually process all the invoices vs 1 FT AP agent to manually deal with the exceptions). So if the cost of the software is greater than the manpower saved, it’s negative value.

This assumes that the agent is deterministic and will do all processing according to user defined rules and in user defined bounds. If you are using LLM-powered agents and giving them autonomy, there is no guarantee they will follow all rules and stay without bounds — autonomy means that they can decide only 10K over their approval limit is ok because it appears to be a known supplier, onboard an uncertified supplier, issue a new PO to a supplier who is late on other critical deliveries, etc. which can result in significant losses.

Which brings us to the most important question:

“ONE INTERFACE > MANY SYSTEMS > WHO DECIDES?”

This is a key question for multiple reasons:

1) You can’t cost / benefit a system without knowing.

As above, if the decision is ultimately human, you can accurately cost the system and determine it’s fixed (workforce reduction) benefit as well as it’s expected benefits from (weighted) average results and track true benefits over time.

But if the decision is ultimately the system, you can’t truly estimate the benefits as you don’t know what it will do, how many mistakes it will make, and what the cost to clean them up will be — and if it uses LLM technology, you can’t even cost the system as you don’t know how the token/compute cost is going to increase over time as you don’t know the token growth that will be required or how soon you’re going to have to pay true compute costs (the big AI companies can’t keep losing $4 for every $1 of revenue, and with today’s energy and water costs, the true compute cost is about 5X what most of the players are charging … and this will only increase over time.)

2) You can’t quality control without absolutely knowing who decides what, what the range of options are, where, and how to encode the checks.

Which means that:

“THE CENTRAL QUESTION … IS WHO OWNS THE REASONING THAT DETERMINES WHAT PROCUREMENT SHOULD DO”

Especially when the answer to:

“Are Twenty Agents Really Twenty Opinions?”

is NO!

I know Jon W. Hansen might disagree with me here, since he uses multiple systems to arrive at his (starting) algorithmic analysis of the marketplace regularly, but agents reason off of the data they are given.

When you interconnect them, they share “data” and “reasoning” continuously. Also, even though they are ultimately sophisticated probabilistic models no human can fully understand, the core is similar to deep multi-level feedback neural networks. This means that common “data” and “reasoning” increases the weighting on that “data” and “reasoning”, increases similar output, which increases similar input to the minority models, which causes that “data” and “reasoning” to become more heavily weighted in them. Or, in simple terms, a majority of agents will bully the minority of agents into their viewpoint until there is one opinion, not twenty.

Even if all 20 agents start out different, as they share “data” and “reasoning”, there will be some commonality, and as the “data” and “reasoning” flows back and forth, the weighting of the commonality will increase until it snowballs into a majority, given enough exchanges (over time).

While some “experts” will try to tell you this all but certainly guarantees you will get the best results once the agents agree, that is ONLY true if the common “data” and “reasoning” is accurate. Some agents will have bad / fake / hallucinated (wrong) data and others will share faulty “reasoning” because they don’t actually reason. (They predict arguments … think of them as a super powerful fancy version of next word suggestion on your iPhone, except they are predicting answers to questions and sometimes even the steps involved to get there!)

While individual agents sometimes work well if they have enough raw question/answer input/output previous step/next step data top work from (and that’s how they create mathematical “proofs” — they can scan millions of research papers and proofs, build up all the associations as input/output pairs, and then see if there is a way to chain them all together from a question to an answer where the output of one step in one paper is the required input of a step in a paper in another paper, possibly published in an unrelated journal in an unrelated discipline), they sometimes don’t work very well at all!

They’ll tell you to eat one rock a day. Or that strawberry only has 2 rs. Or, because they don’t understand reality, when asked, they will tell you that “the woodchuck could carry 57,600 pounds of wood in a day” when asked “How much wood could a woodchuck chuck if the woodchuck was 10 lbs?” (I didn’t make this up, DeepSeek did!) (And, even worse, it gave some extremely ridiculous “reasoning” to back it up which might fool someone who didn’t think twice because the logic was pretty good, while the data it worked on was ridiculous [and obviously hallucinated]. I should also point out that this was a result “I” totally expected because there shouldn’t be much “data” on “how much wood a wouldchuck could chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood” on the internet [which is it’s training data], because we all know a woodchuck can’t chuck wood but the AI doesn’t know that.)

Thus, whether you use one agent or twenty, you will get one opinion, and one result, which could be a total hallucination if none of the systems had enough correct “data” and examples to “reason” on.

Given that, as Paul Martyn points out, the best decisions are made when there is

  1. A diversity of experiences and information to draw on
  2. Independent thought by the participants (that can provide truly different views to the ultimate decision owner)
  3. Decentralization of knowledge for risk mitigation

and that today’s AI, which is NOT intelligent, cannot be trusted to always make the best decision as

  1. all agent systems have access to the same data on your network and the web
  2. agents cannot think, only produce “outputs” based on different weightings of “inputs”
  3. agents with minority data/reasoning can, and will, have at least their reasoning, if not their data, overwritten by the majority

This brings us to the following conclusions:

1. Traditional Suite and BoB solutions ARE still needed, even with orchestration and agents (especially since the later should be restricted to either fully deterministic processes or processes where the cost to fix/clean up after an occasional bad decision by software is less than the cost of having a team of people do that process manually)

2. The New Hotness Hype will always take sales away from established players, as the lazy and greedy look for that panacea solution that does not, and cannot exist … but when those solutions fail to achieve the result, some of those sales will return (as the only other option will be to build the missing parts into the acquired system, and why waste money trying to extend a system that’s fundamentally broken?)

3. “The Market is Not Dying”, as Paul Martyn states, but it is shifting. Suites will become the transaction engines and systems of record in organizations that experiment with new interfaces, orchestration, and AI agents. Hybrid suites, which embed orchestration and intake, will take over in organizations that want modern connectivity and interface but want to limit the number of vendors they need to deal with. And traditional suites will gain traction in highly regulated industries and governments where everything has to be 100% predictable and in-line with thousands (if not millions) of pages of policy regulations!

As Jason Busch likes to say, “many things can be true at once” and as long as those things are not mutually exclusive, they will be in the market.

(P.S. Thanks for taking up my day with no warning, Paul!)

Procurement is NOT a Place of Comfort!

A while ago, Garry made a great point in one of his post on how a surprising amount of leadership is simply holding the line on reality.

And, more importantly, a surprising amount of leadership is the acceptance and confrontation of uncomfortable reality. You see, in most organizations, leaders believe it’s their job to be optimistic and keep the team happy and comfortable. They tell the team “we’re almost there … the project’s almost done” even when it’s a dumpster fire. “The pipeline is strong” when all the pipeline consists of is a list of companies who indicated they might be interested in a solution that falls in the category of solutions the company offers and they have not been vetted beyond a third party discovery call. “It’s just timing” when the RFP only gets 3 responses from 7 suppliers after extending the deadline by two weeks. “Once we hire X, it’ll be fine” when the reality is that things will get worse since “X” won’t know how to fix anything until trained (and someone will have to stop fire-fighting to train X, which will allow the fires to consume even more).

A good leader addresses the discomfort.

“Okay, things went to sh!t with this project but we succeeded in the root cause analysis, we can get back on track in two months, and, more important, we also identified three other oversights in the project plan, corrected those, and forced the vendor to upgrade capabilities that will allow us to be more productive than planned when we go live. We’ll just have to work harder to ensure the revised plan doesn’t hiccup“.

“Losing MegaCo to our biggest competitor, whom we know can’t serve MegaCo, was a big hit. We had to cut our simultaneous sales efforts in half and what’s left in RFP stages doesn’t even equal MegaCo’s potential when combined, and we know we’re only batting 50% when we get to that stage. We need to refill the pipeline with active targets fast, and we know that the leads given to us by DealSourcingCo are not well qualified based on our few conversations. Since we also didn’t have time to review many leads the past quarter, those wankers really slacked. We have to shape up, do our own pre-sales and qualification, work overtime, and re-jig the entire pipeline over the next two weeks. However, even if only a third of the “pre-qualified” leads pan out, which is the current success ratio, the good news is that we’ll have more than enough to keep us busy and get back on track for next quarter.”

“It’s not timing. If 4 / 7 potential suppliers didn’t answer the RFQ, then we really f*cked something up. We need to contact each of them, and find out why. We’re we not specific enough on our requirements? Was our guaranteed commitment too low? Was the timeframe too short for them to respond? Were we asking too much in the RFQ for no guarantee? Did we misjudge the supply/demand and they just don’t need us? However, I just licensed us a category management system where we can encode all the knowledge we gain from every sourcing exercise to make sure this situation doesn’t (unnecessarily) happen again as we will know what we need to get it right“.

“Bob quitting and taking all his knowledge was a big loss. We’re totally underwater as we don’t have his category knowledge, know which of the 10,000 spreadsheets he was using for the last events, or who really managed the relationship at the supplier. The fact my predecessor never made Bob properly track anything left me with a hole I’ve ben struggling to figure out how to fill, especially since every time I pushed for better data organization he kept being more insistent he just didn’t have the time with his workload.
However, I did license an AI tool that will scan all his files, attempt a categorization by category, and extract the likely supplier, contact, products, and prices. I did license a category management tool that all of this data, once reviewed by an independent expert, will be pushed into.
And I did go out and find a few independent consultants who are real veterans with 20 years of category experience and engage them for the next quarter to sit down and help us get everything organized. (Independent, not fresh-faced known-nothing MBAs from a big consulting co.) The next three months will be hell, but then things will be better than they ever will before because we’ll all know where all the key category knowledge is at all times and we’ll be able to bring Bob’s replacement on and have that person be effective day one. For now it sucks, but if we can hit our targets, I’m going to expand your bonus pool by giving you some of mine
“.

That’s leadership. Telling the team as it is, making sure they understand it’s not going to be comfortable for a while, but that they will get through, you’ll be there with them, and you’re doing whatever you can to make it possible.

Theoretical Procurement Models Are Cool – But Not Always Recipes for Success

For this piece, I’m going to pick on a recent post, and graphic, from James Meads. Not because he got the models wrong, they’re perfect, but because neither are appropriate for today’s Procurement. We’ll first discuss what, at a high level, the right model actually is and then discuss what ALL models miss that is key for Procurement success.

In short, it’s a blend. It’s a model that shoots for the ultimate expression of what Procurement should be in a perfect world, while accepting the reality that the world is not perfect (and there ain’t no living in a perfect world anyway) and you have to function accordingly. To explain this, we’ll tackle each of the six dimensions and explain why entrepreneurial procurement, the perfect model for a perfect world, is not always the recipe for success and why, occasionally, it’s no better than the old-school technocratic procurement most procurement departments are still stuck in (which, while successful yesterday, is no longer successful today).

Let’s start with goals. It’s obvious that yesterday’s technocratic goals of cost savings and compliance are not a recipe for success, as the emphasis they place overlooks risk and resilience and sees Procurement being involved too late in the process to have any significant impact on total cost. On the flip-side, it’s not all innovation and value-creation — innovation can take years to from ideation to reality and value-creation usually involves new service offerings which rely a lot on suppliers who will need to be developed to get there. That’s why success is a balance between the original goal of Procurement — supply assurance (because No Sale, No Store) — and value generation. It’s conceited and absurd to think Procurement is the source of all value creation in an organization. It’s not. But it is the source of all value realization and generation — because it’s up to Procurement to acquire the required products and services in perfect orders where, when, and at the right TCO that is required for the value realization, and, preferably, at lower cost and higher quality than budgeted for to generate additional value beyond what was expected. It’s a fine balance between aspiration and cold, harsh, reality.

Now we’ll move on to process. The process should be engineered in a layered fashion that builds on must-have, should-have, and nice-to-include steps that, when layered and strung together completely defines a well engineered, almost rigid, process that a junior buyer new to the category can follow and be guaranteed success in typical market circumstances; that an intermediate buyer can strip down to the should-haves, adapt slightly to current market conditions and time-constraints, and use their sourcing experience to take advantage of the specific market conditions and/or an expanded supplier pool; and that a senior buyer with category expertise can strip down to the absolute must haves (engineering part verification, mandatory compliance requirements, etc.) and execute rapidly in an emergency situation. Not all categories are created equal, and the degree of agility and flexibility that can be supported is highly dependent on the category, the market conditions, the buyer’s experience, and urgency of the need. For example, you can’t be 1mm off in (electronics) hardware acquisition. But if the paper/posters are off 1mm from specs, who cares!

Mindset needs to be balanced between the reality that can crush you (and even bankrupt your organization on a bad, experimental, sourcing decision) and the future state you hope to some day achieve. While being too risk-averse can close off the discovery of great new suppliers with great new production methodologies, or great new software technologies to accelerate your Procurement (capability), being too experimental and open-minded can lead to decisions that ignore emerging risks that can result in supply lines suddenly disappearing, production lines going down, and losses in the tens of millions. In an age where geopolitical tensions are at an all time high, tariffs are materializing daily, sanctions are one retaliation away, shipping lanes are being cut off by terrorist activity (Red Sea) and lack of rainfall (Panama Canal), and your entire rare earths supply is one dictatorial decision away from disappearing, you have to be risk-centric in all your decisions. For critical products, you can’t increase risk if they are (primarily) sole-sourced (or primarily dependent on a sole-source somewhere downstream).

Technology is not about UX, because that ultimately comes down to UI for the majority of users, and that results in the prettiest system being selected. But you have to remember, it’s not about pretty, it’s about function, and if you want success, remember what the Northern Pikes told us 36 years ago when you’re selecting tech and being sold a flashy UI: she ain’t pretty, she just looks that way. You want something easy to use, but first and foremost it has to do what you need done. It HAS to support the process. UI/UX ONLY comes into play once the baseline functionality has been established. (And if someone won’t learn the necessary processes and systems required to ensure success, they should be replaced. That includes Chat-GPT addicts who prefer cognitive decline to actually trying to learn and improve!) Furthermore, the technology must be more than just configurable (using adaptive rules), but it must also be agentic so that, once appropriate rules are defined [and exception cases identified], it can run automatically so that, over time, the buyers spend less and less time on tactical tasks and more and more on strategic decision making, supplier development, and value generation and realization. Finally, it must not just be “connected” but be “concentric” and be built to be connectivity-first so that it can sit at the center of all of the organization systems that contain the data Procurement needs to do a proper analysis and make the right decisions.

Supplier Focus should definitely lean towards partnership and growth, but “partnership” and “growth” are nebulous and subjective and fuzzie-wuzzies don’t guarantee that the relationship is valuable to the buyer and definitely don’t provide a foundation for joint value growth for both parties over time. While there must be a joint commitment to improve, the focus needs to start with 360 performance measurement which become the foundation for jointly created and agreed upon development plans that will increase value, and it must continue with a constant eye out for risks and the development of mitigation and remediation plans should the risks become significant. It’s not about touchie-feelies, it’s about true value realization over time.

Finally, while the organization wants to be seen as an indispensable business partner, there’s no way that’s ever going to happen if it’s not seen as a source of value. And even if it is, considering Procurement is always going to come with process, overhead, and forced evaluation before a “preferred choice” can be selected, organizations like Marketing, IT, etc. are never going to see it as an IBP. But as long as the C-Suite sees it as a core source of value, it’s utilization is always going to be mandated!

In short, while theoretical perfect-world models are great in theory, and do a great job of giving us something we should want to strive for, success requires not forgetting the reality that surrounds us and in an age where free trade is crumbling, supply sources are at risk, and supply lines are crumbling. We have to be reality first to ensure supply, which has again become Procurement’s most critical function. Nothing else matters if there are no products or services to sell because critical supply sources/lines disappeared and Procurement wasn’t ready to replace them.

Dangerous Procurement Predictions Part III

As per our first two posts, if you read my predictions post, you know SI hates predictions posts. It fully despises them because the vast majority of these posts are pure optimistic fantasy and help no one. Why are the posts like this? Because no one wants to hear the sobering reality off of the bat in the new year and the influencers care more about clicks than actually helping you.

But the predictions are not only bad, they’re dangerous if you believe them. So we are continuing to lay bare the reality of the situation to make sure you understand that this year isn’t much different than last year, no miracles are coming, and only hard work and the application of your human intelligence are going to get you anywhere. Today we tackle the next three, and while we hope we’re getting close to the end of the series, we’re pretty sure there will be at least one more entry.

8. Global Trade Will Shift, Prioritizing Resilience Over Cost.

In the mid to long term some trade will shift to prioritize resilience, but most trade won’t. While defence procurements, critical mineral and material acquisitions for high-end electronics, and valuable commodities that can be traded like currency (such as gold, silver, platinum, diamonds, etc.) will be shifted for resilience, the reality is that, even with natural disasters, sanctions, trade wars, and actual wars, most companies aren’t going to make any changes to their supply chains (unless given absolutely no choice) because

  • finding new suppliers (in new countries) takes time and effort
  • qualifying new suppliers (in new countries) takes time and effort
  • identifying and contracting reliable carriers takes time and effort
  • building and securing new supply lines takes time and effort
  • etc.

and most companies are in constant fire-fighting mode, overworked, overstressed, and they just don’t have the time as long as the current supply chain, while strained, still works. Until their supply completely dries up, their primary production lines and revenue streams are threatened, and they have no other choice, they won’t change because they’ll keep telling themselves random natural disasters won’t impact them, the tariffs are only temporary, sanctions change with administrations, and wars eventually end.

9. Your employees will orchestrate outcomes.

Woody Woodpecker, take it away!

The level of talent needed to orchestrate outcomes is well beyond the average level of talent in an average (and even most above average) Procurement Department(s). There’s a reason that talent is a concern, a <href=”” target=_blank>top risk, and a top barrier for not just the last five years of studies and surveys, but at least the last ten. Talent has been scarce for a decade, and the situation is much worse since COVID. COVID saw many early retirements of the forced and chosen variety. Then the constant fears of recession saw more layoffs, starting with the highest paid (and most experienced) talent first. And you can be damn sure many of them are not coming back. We told you a year ago that talent is about to become scarce, and we’re sad to say we think we underestimated just how scarce talent is about to become.

And the reality is that only top talent can orchestrate outcomes. All the vast majority of talent can do is execute tasks one by one in a well-defined process. They can’t create new processes, and they certainly can’t define new outcome-centric processes on the fly. Especially when the ORCestration platforms they are given can’t even “orchestrate” a process to lead a mouse to the cheese it desperately wants.

10. New Year, New Me.

Who were you last year?

That’s right, the same person you are this year.

This BS lasts until all the bubbly you drank on New Year’s eve wears off, the rose coloured glasses go dim from the glare of doing the same damn thing as you stare at the same damn screen 12 hours a day, and you get overwhelmed with all the same tasks you were doing last year. Within two weeks at most, the new year, new me bullcr@p disappears with your last new years resolution and you’re just fighting to survive being overworked, understaffed, underfunded, and under-resourced, especially on the tech side (because the C-Suite wasted all the budget on a Big X Consultancy Gen-AI project that never even got to beta testing because the prototype phase never actually worked).

Most people won’t even make an effort to improve, which is the best one can hope for! (So if you have an employee who does, proactively give them a raise, any training they ask for, and keep them. Because, as per our response to the last false, and dangerous, prediction, talent is scarce and you should do whatever you can to keep whatever talent you have [instead of trying to replace it with fake AI that will never work fully autonomously].)

Dangerous Procurement Predictions Part II

As per our first post, if you read my predictions post, you know SI hates predictions posts. It fully despises them because the vast majority of these posts are pure optimistic fantasy and help no one. Why are the posts like this? Because no one wants to hear the sobering reality off of the bat in the new year and the influencers care more about clicks than actually helping you.

But the predictions are not only bad, they’re dangerous. And to make sure you don’t fall for them and make bad decision based on them, we’re going to tackle some of the most dangerous predictions, which include predictions that look innocuous at first glance (like the last prediction on how a big legacy suite will go out of business) but hide the dangerous consequences of what will actually happen if a big suite finds itself in big trouble. Today we tackle the next four, and you can be sure this won’t be the last post in our series. Feeds are still being flooded with prediction posts, and I’m done ignoring the insanity.

4. The jobs market will be tough for the first half of the year, but will start to pick up in Q3 and Q4.

The job market is tied to the economy, and everyone predicts the job market will rebound when the economy picks up. But here’s the thing. Even when the economy picks back up, the job market never does quite as well as the last time. And the economy isn’t going to magically improve half-way through the year. This is the exact same thing we’ve been told the last two years, and it hasn’t happened.

First off, most of the first world economies around the world are flat, borderline recession, or in recession. Secondly, the only thing propping the US economy up right now is AI, and the money circles keeping it afloat as all the AI, Hardware, and Software companies keep moving the same money around investing in each other to keep each other afloat. If the bubble bursts, the US is in trouble, and the economy will quickly flush itself down the toilet. And the job market will go with it.

Considering only the big tech giants who have been hoarding cash for the last few years are in good shape, and everyone else is trying to conserve cash to survive not only the current market but a potential recession, the last thing they are going to do is hire unless absolutely necessary to fill a critical role as a result of a departure. Remember, they’ve spent the last two years using AI as an excuse to lay people off and are always looking for the next excuse to lay people off, not hire them!

Jobs will continue to be super scarce, and only the best will have a chance to land one.

5. We’re in the early stages of a broader pushback (against unnecessary upgrades or technology investments).

A few companies smartening up and saying no to forced big provider upgrades, eight (8) figure consultancy projects, and big Gen-AI investments is not pushback. There have always been a few leaders who have broken away from the pack, did the math, and made the right decisions, but the pack is still charging ahead on Gen-AI. Every big software shop except IBM (who hired a CEO who can actually do math) has invested heavily in Gen-AI, which still loses four dollars for every dollar of revenue, despite any hopes of a real return in the near future and a 94% failure rate.

Let’s face reality. I warned this space about The Vendor In Black nineteen years ago and how he always Comes Back sixteen years ago, no one took heed then, and no one is taking heed now. The business model of the enterprise software space, which has not changed for the two decades I’ve been covering it, is to solve the problem created by the old sh!t by selling the customers the new sh!t that comes with new problems so they can sell even newer sh!t in three years to fix those (and so on). Same old story. Only the vendor names change.

6. We Won’t Buy Things; We’ll Orchestrate Ecosystems.

This prediction likely came straight from the A.S.S.H.O.L.E. and anyone who repeats it should be ashamed of themselves. There are no AI Employees. Claims to the contrary are false and anyone making those demeaning and degrading claims is simply dehumanizing you. And, as we have clearly explained, you definitely don’t want agentic buying because it will happily spend your money not only on stuff you don’t need but stuff that doesn’t exist and, if you’re super unlikely, stuff that is highly illegal. You need wood, it will buy up all the Minecraft wood because it’s cheap and call your problem solved. And that’s if you’re lucky. If you’re not, it will fulfill your resin need with an illegal purchase of hash (the drug) on the dark web (which is labelled resin so the poster can claim they never advertised an illegal drug). And so on.

Plus, as we have already noted, most of today’s “orchestration” platforms in Source-to-Pay are really ORCestration platforms and can barely connect a handful of major Source-to-Pay offerings. They’re nothing close to what is needed to orchestrate ecosystems.

7. Boards will Zero in on Supply Chain Security and Supplier Risk shifts from quarterly PowerPoints to continuous “signalops”.

Just like they won’t invest more in cybersecurity, they won’t invest more in supply chain security until they lose a shipment in the tens of millions. After all, they’ve got supply chain insurance, why should they care? Especially since their current security measures have been sufficient up until now.

But here’s the thing. When the economy goes down, jobs go down. And then two things happen. People get desperate and turn to crime. And criminals, when their investments in drugs, alcohol, gambling, prostitution, and other quasi-legal through illegal activities start losing money because unemployed people run out of money to spend on their vices, these criminals get desperate too — and high value theft becomes more attractive. A temporarily unguarded truck here. A container there. An entire warehouse. And so on.

If it’s critical raw materials they can move (like rare earths), in-demand finished electronics they can sell (like iPhones, where a single container will contain at least 20M worth), military equipment or weapon (component)s that are now in demand globally, they’ll take bigger and bigger chances, especially if there are weaknesses in security. It’s not just cyber attacks that are going to increase, it’s physical attacks, supply chains aren’t ready, and companies won’t even stop preparing them until they lose tens of millions, don’t recover it all through insurance, and risk losing their insurance entirely. No one likes the math of risk prevention because, when it works, you don’t see the return. Even though it’s so much cheaper than insurance! And that’s why, in the majority of organizations, nothing will change.